• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt |OT2| Wanted to find Ciri, but everything Gwent wrong

Status
Not open for further replies.

jett

D-Member
But thats not possible I thought.

You either save the orphans or Baron and Anna. Cant save both. What choices did you make?

I think
You must free the spirit before you visit the orphans
, but I'm not completely sure. I've heard others get the same result.

You can do it if you free the tree spirit BEFORE meeting the ladies. Apparently. Not sure if a bug in the quest logic or if CDPR intended this hidden outcome.

I do believe I
might have freed the spirit before meeting the ladies, maybe. I'm not sure on that, but I know I stumbled upon the spirit's cave by accident before initiating the questline properly.

Man, this third act is really poor compared to the previous two. I feel like the game should have finished at
the fight at Kaer Morhen.

Agreed 100%.
 
Well, it is not that simple.

You are not simply choosing between the orphans and the baron's family.

The baron's family is sad, true. But the actual worst part is that you basically condemned the whole village of Downwarren. They do serve the Crones sure, but what else they can do? They have to fend for themselves so they have to submit to whoever ruling the area. By helping like 5 orphans, the whole village is destroyed, all the villagers got crazy and killed each other along with all the kids there.

I am not saying you make the wrong choice, sure you can feel more attached to the orphans because you have more interactions with them but that doesn't make the truth any less worse.

I love the orphans, but letting them die and save the whole village with their inhabitants in my opinion is the lesser of 2 evils.

Another Thing is,
that after the Baron is dead, his Sergeant and his former Henchmen harassing the whole vicinity of Crow's Perch.

On a second read through, this has nothing to do with the above quest,
because the outcome with the Henchmen is the same.
My Bad.
 
I never played witcher 1 and 2, but picked up 3 last night. Its good but i don't understand whats going on really. Does anyone know of any youtube videos for people in my situation that recap 1 and 2?
 
If Ciri is alive, it's good. Presumed dead, it's bad.

Also,
The best ending is supposed to be when she goes back to Nilfgaard, but I like having her stay with Gerald.

presumed dead by all except geralt, she was at the bar in white orchard

Is that bad?
 
Isn't mutagen conversion straight up impossible right now? I finally have enough lessers to put a greater red in my second combat branch but now I can't make one!

I'm kinda annoyed with it because in order to brew Superior Swallow (I think it was), I need to make 2x Vitriol and the game will only allow me to make one right now. I have all of the stuff needed for all of these potions and I can't make them... Doesn't help that I found like 20-30 new recipes last night.

Not impossible but it's a pain: you have to craft, drop it on the ground, craft , drop etc until you have all you need and then pick them up.
 

SomTervo

Member
Not impossible but it's a pain: you have to craft, drop it on the ground, craft , drop etc until you have all you need and then pick them up.

I missed the start of this conversation – what is the situation here? I noticed I'm struggling to make red mutagens even though, IIRC, i've got a few in my stash

Geralt needs a stash. I'm out of space constantly.

In Skellige I just found a +100 inventory space saddlebag

From the blacksmith's wife in Crow's Perch you can get + 60 or 70 I think.

If you're really struggling just find an empty house near a fast-travel point and drop your unwanted shit. It'll stay there forever. Call it home.
 

Sub Zero

his body's cold as ice, but he's got a heart of gold
Act 2 question

J
ust heading to the Isle of mists after recruiting all possible allies. I thought you could recruit Triss as well, I did her personal quest and she left with the other mages, I didn't get an option to ask her to go to Kaehr Moren. Did I miss anything or does she go to Kaehr Moren by default?
Also how far am I into the game?
 

Flipyap

Member
Also,
The best ending is supposed to be when she goes back to Nilfgaard, but I like having her stay with Gerald.
Nah, the witcher ending is the "best" one, because that's the one you get for sticking by her side all the way through.
The empress one requires you to disappoint her by at least taking her to see Duny The Hedgehog Emhyr.

But it's not like the bad ending is without merit. It has some of the best cinematography in the game and what could have been the best characterization of Geralt if the writing were a bit better in those scenes.
 

MayMay

Banned
Finished the game just now.
Good
ending,
Ciri becomes a Witcher.

Man, what a ride. Took me around 80 hours and I still got lots of contracts and sidequests..

I was sure of it after the first 10 hours, but this is definitely my favourite game of all time.
 

DToneli

Neo Member
I missed the start of this conversation – what is the situation here? I noticed I'm struggling to make red mutagens even though, IIRC, i've got a few in my stash



In Skellige I just found a +100 inventory space saddlebag

From the blacksmith's wife in Crow's Perch you can get + 60 or 70 I think.

If you're really struggling just find an empty house near a fast-travel point and drop your unwanted shit. It'll stay there forever. Call it home.

