The Last of Us - Review Thread [Emargo up, scores in OP.]

Status
Not open for further replies.

Deadly Cyclone

Pride of Iowa State
Cheers!

tumblr_mnil0hpz561r863jjo6_1280.jpg

Where did you get this? I must have one.


Also, Sessler's review was great. Very low spoilers and a good overall context. I should hopefully be reviewing this soon, so we'll see how it compares.
 

MiKeD

Banned
Why the fuck is ign forcefully redirecting me one of their separate country websites. I don't want it in my language, I want the US version.
 

Jarmel

Banned
Where did you get this? I must have one.

Also, Sessler's review was great. Very low spoilers and a good overall context. I should hopefully be reviewing this soon, so we'll see how it compares.

I liked Sessler and Destructoid's view a lot as they highlighted issues with the AI that will probably be immersion breaking.
 
Why the fuck should I care about Naughty Dogs review scores? These are companies motivated by one thing, profit. Naughty Dog and Sony are NOT you're friends. They don't make games because they like you personally, they make games because it's an extremely profitable business for them.

Stop humanizing these corporations, they don't have your best interest in mind.
That's a very negative view of life. Sony may be a large corporation but naughty dog is a regular studio. They work hard and are passionate with what they do. You'd be surprised how many of them actually care about their work, what their fans think and how they can improve. Money isn't everything, despite popular belief.

There have been many examples where studios are driven by passion more then money. The people who made journey for example, probably quantum dream, oculus rift for sure, etc.

There are even gaffers that do game development who like to give a complete experience instead of locking content out for money like some publishers do. I am well aware of greedy corporations but not all companies are like that.
 

SpicyKeychain

Neo Member
Read that blurb from IGN and you've basically just read any review they've ever published. Glad to see other sites are quickly maturing past this style of writing.
 

Gadirok

Member
Wow this game is getting reviews higher than I thought it would get.

Was expecting 87/100ish before I read the playtesters thing, then I thought it was going to get a 92/100 tops.

I know I shouldn't talk about numbers, but it takes no genius to realize it does have an impact on commercial performance, hype etc etc.


Well, time to look at the merits of the game and see WHY it actually scored so high. For the record, I like Naughty Dog's games but I don't think many of them deserve the scores they got. Then again, I don't think any game on metacritic should deserve above a 90/100 average except Super Mario Galaxy 1 and LittleBIGplanet 2, and maybe Rayman Origins and a few more select games but to each his own I guess.


I'm having alot of entertainment reading a lot of people's comments with their confusion over Polygon's numbers, and also people flocking to jump on the people who are frustrated at Polygon. Theres always that same group of people no matter what game it is, defending and arguing over numerical values.

I wish that not just this industry, but others would assess merits based on what skills you have and how skilled it actually was, even a pros or cons list, rather than assessing by numerical values on a basis of 100. I mean I'm looking at movie scores on metacritic and I see a wide spectrum of scores for different movies, yet even when movies have poor critical performance people still go to see them. I think the problem here is, when a game scores less than 70 people immediately assume its shit. If Iron Man 3 was a game, hardly anyone would have bought it. People would have even been iffy on Star Trek: Into the Darkness which I just went to watch yesterday (great movie by the way).


On a more related note to the game, I saw the MP trailer last night. Wasn't exactly happy as I was expecting a mode involving clickers but it seems like Sony is going to take this to the bank all the way with extra dlc modes in the coming months. I don't blame them as its looking like its going to be a commercial and critical success. So looks like that mode with infected will probably launch once the game is done and settled.
 

Salsa

Member
that cup is terrible guys what's wrong with you

- super small, holds very little liquid

- handle is awful

The Last of Us Cup revew thread:

2/10
 

Leeroy605

Member
Being primarily a pc gamer who is used to getting the latest releases for under £20, I told myself I would never buy a full priced console release at launch and wait till the inevitable price drop two or three months down the line...

I just preordered this and I don't even care, seems as though it's one worth paying full whack for.
 

ERC198X

Banned
FANTASTIC SCORES!!!

This is the surefire GOTY!

can't wait to get my greasy hands on this epic

Also, LOL at polygon review
 

jufonuk

not tag worthy
When this drops in price, I am getting this for my bro on his ps3, for him to play ok, we'll maybe he can watch me play
 

sleepykyo

Member
Not to say anything about this game, but maybe i'm just cynical but does it feel like certain developers have cracked the whole games reviewing system?

Like some magic sauce that makes your 8-8.5 game to a 10/10 reviewed game.

something about pressing the right buttons for your typical hyperbole spewing reviewer.


hmmmm...

next gen is gonna be interesting.

Naughty Dog, Bethseda and Ninja Theory. Also make statements about elevating the writing in games or how the industry wanted to x female out of the game/off the cover. Anything to allow the reviewer to think their shilling contributes to a greater good/sense of legitmacy,
 

N30RYU

Member
OMG I found a bug in the demo... when you finish the last section and kill all the foes, the demo ends... but if you pause the game and choose to restar the last check point you can continue palying past the last area!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 

Represent.

Represent(ative) of bad opinions
They should have released this game a week earlier.

Cant wait another week. Gonna search around in local Mom & Pop shops.

If anyone sees the game for sale anywhere in Toronto (entire GTA), drop me a PM or something.
 

Radec

Member
I hope anyone who spoils the game in the OT gets instabanned so hard he can't even post in the Neogaf Facebook Page.
 

Boss Man

Member
Naughty Dog, Bethseda and Ninja Theory. Also make statements about elevating the writing in games or how the industry wanted to x female out of the game/off the cover. Anything to allow the reviewer to think their shilling contributes to a greater good/sense of legitmacy,
There might actually be something to this. Part of the reason why the critic reviews and user reviews on Metacritic seems so distanced and random.
 

Sn4ke_911

If I ever post something in Japanese which I don't understand, please BAN me.
OMG I found a bug in the demo... when you finish the last section and kill all the foes, the demo ends... but if you pause the game and choose to restar the last check point you can continue palying past the last area!!!!!!!!!!!!!

There was a thread about that.
 

Andrew.

Banned
OMG I found a bug in the demo... when you finish the last section and kill all the foes, the demo ends... but if you pause the game and choose to restar the last check point you can continue palying past the last area!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Old news brah.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom