Hi guys, I'm planning my next vacation for Toronto/Niagra, and I'm wishing the OP had a section for Brew Pubs, Irish/English Pubs, or other nightlife. Anyone have any suggestions?
The Wheat Sheaf is Toronto's oldest. It's a little dive-ey now, but has a good selection of on-tap beers and lots of TVs playing lots of footy in the summertime.
Victory Cafe also has a great selection and if you're into the boho vibe, does poetry and music stuff in their upstairs area. At least, they used to.
C'est What is a nightlife hangout for local 20-somethings. Again, decent selection, and a huge basement space right downtown. Good food, too, for a pub/bar.
The Queen and Beaver is an English pub gone upscale. Haven't been there myself but I've heard good things about the food. Including but not limited to the Scotch eggs.
Duggan's is a local brewer with restaurant attached. The food is good stuff - duck confit poutine, for one thing - and they have some great beer pairings. Last I checked they also had a nice variety of scotch, too.
Mill Street is another local brewer with a nice variety of their own brews. Down in the Distillery District, it's got a really good neighbourhood vibe and the eclectic surroundings are fun to explore pre-drink.
McVeigh's is an iconic Toronto Irish Pub, though I hesitate to suggest it because it looks like a dive. The food is decent but this is a place you go for booze.
Fynn's of Temple Bar is an Irish-inspired place. On Friday nights there's a live DJ. This is a place to go for drinks and people-watching, the food isn't on my top-10.
Granite Brewery has a micro-brew, but they're more known for their scotch selection. The food is passable.
The Monk's Table is an all-purpose good-food good-drink English Pub. Give it a shot.
Rebel House has a short but tasty menu and a good selection of non-traditional (ie non-Molson/Coors and the like) beers. I liked their side of mac & cheese.
Auld Spot is another popular choice. Having never been there I can't speak for it, but others have indicated to me it's a good option for a casual night.
Brazen Head is a good Irish Pub with multi-level seating, and it's new enough that it doesn't yet look all dingy. Pretty good on the food, too.
Unicorn is a bit of a dive, but it's one of the few places in Toronto that has had Magner's on Tap. It will soon be closing to feed Toronto's condo boom.
Bier Markt is probably the only multi-location chain I'll mention. They have a near-unparalleled selection of beers here, and the food is tasty.
Wvrst ("Wurst") is a newer, hipper, deliciouser place to go. This is a semi-cafeteria style joint where you pick from a selection of sausages (including wild boar, kangaroo, etc) for your meal and there are beer pairings suggested. Worth a shot, but it gets crowded on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday nights.
Bellwoods Brewery is another stand-out spot, this one on the gentrifying Ossington Strip. It's an industrial space rather than a traditional restaurant, and they have a microbrew in the back. Food is decent but the drinks are better.
All of the above can be googled and should have an operational website. Reviews for most can be found on Yelp.ca (pretentious foodies), BlogTO (hipsters), and Toronto Life (professional reviewers).
One thing that you'll notice about Toronto is that it's very neighbourhood-oriented. Each has a slightly different vibe, and some you'll like better than others. The east-enders here will note I've been remiss to mention a lot of Leslieville and Danforth-area pubs. I don't know those areas as well so I'll leave it to them to cover them better.
Toronto has no shortage of pubs and lounges and gastropubs and brewpubs to check out. Look for crowds - an hour's wait is a pretentious joint; seated among one of five other patrons is a bad sign. Somewhere in the middle is worth your while.
If you want to get out of touristy areas and chain fare, avoid "Duke", "Firkin", and "Fionn Maccool's" pubs. Also, avoid Front Street between York and Spadina, Dundas between Church and Bay, and, unless you're going for Dim Sum (which I do recommend), Spadina from Queen to College.