You can buy a +100 saddlebag from a vendor in Novigrad, he is close to the entrance to the "poor part of the city" where you have to knock on a door to get in
It costs 900 crowns, so it is a blessing to find it
 

TheFatMan

Member
Act 2 question

J
ust heading to the Isle of mists after recruiting all possible allies. I thought you could recruit Triss as well, I did her personal quest and she left with the other mages, I didn't get an option to ask her to go to Kaehr Moren. Did I miss anything or does she go to Kaehr Moren by default?
Also how far am I into the game?

You can stop her from getting on the boat if you tell her you love her. Then she will be at Kaer Moren. I'm sure there is another way to do it as well.
 
Nah, the witcher ending is the "best" one, because that's the one you get for sticking by her side all the way through.
The empress one requires you to disappoint her by at least taking her to see Duny The Hedgehog Emhyr.

But it's not like the bad ending is without merit. It has some of the best cinematography in the game and what could have been the best characterization of Geralt if the writing were a bit better in those scenes.
Wrong.
Visiting the emperor opens up Choice #2, but it doesn't give a negative effect on the ending as long as you choose not to accept the gold from Emhyr.Meaning if you don't kill Radovid, you can still have the Witcher ending like I did.
Positive Ending – Ciri is Empress

During Blood on the Battlefield, Ciri asked you to go after Imlerith, and you had the option of agreeing, or going to see the emperor first. If you chose to see the emperor, it opened up Something Ends, Something Begins II as a possible ending. The key here is that you still have to have more positive choices than negative, Radovid must be dead, and you must have sided with Roche and Thaler.

Source: http://www.usgamer.net/articles/the-witcher-3-endings-fates-of-ciri-and-geralt

After reading on that ending, I also think the one where
ciri ends ups being empress is the better one.
 
Act 2 question

J
ust heading to the Isle of mists after recruiting all possible allies. I thought you could recruit Triss as well, I did her personal quest and she left with the other mages, I didn't get an option to ask her to go to Kaehr Moren. Did I miss anything or does she go to Kaehr Moren by default?
Also how far am I into the game?

There was an dialog choice for
Triss to stay, in the cutscene where you both say goodbye.
 

Cyborg

Member
Broken Flowers mission was an unbalanced part of the game (regarding XP)

I dont get it why they gave me so much XP for only running and talking to some people, it was just strange. It boosted my level by a lot due to that I couldnt get XP's from other missions.
 
Broken Flowers mission was an unbalanced part of the game (regarding XP)

I dont get it why they gave me so much XP for only running and talking to some people, it was just strange. It boosted my level by a lot due to that I couldnt get XP's from other missions.

For real. 450XP. I was shocked. Teetering on 12 at this point.
 

Trojan

Member
Broken Flowers mission was an unbalanced part of the game (regarding XP)

I dont get it why they gave me so much XP for only running and talking to some people, it was just strange. It boosted my level by a lot due to that I couldnt get XP's from other missions.

*Sets reminder on calendar to play Broken Flowers mission tonight
 

Flipyap

Member
Wrong.
Visiting the emperor opens up Choice #2, but it doesn't give a negative effect on the ending as long as you choose not to accept the gold from Emhyr.Meaning if you don't kill Radovid, you can still have the Witcher ending like I did.

Source: http://www.usgamer.net/articles/the-witcher-3-endings-fates-of-ciri-and-geralt

After reading on that ending, I also think the one where
ciri ends ups being empress is the better one.
Oh, that's good to know.
Making that a timed choice seemed kinda unfair, but I guess it's not so bad if it doesn't lock you into an ending.

I disagree about it being the better ending,
because it sounds rather out of character and it completely robs her of the "ending" she already got in the novels, unlike the witcher ending which at least restores one thing she seemed to be quite satisfied with.
 

omgkitty

Member
Do the Axii upgrades have to be equipped in order to get perks in conversations? Should I go ahead and max out all the axii upgrades available to keep getting the conversation perks to work on a higher level for end game conversations?
 

Applesauce

Boom! Bitch-slapped!
Broken Flowers mission was an unbalanced part of the game (regarding XP)

I dont get it why they gave me so much XP for only running and talking to some people, it was just strange. It boosted my level by a lot due to that I couldnt get XP's from other missions.

It felt like leveling up went too quickly once I started doing quests in Novigrad, like around level 10ish. Now at level 30 and everything is really easy, plus I got a shit load of side quests that have been grayed out. Wish they did a better job at scaling enemy levels as you progress, fighting a group of level 13 drowners or white wolves isn't even worth drawing my sword for anymore. I will occasionally get that level 29 mini-boss but even those aren't all that hard. I suppose I should just up the difficulty level.
 
Guys, am I progressing too fast?

Early game:

Just got to Velen and went to find that Hendrick guy. The recommended level for the next part of the main quest (finding either the Baron or the Witch) is level 6/7, but I'm only a high level 3. Should I slow down my pace?
 
Guys, am I progressing too fast?

Early game:

Just got to Velen and went to find that Hendrick guy. The recommended level for the next part of the main quest (finding either the Baron or the Witch) is level 6/7, but I'm only a high level 3. Should I slow down my pace?

I would say, slow down on the main quests. Don't miss out on those side quests and contracts. They have depth and you'll find yourself over leveled for the main quest after a few of them.
 

omgkitty

Member
Broken Flowers mission was an unbalanced part of the game (regarding XP)

I dont get it why they gave me so much XP for only running and talking to some people, it was just strange. It boosted my level by a lot due to that I couldnt get XP's from other missions.

Yeah you got 500 for doing the first part, and then 150 each for each of the girls. I don't know, I kinda liked it. I was thinking of going to Skellige and that said I needed to be 16, and I'm still not there yet. For getting a boat, one of the areas has the big yellow circle around it, and there's a captain on the boat looking out, but when I talk to him he tells me to go away. The only other one I found wants 1000 crowns. Any ideas?
 
I would say, slow down on the main quests. Don't miss out on those side quests and contracts. They have depth and you'll find yourself over leveled for the main quest after a few of them.

Yeah, I'm enjoying the side quests that I've come across. Location wise, where should I be headed for my level/this early on?
 
Yeah, I'm enjoying the side quests that I've come across. Location wise, where should I be headed for my level/this early on?

All of Velen is fine if you ask me. I would wait with Novigrad (I didn't go there until I was done with all main quests and all non-top-level-side quests in Velen). Go to some nearby village and check the message board for contracts and quests, then just do whatever is closest to your level. There are tons.
 
Guys, am I progressing too fast?

Early game:

Just got to Velen and went to find that Hendrick guy. The recommended level for the next part of the main quest (finding either the Baron or the Witch) is level 6/7, but I'm only a high level 3. Should I slow down my pace?

You'll catch up and pass that soon enough. Being 5 levels below whatever you're doing is still ok
 

TheKeyPit

Banned
I want to start "Isle
of Mists
", but first I'd like to finish the sub-quest "
Brothers in Arms: Novigrad
". Still have the problem that I can't start "Eye for an Eye" because of
Roche
not appearing at Hanged Man's Tree. Will have to wait for the patch to finally arrive :(
 
I played Cerys' quest last night and for a lot of nothing, that was a nice and enjoyable quest line. More enjoyable than her brother's.

Oh and that sidequest to get
Iorveth's Gwent card...LOL...getting tricked to break a druid's vow of silence by his fellow druid.
. CDPR, you cheeky bastards.
 
So I finally finished the game this morning. I have no idea how many hours I put in, better part of 2 weeks, about an hour or 2 each of the week days and id estimate about 12 over the course of the weekends. finished at level 30.

I really enjoyed my time with this game. I dont have much a desire to go back in and finish up the quests I missed but it was good adventure, lots of laughs, emotions, and fun. Best part is, it finally broke my Destiny addiction which has plagued make since release. i loved playing Destiny with gaffers but felt compforted in just going on an epic adventure on my own. Felt good.

just some critques:
-graphics are hit and miss.
Some times thsi game looks photo realistic. I remember riding up to the barons house just as the sun was comming up over the ridge practically blinding me. The light refected on the puddles in the dirt. some parts of the day looking over the hills are breathe taking. Skellige is espacally good looking However most time at night or in the cities (Novigrad especailly were so bland looking) seemed off, like the game lost all processing power and looked like a PS3 game at times. I think it looked great for the most part, but I just wonder what happened in certain areas.

-overwhelming crafting system
I wouldnt call myself a casual gamer, but compared to some of you I might as well be a 3 year old swinging at trees lol. theamount of things you can pick up, dismantling for more things, the huge inventory of items it was overwheling, so much so I stayed away from it for most of the game. I ended up trying to go after some
wicther armor
I chose the
feline gear set
and had to craft at that point. it probably took the better part of an hour or more to try and figure out what I already had, what it could be borken down into, what I would need to craft to make something that I needed to craft something else. I had to bust out a notepad to keep track of it all. I have frerinds who love this sort of thing in games to me it was alot of work. if there was an easier way to catologue and sort what you had it wouldnt be so bad.
 
ladies of the woods.

I dont know
whether to help the tree or not, what is the best outcome here?

I was in the same predicament, I really didn't feel that I had enough information to make a reasoned decision, I think it was more damned if you do, damned if you don't :-/

Arrrghh this is driving me nuts, I cant decide!

Actually, there is a book that you can find before you do this quest. I don't remember where I found it. But this is what it says.

Edit: Whoops, wrong link. Let me find the right one.

Edit 2: Can't find a link, will take a screen shot once I get home. The book is called "She Who Knows".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom