• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt |OT2| Wanted to find Ciri, but everything Gwent wrong

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hmm.. So I am on the ps4. I examine the body and the arm is of and he says it could be the arm the bracelet was on. Other than that I can jump in the well... But don't see anything else around the well. I saw where I have to burn the bracelet but where?

When I played the quest the other day I found a bracelet in one of the houses but obviously it wasn't the correct one. Is this where you found the bracelet because if so it's not the right one.
 

Acorn

Member
Any reason i should simulate a witcher 2 save? Any cool content or stuff i miss out on if i don't do it?

I have all 3 games but haven't completed any for reference and can't remember shit.
 

VE3TRO

Formerly Gizmowned
Got a question. I bought a couple of ingame books for about 70 crowns each (which was most of my wallet at the time). I thought they related to crafting/repairing stuff and might offer me a bonus to said disciplines. They don't appear to. Are these types of books just lore fluff (expensive lore fluff at that) or am I missing something?

Make sure to read all of them then once thats done sell.
 

Isendurl

Banned
So, I guess this game is selling well huh?

Sn_mek_obrazovky_15.png
 

Garibaldi

Member
Think it's just for lore. There's tons of normal books you can buy that are just for reading.

Ah that's disappointing. Wasted a fair bit of wedge to learn you use a whetstone to keep a blade sharp. Which is kind of useless even lore wise. I could have used that cash to buy some upgrade mats. Never mind.
 

phaze

Member
This alchemist near Novigrad has way too little money. Buy everything from me goddamit. And bastard doesn't even want to talk to me most of the time.
 

Cathcart

Member
Is it really necessary to keep the starting Witcher gear, as people were saying last week? The Kaer Morhen armour is used for a fairly rubbish leather jacket and the starting swords don't seem to matter for any of the other Witcher recipes I've found so far.

Nah. Later on you may find plans for armor sets from the various witcher schools. For instance, there's a set of light armor plans from the Cat school. That armor can be upgraded, at least 3 more times. To do the upgrade you need the previous version of the armor plus some other stuff.

So if you craft other witcher gear hold onto it. There may have been plans to upgrade the starting armor but I haven't found it and I prefer the light armor anyway (starter is medium).
 

aravuus

Member
Yeah, some of these are good points, but I think most of these absences boil down to CDPR intelligently clipping things which wouldn't fit Geralt's character and how they would represent his story and world.

He didn't say TW3 needed any of those things, in fact, the post literally says they aren't criticisms. He's merely pointing out that TW3 and Bethesda RPGs are different open-world RPGs, the world has room for both of them.

e: well, looks like seanspeed himself replied to you already

But yeah, TW3 is missing a bunch of stuff. It's still fucking great and aside from FO: NV, so far a much better game than any of the Gamebryo games.
 

It asks you the choices you made in those games. It changes whether some characters are alive or dead during the Witcher 3, meaning you can possibly miss out on side quests. I never played the other games but I went ahead and did it. Since I didn't know any of the characters I looked them up and decided from there if I wanted them alive or dead.
 

Braag

Member
I wonder why the Wolf and Viper schools don't have armor sets of their own :(
Geralt's default set could have been the wolf school set which you'd need to enhance.
Hopefully via DLC then :p
 

Acorn

Member
It asks you the choices you made in those games. It changes whether some characters are alive or dead during the Witcher 3, meaning you can possibly miss out on side quests. I never played the other games but I went ahead and did it. Since I didn't know any of the characters I looked them up and decided from there if I wanted them alive or dead.

Yeah go for it. Early on in the game you will be asked some questions regarding choices you made in the past. Just select what you prefer even if you can't remember.
Alright thanks guys. What are the default choices anyway?
 

Garibaldi

Member
No, books aren't just for lore. Not all books do something, but many of them give you stuff like bestiary entries and undiscovered locations.

That's the sort of thing I thought it would do. Add a bestiary entry or a crafting schematic or something. Especially since at the time it was a large amount of my cash. Alas the fine merchant in Velen exploited my curiosity and lightened my wallet.
 

brau

Member
So this is a dead end for now? Good to know, time to uncover the other 34 interesting locations on my map lol

Usually those are just walls that uncover and exit. After going through a cave or something. You get that talisman pretty early on, so just do some quests and you'll get it.
 

neorej

ERMYGERD!
I'm leaving for a vacation next week and I can't bring my rig. Are the books worth reading and not spoilery for Witcher 3 Wild Hunt?
 

SomTervo

Member
I'm not asking for TW3 to have these things. I think you missed where I said they aren't criticisms. They each do things differently enough that I can enjoy both is all.

Sorry, I did pick up what you meant. Wasn't right when I said 'criticisms'. I suppose my point was that everything in TW3 is so well justified that these things would probably detract from it in various ways. Whereas even in Skyrim a lot of stuff feels unnecessary or like filler. I agree with you that both do things very well – though I strongly believe TW3 is greater than any of the Elder Scrolls games (maybe not Morrowind but I never got into that enough to know properly).

He didn't say TW3 needed any of those things, in fact, the post literally says they aren't criticisms. He's merely pointing out that TW3 and Bethesda RPGs are different open-world RPGs, the world has room for both of them.

e: well, looks like seanspeed himself replied to you already

But yeah, TW3 is missing a bunch of stuff. It's still fucking great and aside from FO: NV, so far a much better game than any of the Gamebryo games.

Yeah got back saying as much, my bad. However I don't feel TW3 is missing anything really. Perhaps it would benefit from an external storage system, even something simple like a chest at an inn or whatever, like Dragon's Dogma.

I personally believe practically everything in the game is in its perfect place and that if they added anything significant (eg stealth, first person, houses) the game as a whole would suffer.

This isn't to say that they can't pull something like stealth off in a later game. I mainly mean that in this specific title's case, they were obviously pushed for resources already, and putting more features in like this might have detracted from quality elsewhere/overall.
 

phaze

Member
I'm leaving for a vacation next week and I can't bring my rig. Are the books worth reading and not spoilery for Witcher 3 Wild Hunt?

No but the games, Wild Hunt in particular spoil a whole lot from the books. To be expected since they take place after them.
 

ukas

Member
Alright thanks guys. What are the default choices anyway?

Strategy Guide information regarding the choices and what they mean in the Witcher 3.

Arjan LaValette
If you killed Arjan LaValette (PC save game), or tell Voorhis you did (PC, consoles without save game), your interactions with a woman named Molly are different during Main Quest: Broken Flowers.

The path of Roche or Iorveth
This only effects a very small conversation choice during Main Quest: Get Junior, when you visit Roche’s camp for the first time.

Sile de Tansarville
If you allowed her to die (PC save game) or tell Voorhis this (PC, consoles without save game), she does not appear during Main Quest: The Great Escape.

The Witcher Letho
Answer any questions and mention Letho is still alive, and Secondary Quest: Ghosts of the Past, becomes active later.
Mention that Letho is dead, or ignore the conversation, and Secondary Quest: Ghosts of the Past cannot be accessed.
 
Homes that come up with ' needs key'. I'm assuming this mean someone is carrying the key around with them in the game. Has anyone managed to find a key?
 

aku:jiki

Member
Random encounters. Whether enemies or NPC's. Everything in TW3 seems placed very specifically. Enemies stick to assigned little zones and there aren't any dynamic events ever.
Fair enough. Most of those things aren't compelling to me, but I recognize that you didn't say that they would be.

I hope you're planning on reading Sword of Destiny in there somewhere, too.
Yeah, it's just that it's more expensive since it just came out (that publisher's version anyway) and I have to finish another trilogy first anyway.
 

faer0n

Member
Archers are too OP in this game. I mean, we're talking about homing arrows that take off a quarter of your health at a time. Will the deflection parry cure my ailment?

the alternate yrden destroys all arrows or u could brainwash them and let them kill the others
 
I mean if you're a dirt poor peasant with little to look forward to, would you try to stop a mutant Witcher with 2 swords on his back from taking what meager belongings you have in your house? Now if guards didn't react to my looting I would be a little annoyed.

If anything Skyrim was similar since you could just put buckets on NPCs heads and literally rob them blind. That or just grab the item by holding E and taking it to where the NPC can't see and then looting it. Then sometimes you would steal something and since a chicken or dog saw you now the entire town wants you dead.



