I play most modern games on my PC with the Xbox360 gamepad and in most cases the controls and handling is fine, but I just can't play W3 with it - M+K is way, way more better for me personally and it controls really good - handling of Roach is perfectly fine just like the swimming controls & combat and menus are great.. some problems are only when Geralt is in a building but other than that, I'm glad how the M+K controls are in this game