The key difference between me and most off the true fans is that I have played and beaten the game. You aren't lazy when you step into an arena and outclass most all of your highest regarded competition.
This is a broken record at this point but this is Resident Evil 4 all over again. It went over easier because that game reviewed like crazy weeks before it came out and it was revolutionary at the time. I hate to see the old games go. I just recently beat Underworld and I loved every moment but this new one is hands down a better game.
Well you didn't actually say how even a single thing I said was wrong. Saying "i've played it" is not a good defense of any of the things I said, given their common knowledge status at this point and the fact that it's completely true that it destroys classic Tomb Raider once and for all.
You can say whatever this nebulous thing is is "better", but it can only be better as far as I'm concerned is if you never liked the foundations the series was based on. That's the only way. The series is based on puzzles, isolation, death defying platforming, all three of which have been annihilated. To try to then say 'I don't get why people talk about 'true fans' like that' makes no sense. Most people accept what the game is at this point: why try to act like it does anything that ever made people play the series?