To be fair, Skyrims dungeons were very literal copy paste drauger infested nonsense. Either that or the Dwemer variant with a couple unique ones here and there. Your other points, especially about first person are spot on though.

I got bored of Skyrim, and yeah, the dungeons were partly why. Just copy pasted, it felt like.

I felt Fallout was constantly rewarding on the other hand. Maybe it was just the atmosphere and setting, but vaults always had an interesting and eerie backstory, and it was fun to explore huge creepy buildings.

What's it like in Witcher? Lots of dungeons or caves or something?
 

Pancakes

hot, steaming, as melted butter slips into the cracks, drizzled with sticky sweet syrup OH GOD
is there any reason to go back to the imperial palace? I'm currently
searching for dandelion in novigrad

Not really, unless you were like me and wanted to get revenge on that snobby Nilfgardian noble who I couldn't beat in the beginning at Gwent.
 

Acorn

Member
Strategy Guide information regarding the choices and what they mean in the Witcher 3.

Arjan LaValette
If you killed Arjan LaValette (PC save game), or tell Voorhis you did (PC, consoles without save game), your interactions with a woman named Molly are different during Main Quest: Broken Flowers.

The path of Roche or Iorveth
This only effects a very small conversation choice during Main Quest: Get Junior, when you visit Roche’s camp for the first time.

Sile de Tansarville
If you allowed her to die (PC save game) or tell Voorhis this (PC, consoles without save game), she does not appear during Main Quest: The Great Escape.

The Witcher Letho
Answer any questions and mention Letho is still alive, and Secondary Quest: Ghosts of the Past, becomes active later.
Mention that Letho is dead, or ignore the conversation, and Secondary Quest: Ghosts of the Past cannot be accessed.
Thank you!
 

aravuus

Member
Wish there was a mod to increase the witcher's senses sensing radius or something. At first they didn't bother me nearly as much as they seemed to bother some people, but I'm slowly starting to get sick of the "here's a circular area, go through every nook and cranny with your witcher's senses" parts of many of the quests.
 

Caja 117

Member
I finally finished the prologue yesterday (Dont burn me, Im playing at my pace to savor the game), and my take so far:

-The combat, Im sorry but whoever is saying the combat is, Slugish, bad, unresponsive, etc, I think they are doing it wrong, the combat mechanics are excellent, it plays way better than the Witcher 2, and just like the Witcher 2 its not just a hack and slash type of combat, you need to understand your situation before attacking a group of people/monsters, I usually lure monster one by one to tackle them, and when fighting humans always take out archer first which so far get killed with one attack.

Of course not everything in the combat is perfect, I cuuld had liked the camera to be closer to Geralt during combat. I also not sold on the decision on using slots to decide what abilities are active.

-Storytelling is still as good as before, very immersive in whats going on, the conclusion to the epilogue was impressive for me and the audience wit Tyw... Emyr was as epic as I imagined it was going to be.

-Im still at awe at the vastness of the world maps, the new area that Just opened contained what it looked like (at least) 2 Flotsam sized towns.

-The Graphic on this game are really nice and colorful, and just as I started the second area, a rain storm started and the gloom that comes with a rainstorm was nicely simulated in the game.

Thats my take so far, I basically did every sidequest and Point of Interest in White Orchard, but Im contemplating in turning of the Point of Interest marks in the map to have a more immersive experience.
 

RDreamer

Member
Fair enough. Most of those things aren't compelling to me, but I recognize that you didn't say that they would be.

Yeah, it's just that it's more expensive since it just came out (that publisher's version anyway) and I have to finish another trilogy first anyway.

That's good, because it's definitely a good one, and it should be read before the saga books (so, after The Last Wish and before Blood of Elves, etc)
 

Aces&Eights

Member
Homes that come up with ' needs key'. I'm assuming this mean someone is carrying the key around with them in the game. Has anyone managed to find a key?

I have found keys but they never open the door close to where I am. I have no idea how that all works, lol. I really want in some of the houses that are locked. My only thoughts are they are quest related so I cannot enter until I start the quest.
 

Hobiologe

Member
I almost have the feeling, the downgrade was good for the game or let's say, the best what could happen for this game. Because without this impressive reveal- and target trailers this game wouldn't have received this huge awareness over the years, respectively couldn't have achieved its final budget.

