SAO Smartest anime in years is still god king of anime articles.
I'm just going to systematically take this review apart here, if no one minds. Reviewing the review or some such.
Here is the original review to read alongside of this.
http://kotaku.com/sword-art-online-...ZSnKcw.5&utm_referrer=https://www.google.com/
Good — A Sense of Time
Here, the reviewer talks about how the fact that the show creates timeskips is good. However, your average person hated this, as the pacing was suddenly trash and this wasn't for the best. He managed to take a thing we all hate and say it was a good part of the show. He says this lets you look at the psychological implications of being in a VRMMO, but I would argue no more than as if you had been in one for two days, as the first Log Horizon light novel so clearly shows. People don't PK because they've been there two years. Next, he says it makes them wonder if the real world even exists, which I think he made up for dramatic effect. Lastly, he ends this point with an incomplete thought, I think it was either a question he ended with a period or half a thought, I am unsure.
Next up, we have
the implications of society!
Which has a great quote
"So do you, as a hardcore gamer, draft the whole lot and make them fight? Do you just leave them—including the children—to fend for themselves?"
It continues on. However, we have no agency in the show. It's a TV show. We are not Kirito, nor is it interactive. We do not watch the newest action thriller and pause it in the middle and look at the audience and ask them what they want to do - that would make no sense, as does this statement. It even says all these questions are addressed and more! There is so much wrong with this....no...these things are not addressed. They aren't even pivotal parts of the story, and as such, aren't worth mentioning in any review.
Oh boy
The author says that because people don't have much knowledge of the world around them, the world is perfect for genre crossing adventures, such as mysteries, love stories, criminal suspense, etc.
However, the fact they don't know much of the world around them doesn't really cause that, that would have happened anyways. He also continues to spin the fact the story keeps jumping all over the place as a good thing- which it clearly isn't.
Mixed- Predictably Tragic
Predictable? Sure. Tragic? Eh, at...times? The show isn't actually that crazy on the tragic deaths, Kirito's entire harem lives. In the case of the first 12 episodes, on the basis of how many lived, it was no tragedy.
Overall, I would rate this as a very poor and illogical review, and if I had to give it a rating
Should you read this review?- NO