It is easily the highlight of this new Toonami and my toonami-gaf experience. Really doubt they'll ever top it
My favorite Toonami-GAF experiences (in no particular order)
SAO - KIYABA!
Tenchi Muyo! GXP - Finale
Deadman Wonderland - Hummingbird
Bleach - Momo!!!
SAO - Tentacles
SAO - Rudolph the Red Nose Reindeer
Tenchi Muyo! GXP - Tannan (pink haired guy) episode
SAO - Sugo tears
Thundercats - MAXIMUM TROLLING
Black Lagoon - Rock and Levi share a cigarette
Space Dandy - Viva All
Space Dandy - Zombie episode
Symbionic Titan - Shake it, Bake it
Symbionic Titan - You know, for kids!
Granted they are mostly awful moments for the most part it is these extremes and the reactions to them push them into classic territory. Even better was when the moments coalesced into one great moment like the SAO - Sugo reveal airing after space dandy led a classic gif I can't find featuring the Space Dandy Zombie Door but instead of opening the door to a zombie Meow it was Sugu. It is moments like those make me love this place. Going back also makes me realize how much I miss Andrex