That's why I can live with this downgrade, especially as a console gamer. This game is so huge, so impressive, this amazing atmosphere and graphics, especially this love of detail and every single sidequest or random event is much better than standard mainquests of "comparable" RPGs.

I admit, I was also a bit upset about CDPR about their communication and marketing tricks, but after hours of spending with this game I just can praise CDPR and wish them to sell millions of it. And honestly speaking, I'm pretty much OK with the same "downgrade" procedure for (hopefully) The Witcher 4, when the outcome is again such a gem.
 

Caja 117

Member
I almost have the feeling, the downgrade was good for the game or let's say, the best what could happen for this game. Because without this impressive reveal- and target trailers this game wouldn't have received this huge awareness over the years, respectively couldn't have achieved its final budget.

That's why I can live with this downgrade, especially as a console gamer. This game is so huge, so impressive, this amazing atmosphere and graphics, especially this love of detail and every single sidequest or random event is much better than standard mainquests of "comparable" RPGs.

I admit, I was also a bit upset about CDPR about their communication and marketing tricks, but after hours of spending with this game I just can praise CDPR and wish them to sell millions of it. And honestly speaking, I'm pretty much OK with the same "downgrade" procedure for (hopefully) The Witcher 4, when the outcome is again such a gem.

You should post this in the Downgrade thread , to enjoy the reaction and responses from people over there.

/\

And also NSFW for anybody at work right now.

Too late for me, Im trying to explain this now. lol
 

aku:jiki

Member
-Im still at awe at the vastness of the world maps, the new area that Just opened contained what it looked like (at least) 2 Flotsam sized towns.
Haha, dude, the northern town, Novigrad, is probably bigger than the entirety of Witcher 2. The tiny villages are Flotsam-sized.

I almost have the feeling, the downgrade was good for the game or let's say, the best what could happen for this game. Because without this impressive reveal- and target trailers this game wouldn't have received this huge awareness over the years, respectively couldn't have achieved its final budget.
That doesn't really make sense. CDPR is an independent company, they didn't have to beg their publisher for money and you don't make any actual money off of a trailer or pre-release awareness.

But, yeah, downgrade thread.
 
question for anyone who has finished the game
is it better to kill the tree spirit or let it free? I've heard a whole village gets ruined if you spare it but you save 3 children. But maybe that isn't really a good pay off?
 

Cathcart

Member
I finally finished the prologue yesterday (Dont burn me, Im playing at my pace to savor the game), and my take so far:
Yeah I'm moving pretty slowly, too. I mean what's the rush? I'm gonna be sad when I finish this game so I'm taking my time to see everything. Sometimes I just pick a direction and go exploring for a bit. It's friggin' fantastic.

-The combat, Im sorry but whoever is saying the combat is, Slugish, bad, unresponsive, etc, I think they are doing it wrong, the combat mechanics are excellent, it plays way better than the Witcher 2, and just like the Witcher 2 its not just a hack and slash type of combat, you need to understand your situation before attacking a group of people/monsters, I usually lure monster one by one to tackle them, and when fighting humans always take out archer first which so far get killed with one attack.

Of course not everything in the combat is perfect, I cuuld had liked the camera to be closer to Geralt during combat. I also not sold on the decision on using slots to decide what abilities are active.
I came right from Bloodborne so it was a bit of an adjustment for me but now I'm really liking combat. The one problem I have is that I've gone with light gear and fast attack abilities and now I almost never use heavy attack. Maybe when I get a few more points I'll put some into one of the heavy attack abilities and see if that gives me more incentive to diversify.

-Storytelling is still as good as before, very immersive in whats going on, the conclusion to the epilogue was impressive for me and the audience wit Tyw... Emyr was as epic as I imagined it was going to be.
I actually think this is an understatement, the story telling is world class.

Thats my take so far, I basically did every sidequest and Point of Interest in White Orchard, but Im contemplating in turning of the Point of Interest marks in the map to have a more immersive experience.
After finishing WO I turned off the minimap, quest tracking and POI marks on the world map. It's too easy to hone in on the dotted line and just do what the line of text below it says. I'd love a compass, though. Sometimes it's frustrating to realize I went in the wrong direction but more often than not I end up finding something else to explore. This is one game where I really don't mind getting lost.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom