First I really appreciate you taking the time to post all that. Even though I disagree its great to see where your coming from.
As far as the human archer section I'm not locking on. You know how Geralt automatically centers to face the closest threat. Thats what I mean. I can't just run toward the arrow guy dodging everyone around me. Its like I'm waltzing with each enemy till I can get close enough to strike.
I can understand people liking the slow pace of the combat but imo its a terrible system and shows that CDRP have no idea what they are doing when it actually comes to the mechanics of these games. I was just watching some Witcher 2 combat videos and it looks really similar to W3 so it looks like they are just sticking to their guns with this.
Thanks for the response, too, man.
I think the dichotomy here might be that I enjoy the 'role playing' aspect of doing what Geralt would do, whereas you're looking at the combat more from an outside perspective of action game mechanics.
TW3's combat is not pretty, it's borderline janky, but it's so deep and broadly logical that you really have to
become Geralt to succeed at it. Basically the combat is designed to simulate Geralt. It's not designed to simulate 'good' combat.
The Witcher 2 had it far worse. It has more jank than TW3 and a lot less depth. Still a great game, but it's more like a great work of literature.
Just want to chime in to say that I agree with you regarding the combat. The length of animation to get a hit clearly depends on my positioning relative to the creature I am fighting. I prefer this to an immediate response swing which would have caused me to swing and miss.
When there are groups, it comes down to positioning again. I try to align myself so that I place three or four enemies in a 45 degree V in front of me and use Igni. If the enemies are the "teleporting type", I usually use Yrden and position myself with my back to it but out of the range of anything that could get trapped in it. If all else fails, I use Aard and run away.
Thanks for the solidarity! Think I got to the crux of it with ev, though. Different expectations I guess.