Yeah, if they lean more towards metal than hardcore, they're considered metal.Metalcore is a fusion of two genres: Core and metal.
Some metalcore bands are more core than metal while some are definitely metal.
Plenty of metalcore bands on Metal Archives as well.
If you don't think that atmosphere is an integral part of metal, I don't know what to tell you. I said nothing about speedy tremolo, plenty of great metal without tremolo picking of any kind.I totally agree. Metal isn't just dark atmosphere and speedy tremolo.
And the bolded is straight toe-tappin.
I understand why dismissing bands based on a tag is a stupid thing to do. I'm not doing that. I can enjoy BtBAM, but can't stand Dillinger Escape Plan or Protest the Hero. That's just my personal taste. Metal differs from other genres in that the fans and the community are very picky, and dictate the genre and culture to an extent unlike any other music community.I just see it as a huge disservice to both people looking for new music and for your own ears to be dismissing bands based on a tag. There are generic bands in all genres, but considering the amount of influences a band can display despite being listed as a specific genre, trying to say a band is/isn't metal seems absurd to me - especially when the genre in question has the word metal in its name.
The sounds you're trying to distinguish as metal and non-metal aren't as far apart as you make them seem, and you come off as confusing "most metalheads" with "people that also think like me." If what you wrote is your definition of metal music, a number of bands (that aren't labeled metalcore) don't meet the criteria despite being, without a doubt, metal.
To show you how absurd this all seems to me (from wikipedia):
By your thinking, metal isn't even metal even though it has metal in the name - it's all just rock anyways.
I think the music world knows more than the "metal community" - metalcore is metal. And ultimately, comments like Tess3ract's (he was even completely wrong at labeling the band) and yours should have no place here because we've all used different genres of music as gateways into new forms of music. Running this thread by "the metal archive standard" stifles discussion of an extremely diverse genre.
Exactly. The tree is as big as you make it.
The differences I detailed are pretty clear cut. Metalcore and metal are too completely different beasts, and people can like both, or just one, whatever sounds good to their ears. But it's my opinion that they should be treated as entirely different, because they do have huge differences.
I feel like I'm missing your point on the Wikipedia thing, metal is obviously derived from rock, but it has obviously become a completely different thing. I do understand how ridiculous this is to you though, I imagine it's painfully irritating to hear from elitists that metalcore sucks because it isn't "brutal" enough or whatever. Genres and music can't objectively be bad, but certain subgenres aren't for everybody. I will never enjoy breakdowns and autotuned choruses, they just are not enjoyable for me. But I understand why people into Black Dahlia Murder of Killswitch Engage or The Devil Wears Prada won't ever enjoy the Immortal and Darkthrone albums that I love. And that's fine.
Tess3ract's screamo comment was incorrect, and I can't stand people just branding everything they don't like as screamo, so I get that that post was misguided. I like the spirit of your post, but at the same time, I'm sure you can understand why I feel that metalcore differs so much to metal that it is an entirely separate entity. Where does it end? Do we start talking about nu-metal, or Attack Attack!, or Whitechapel? In all honesty, if I hadn't just had a conversation on this same thing on Facebook after someone posted C'est La Vie and dubbed it "the best kind of metal" earlier that day, there's no way I would have started this conversation at all. I deal with people like that on a regular basis, much like you deal with stupid, quibbling metal elitists like myself, and that's why our opinions differ so heavily. For every mouthbreathing metal-archives moron you deal with, I deal with someone who just listens to metalcore or mallcore, but dubs it metal. Thus, I get recommendations for A Day To Remember because someone "heard I like metal too," and it drives me crazy.
This will be my last post on this subject, because I'm shitting up a great thread for an argument that is doing more harm than what I'm arguing against in terms of taking too much thread space. If you or anyone else with an opposing viewpoint want to take this to PM's, I'd be more than happy to do so.