FLCL will always have a special place in my heart for being the show I woke up to one night at like 2 or 3 am when I was in like 6th grade and it having alter the course of my mind forever (it was the episode, like all eps it was fricking nuts.) I had accidentally seen eps of Home Movies and some other early AS shows but none had the effect on my that one episode of FLCL did. I didn't even know the name of the anime until years later, and of course the live action anime just further bewildered and enchanted me.focusing on that theater president girl or whoever
It's one of those things that happened as a kid you'll never be able to replicate, and I will forever love the show deeply for it.
This is my EXACT same experience, except it was my little brother and I at our shore house. Same episode too!
I might have been a freshman, it's hard to place the exact year.