• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The XXII Sochi Winter Olympic Games / Ski And Skate Against Hate

Status
Not open for further replies.

2Crisis

Member
Can someone explain to me how the Team Pursuit qualifications work?

A Final for gold and silver, B final for bronze, and C and D finals for ranking?
 

Madness

Member
It seems like there is a very obvious home field advantage in hosting (you get to practice on the equipment...and I think you get more qualifiers per event?).

Definitely. You get to do more runs than anyone else on things like the bobsled track, you get to know the intricacies of the ice, plus the home team usually has a fire lit under their ass, and are given tons of support, money in the lead up to the games. Whatever may come of Russia, if they're smart, they'll use the legacy of Sochi and the facilities made to become a winter Olympics powerhouse again.

Then again, the US is proof that those with the most money, corporate sponsorship and world class facilities at home can do well as well. Guys like Bode Miller and Tim Ligety come to the game with hundreds of thousands of dollars of equipment, guys like Shaun White get their own half pipes made to practice on, BMW makes special one of a kind bobsleds with experimental designs etc.
 

Kagey K

Banned
Holy shit Canada is murdering GBR in Curling. That is one lopsided final.

Edit and that's that Canada sweeps Curling. Hockey on Sunday and we are good.

Wait tell me that wasn't pre recorded. I have a sneaking suspicion I am about to feel stupid.
 

DigiMish

Member
Holy shit Canada is murdering GBR in Curling. That is one lopsided final.

Edit and that's that Canada sweeps Curling. Hockey on Sunday and we are good.

Wait tell me that wasn't pre recorded. I have a sneaking suspicion I am about to feel stupid.

Hahahaha.
 
Holy shit Canada is murdering GBR in Curling. That is one lopsided final.

Edit and that's that Canada sweeps Curling. Hockey on Sunday and we are good.

Wait tell me that wasn't pre recorded. I have a sneaking suspicion I am about to feel stupid.
About 18 hours too late, friend.

~_~
 

Big-E

Member
I think they should really start to curb using foreign nationals on these teams. I think a good way to curb it is to say that once you compete in the Olympics for one country, you must compete for that country unless that country does not exist anymore. That article mentioned above says that the Canadian breakman has been on 3 different teams. That guy is pretty much just a mercenary. Olympics shouldn't be about that.
 

Timbuktu

Member
I think they should really start to curb using foreign nationals on these teams. I think a good way to curb it is to say that once you compete in the Olympics for one country, you must compete for that country unless that country does not exist anymore. That article mentioned above says that the Canadian breakman has been on 3 different teams. That guy is pretty much just a mercenary. Olympics shouldn't be about that.

That's how it works in football and FIFA right?
 

baekshi

Banned
Just updates on this:

http://www.change.org/en-CA/petitio...-and-demand-rejudgement-at-the-sochi-olympics

IOC has repeatedly mentioned "with no official complaint, no 'petition' will have any impact"

Well just an hour ago, Korean Olympic Committee has sent in the official complaint letter to the IOC mentioning the shame felt by the decision. It asks for an action to be done according to the IOC measures and to announce their official position.


PFIVUJi.jpg

6mXf2oD.jpg
 

Heshinsi

"playing" dumb? unpossible
I think they should really start to curb using foreign nationals on these teams. I think a good way to curb it is to say that once you compete in the Olympics for one country, you must compete for that country unless that country does not exist anymore. That article mentioned above says that the Canadian breakman has been on 3 different teams. That guy is pretty much just a mercenary. Olympics shouldn't be about that.

At the end of the day it's all about the athletes. Viktor Ahn has won 4 medals(3 gold and 1 bronze) at these games. South Korea didn't pick him in 2010. If he believes he is as good as he is, is he supposed to just give up his dream?
 

baekshi

Banned
At the end of the day it's all about the athletes. Viktor Ahn has won 4 medals(3 gold and 1 bronze) at these games. South Korea didn't pick him in 2010. If he believes he is as good as he is, is he supposed to just give up his dream?

You're right, I don't see anything wrong with this. It's was their own loss that they didn't believe him to be good enough or for whatever reason it maybe.
 
I spent today closed off from the world and happened to tune in when I thought the next day should be starting. I do feel like an asshat though.

Thanks for making me feel better. 0_o
Haha no worries. I mentioned earlier in the thread I feel the networks should be putting the word LIVE in the corner during broadcasts so people know because a lot of people have been confused about what events are live and not, myself included. I know at least CBC in Canada don't do it.
 

Timbuktu

Member
Of all the sports it does seem like it's the best to be snowboarders. They are often smiling, you see comradery between the guys and girls and even when they crash they can sometimes still be happy for each other. Maybe that's all for show, but it's still a far cry from all the hate and anger that seem to be there for skating and short track.
 

DigiMish

Member
Of all the sports it does seem like it's the best to be snowboarders. They are often smiling, you see comradery between the guys and girls and even when they crash they can sometimes still be happy for each other. Maybe that's all for show, but it's still a far cry from all the hate and anger that seem to be there for skating and short track.

I think it's the best to be a speed skater because they get a gazillion events and if you're decent in one, you're probably decent in most of them.
 

Kadayi

Banned
There definitely are legitimate reasons for people to feel that Kim deserved gold. The lack of formal complaint doesn't annul that. There's no point lodging a complaint without actual evidence of wrongdoing. In the 2002 scandal, the complaint was lodged by an official who spoke to the judge who privately admitted to being pressured into scoring the Russian pair higher. Or look at any other sports scandal. Plenty of decidedly unfair results slip by because without actual evidence, the results won't be changed.

So there's no point lodging a formal complaint without evidence, and the reason why no one has lodged a formal complaint is because there's no evidence. But despite the lack of any evidence, there's definitely in your words 'a legitimate case' (presumably one that would stand up in appeals court) because a bunch of people whose opinions might not necessarily be all that objective about the result based on personal favoritism (Queen Yuna) or a clear understanding of the assessment criteria at the end of the day firmly believe there's one? Makes perfect sense.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zrzMhU_4m-g

As regards the judge picture. It's not all that unusual for officals to congratulate competitors after an event. As I understand it Sotnikova once she found out she won hugged a number of people including coaches, staff, judges and even other competitors. But of course lets forget that she's a 17 year old girl whose just won Olympic Gold despite the odds in favour of her hugging that one Russian judge because it happens to fit the 'corruption' scenario.

I have to wonder if the shoe was on the other foot, and Yuna had won after a stumble and it was a Korean judge on the panel (which it could of been given they draw lots) 'caught' hugging her afterwards would you be here adamantly calling into an investigation into why Sotnikova didn't get gold? I suspect not.
 

Arjen

Member
I think it's the best to be a speed skater because they get a gazillion events and if you're decent in one, you're probably decent in most of them.

You've got 500,1000,1500,5000 and 10000.
And people who are good at sprint don't compete in the 5k and 10k and vice versa. So it's 2, max 3 events you can compete in.
Hardly a gazillion.
 
These girls are in beast mode on a good day.

So fucking happy right now. The Norwegian women showing their true colors and showing why them not winning gold in the relay was the biggest bomb of the entire Games. Especially happy for Kristin Størmer Steira. As I wrote on reddit:

My greatest wish is that Kristin Størmer Steira will get a medal. It's unlikely, she's past her peak. But she deserves it.
* 2006 Turin - 10km classical - 4th, 7 seconds behind 3rd
* 2006 Turin - 15km pursuit - 4th, 3.6 seconds behind 3rd
* 2006 Turin - 30km freestyle - 4th, 13 seconds behind 3rd
* 2010 Vancouver - 15km pursuit - 4th, 0.1 seconds behind 3rd, 0.5 seconds behind 2nd, 9.4 behind 1st
She has a gold medal from the relay in 2010, but no individual medal from the Olympics. That 4th place in Vancouver was heartbreaking.
 

Peru

Member
Sweep! Our CC girls are def my favorite athletes in our team so I'm stoked and don't really care what the guys do.

1393065761468_966.jpg


As regards the judge picture. It's not all that unusual for officals to congratulate competitors after an event. As I understand it Sotnikova once she found out she won hugged a number of people including coaches, staff, judges and even other competitors. But of course lets forget that she's a 17 year old girl whose just won Olympic Gold despite the odds in favour of her hugging that one Russian judge because it happens to fit the 'corruption' scenario.

Hugging doesn't mean anything - a judge deviating wildly in scoring does, however. And according to sources an official complaint has now been lodged.
 

Angst

Member
Very impressed by the Norwegian girls, but the lack of suspense made the event a snore fest to watch. Looking forward to the 50 km event tomorrow and of course the event that matters the most - hockey finals! :)

Spoiler - I'm Swedish
 

kottila

Member
Very impressed by the Norwegian girls, but the lack of suspense made the event a snore fest to watch. Looking forward to the 50 km event tomorrow and of course the event that matters the most - hockey finals! :)

Spoiler - I'm Swedish

The two only real contenders either had a broken foot (kowalcyk) or was sick just a few days ago (kalla) so it wasn't very surprising
 

Angst

Member
The two only real contenders either had a broken foot (kowalcyk) or was sick just a coulle days ago (kalla) so it wasn't very surprising
Agreed, I expected at least Bjørgen and Johaug on the podium. Steira was the biggest surprise. Kudos to Kalla for not quitting when it was clear that she wouldn't get a medal.
 

Madness

Member
Of all the sports it does seem like it's the best to be snowboarders. They are often smiling, you see comradery between the guys and girls and even when they crash they can sometimes still be happy for each other. Maybe that's all for show, but it's still a far cry from all the hate and anger that seem to be there for skating and short track.

True, but skiers and snowboarders suffer notorious injuries. You'll be lucky to find someone who hasn't broken a bone or suffered a significant knee injury into their twenties. But the lifestyle of theirs is just going fast, enjoying the air, speed, they're some of the most chill people ever. You can watch snowboard cross, see a guy screw up and take out a favorite and like you'd think he'd be upset he lost a medal but they just shake hands and hug and move on lol.
 

Hunter S.

Member
Of all the sports it does seem like it's the best to be snowboarders. They are often smiling, you see comradery between the guys and girls and even when they crash they can sometimes still be happy for each other. Maybe that's all for show, but it's still a far cry from all the hate and anger that seem to be there for skating and short track.
Snowboarding has a laid back attitude about it just like surfing. The snowboard and ski bums create a sort of party culture about it. Your on the slopes during the day and then often drinking partying at night. I think because it is this way in small ski towns the attitude stays with the competitors even once they become professionals. There are a lot of hated dude bro types (on GAF) that live in ski towns. It is an awesome sport to participate in.
 

Kadayi

Banned
Hugging doesn't mean anything - a judge deviating wildly in scoring does, however. And according to sources an official complaint has now been lodged.

Reports seem to vary on that front and it was a 'protest letter' according to some, which isn't necessarily cause for an investigation, but might perhaps relieve the KSU from fan pressure to be seen to do something at their end. Still personally I'd be down with an investigation if that's what's required to put some closure on the matter. I don't think the result is likely to change, and South Korea will just come out looking like butt sore losers from it all (which will bode well for them at the next games), but I dare say then the accusation would be that the investigating committee got it wrong.
 

Peru

Member
Reports seem to vary on that front and it was a 'protest letter' according to some, which isn't necessarily cause for an investigation, but might perhaps relieve the KSU from fan pressure to be seen to do something at their end. Still personally I'd be down with an investigation if that's what's required to put some closure on the matter. I don't think the result is likely to change, and South Korea will just come out looking like butt sore losers from it all (which will bode well for them at the next games), but I dare say then the accusation would be that the investigating committee got it wrong.

IOC wouldn't overturn a medal unless the evidence is blatant and in the public or an athlete fails a doping test, this we've seen many times. I have no hope of that happening. The good thing is there's a consensus Sotnikova's run wasn't a 149 and the history books will take that consensus into consideration.
 

Angst

Member
I always wonder who decides to go pro in crosscountry skiing. It's by far the least amount of fun you can have on skis.
The same personality type that goes pro in running? I'm sure you can have a lot more fun in a pair of sneakers than running 40 kms ;-)
 

Brashnir

Member
Reports seem to vary on that front and it was a 'protest letter' according to some, which isn't necessarily cause for an investigation, but might perhaps relieve the KSU from fan pressure to be seen to do something at their end. Still personally I'd be down with an investigation if that's what's required to put some closure on the matter. I don't think the result is likely to change, and South Korea will just come out looking like butt sore losers from it all (which will bode well for them at the next games), but I dare say then the accusation would be that the investigating committee got it wrong.

judged "sports" have always been, and will always be, a farce.

Imagine if the NBA's Slam Dunk competition awarded a gold medal. They're all a fucking joke.
 

Ulumsk

Member
Three out of four match officials in the hockey final are Canadians with the fourth being an American that happens to have Canadian citizenship? How did that happen?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom