• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

*UNMARKED SPOILERS ALL BOOKS* Game of Thrones |OT| - Season 6

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sean C

Member
One if them was 100% on the show last year, the one with the spear. I think she's Oberyns daughter?

They probably both were, I just don't remember the second one
Whip!Snake was in the previous season, she just had like two lines. Her name is Nymeria Sand, generally called Lady Nym.
 

Aurongel

Member
Maybe I missed it but did they explain why they haven't burn Jon's body? Besides the obvious resurrection I mean.
If you're referring to the mutineers, a pure is probably far too honorable a thing to do for him. Hence why they let him die in the snow like an animal near his shallow grave.
 

Violet_0

Banned
fucking Sand Snakes. Still the worst part of the show, Dorne was a mistake
Danny is back to being annoying
best scene of the episode was Brienne's horse kill
 
dorne8eogo.gif

People are so freaking clever.

Loved it!

XD
 

bengraven

Member
The stumbling was one of the best moments in the episode. Sansa's first major act as someone who is no longer going to be pushed around and yet she's still frightened and young. Brilliant.
 

Aiii

So not worth it
Maybe I missed it but did they explain why they haven't burn Jon's body? Besides the obvious resurrection I mean.

The treasonous men wanted his body found next to the traitor sign as an example.

Ser Davos and Jon's friends are locked up in a room, setting fire to it would not be beneficial to their cause.

Though to be on the safe side I'd have tied him up so he at least wouldn't want to eat my brains halfway through the night. Maybe they forgot about the whole Others business due to the stress of the situation.
 

bengraven

Member
The treasonous men wanted his body found next to the traitor sign as an example.

Ser Davos and Jon's friends are locked up in a room, setting fire to it would not be beneficial to their cause.

Though to be on the safe side I'd have tied him up so he at least wouldn't want to eat my brains halfway through the night. Maybe they forgot about the whole Others business due to the stress of the situation.

Right because at least some of them should believe in the undead after the events of the last five years.
 

Sean C

Member
The stumbling was one of the best moments in the episode. Sansa's first major act as someone who is no longer going to be pushed around and yet she's still frightened and young. Brilliant.
Her "first act as someone who is no longer going to be pushed around" was her lying to the Lords Declarant in 408. This was followed by her acting like an idiot for a full season and getting abused worse than ever.
 
Is Jon warging into Ghost even necessary from a book or TV perspective? Beric Dondarrion was resurrected after being hanged, and he in turn resurrected Catelyn when she was a soggy corpse, so there seems to be little in the way of time limits. In alternative, non-fire magic, we have The Mountain resurrected, very likely with a new head sewn onto his body, so even decapitation seems to be a manageable problem in this universe.

So what is the purpose of Jon temporarily going into Ghost while we wait for Melisandre to bring him back? If Beric and Catelyn didn't need to retain their consciousness in some vessel, why would Jon...? We expect it due to the otherwise pointless Varamyr chapters in the books, but is it even necessary?



...no? Besides clearly being the same actresses, they've established three Show Snakes, who each use a whip, a spear, and knives, respectively, as their Ninja Turtles-esque weapons of choice.

When Beric and Catelyn were resurrected they weren't completely themselves anymore. Being dead and the revival takes something from them. The idea is that since Jon's spirit or whatever is inside Ghost, he'll be pretty much himself once resurrected.
 

Ros8105

Member
Filming Rumors:
From what I've heard they did almost nothing with Dorne this season in terms of filming. We might see the Snakes in King's Landing at some point later this season but we will most likely not see the water gardens again.
This is fantastic news. I can't think of anything I dislike more in a tv series than the sandsnakes.
 

cLOUDo

Member
Man fuck that Dorne shit. If that was their solution to the problems with it last season then fuck that.

Still #Season6willbebetter.
This is my issue as well

If you wanted to get rid of Dorne in a good way...
Doran acknowledge to the assassination of Myrcella and the kills all the sand snakes And ellaria and sends his heads to the lannister as a apology.
End of Dorne


BTW this Trystane was another actor?
 

Tiktaalik

Member
Areo Hotah, who is considered one of the best fighters in the books, killed by this:

I'm actually genuinely upset about this, because it means that all of the Dorne stuff was mere filler in the show. The whole coup is just absolutely dumb. The show never intended to have ANY of Doran's plans for Westeros be relevant. It was just so they could kill off Myrcella and give the Lannisters a reason to go to war with Dorne or something idk.

The entire Dorne plot is like, a 180° of everything in the books. GRRM must be projectile vomiting.

The other explanation is that all of the Dorne stuff from the books is essentially cool world building, not actually that relevant to the core story. The TV adaptation has limited money and time so the producers are going to toss out absolutely everything they can. The fact that the Dorne stuff of last season even existed at all means that Ellaria / Adrienne does something of significant relevance in the books. All the other characters don't and so they're best killed off. I don't think this was handled that gracefully in the last few Dorne episodes, and the death of Trystane Martell in this episode was particularly unsatisfying, but I understand the motivations from the production side.

The major high level takeaway for Dorne I guess is that this was once a stabilizing force in Westeros politics like Highgarden, and now it has shifted into something that is not.
 

carlsojo

Member
Was anyone else totally relieved that Daenerys's widow status made her untouchable by the Khalasar? I was dreading yet another rape plot.
 
There are many people who only can see a chipped piece of bark on a tree, and completely miss the fact that there is a forest around them. Keep SMH over some of the stuff people are complaining about here.

The two snakes got to the prince by hopping on a boat and following him. Do the people confused over that think that the events in this show are happening in real time with a 24 clock ticking in the background?

Has the bolded been confirmed? Did I miss a scene somewhere?

Last I checked, Obara and Nym were standing at the docks with Ellaria and Tyene, watching the ship carrying Jaime, Trystane, and Myrcella sail into the distance. Next episode, Obara and Nym are suddenly on the same boat as Trystane, which appears to be a different boat than the one carrying Jaime and Myrcella.

I must have missed something here: where did they establish that there was a second boat carrying Trystane, and where did they establish how Nym and Obara go from standing on the docks with Ellaria and Tyene to being on the same boat as Trystane?
 

dubq

Member
Has the bolded been confirmed? Did I miss a scene somewhere?

Last I checked, Obara and Nym were standing at the docks with Ellaria and Tyene, watching the ship carrying Jaime, Trystane, and Myrcella sail into the distance. Next episode, Obara and Nym are suddenly on the same boat as Trystane, which appears to be a different boat than the one carrying Jaime and Myrcella.

I must have missed something here: where did they establish that there was a second boat carrying Trystane, and where did they establish how Nym and Obara go from standing on the docks with Ellaria and Tyene to being on the same boat as Trystane?

Jaime was on a second smaller boat to bring Myrcella's body back. That boat probably came from KL to pick him up. Trystaine was on the bigger boat and they even said he can't set foot on the captial.

They didn't establish how Nym and Obara got to him, but is it really a stretch of the imagination that they took another boat and tailed Trystaine before boarding to kill him? Did this really need to be explicitly stated?
 
All the speculation seems more like wishful thinking to me. What are some of the evidences that make people so sure? Just the eyes thing?

They spent a 10 minute scene planting the seeds of R + L = J in season 5.

In a show with finite number of screen time it's incredibly stupid to plant a red herring that will fly over most people's heads unless it becomes important later on.
 
My group of friends, who mostly don't even read the books, were really disappointed in this episode. Did anyone else's friends feel the same?

The Dorne stuff was so damn awful. So damn awful.

The dialogue was horrible. What the fuck is going on here? That scene with the Khal and his buddies was bad. So much cheesy dialogue in this episode.

I really liked the Sansa scenes and the Nights Watch scenes though. It's still really cool to me that we get Sansa and Theon together and the scene where Brienne is offering herself up as a Knight was great.
 

belvedere

Junior Butler
Yep, Dorne was Dorne and the Dany/Khal scene was cliche, but if I'm going to go out of my way to bitch and moan I'll go out of my way to list a few positives as well.

The cinematography of the Sansa/Theon escape was gorgeous
The pacing at the wall seems deliberately leisurely, but well done
Doran - Genuinely surprised, shocked even
Mel - most haunting thing I've seen in decades

Also, if anyone wants to create a Dorne bitching filter, I'll gladly fund it.
 

Brakke

Banned
where did they establish how Nym and Obara go from standing on the docks with Ellaria and Tyene to being on the same boat as Trystane?

Kings Landing and Dorne are p far away. Just pretend that the Sand Snakes rode for some Dornish port where the boat stopped to take on fresh water, and snuck aboard there, if it makes you feel better.
 

Iksenpets

Banned
Filming Rumors:
From what I've heard they did almost nothing with Dorne this season in terms of filming. We might see the Snakes in King's Landing at some point later this season but we will most likely not see the water gardens again.

I love it how one knife stab in the back is enough to take down Areo Hotah and the guards all just sit and watch everything happen.

You'll be getting lots of my commentary throughout the season. Not sure where Vic is.

The filming stuff we were all using to assume minimal Dorne all came from Hotah's actor though. He's the one who said the it was a small plot this season, and who instagrammed their very brief three-day filming session together. Now that he's killed off though, there could be plenty more stuff with the girls that he just wasn't present for, epecially with two of them in King's Landing now.
 
I hope that's the last we see of Dorne. Just have a messenger come in at the end of episode 6 or 7 going "Yeah, we razed Sunspear and the Water Gardens to the ground. Everyone is dead."
 
They didn't establish how Nym and Obara got to him, but is it really a stretch of the imagination that they took another boat and tailed Trystaine before boarding to kill him? Did this really need to be explicitly stated?

Yes, because the last time we saw them, they were with their mother and clearly not on the boat. The whole Dorne thing was poorly handled from the beginning and this is just the icing on that shit sandwich. Hell, I kind of want an explanation as to why the ship didn't turn around the second Myrcella was dead as they were basically minutes away from Dorne at that point. I mean, the princess was murdered for God's sake.

So assuming that they don't turn round for a reason, they also do nothing with Trystaine, who was either supposed to join the small council, or at least would be a major fucking hostage at this point, and the ship is IN King's landing. So for the snakes to get to Trys, they would need another ship, hidden from view for the entire trip, then pull up next to the ship carrying the heir, get on, get to him, and then kill him. Bullshit. With setup it would be ridiculous, without it, it's even worse.
 

duckroll

Member
Garbage nothing premiere. The only things of note which happened made the show 30% (scientific statistic) worse and everything else was just a repeat of the same status quo in case the audience forgot where characters were last season. Even with every scene feeling like it was a few minutes too long, the episode still wasn't an hour long. They're obviously stalling due to lack of material for a full season at this point. Lol.

Oh and someone at HBO must like granny porn. :p
 
Kings Landing and Dorne are p far away. Just pretend that the Sand Snakes rode for some Dornish port where the boat stopped to take on fresh water, and snuck aboard there, if it makes you feel better.

I'm happy to pretend whatever the show wants me to. For instance, I've been pretending that Jaime will see the meaningful development his character undergoes in the books for the past two seasons.

Pretending isn't the problem. The problem is lazy writing.

So assuming that they don't turn round for a reason, they also do nothing with Trystaine, who was either supposed to join the small council, or at least would be a major fucking hostage at this point, and the ship is IN King's landing. So for the snakes to get to Trys, they would need another ship, hidden from view for the entire trip, then pull up next to the ship carrying the heir, get on, get to him, and then kill him. Bullshit. With setup it would be ridiculous, without it, it's even worse.

Bingo.
 

DeviantBoi

Member
Remind me about the Mance death scene in the books.

Was there a red gem holding the glamour in place?

Or was it just Melisandre?

I think I remember reading about a gem, but it was a long time ago.
 
I'm not entirely convinced that Hotah is killed yet (Considering it was one small dagger). While Doran and Trystane is definitely soooper dead.

But maaaaaan are those Sand Snakes line cringeworthy.
 

mantidor

Member
My group of friends, who mostly don't even read the books, were really disappointed in this episode. Did anyone else's friends feel the same?

Yup I saw it in a bar and the reactions were pretty bad. My two friends didn't like it that much although one tried to defend the show a bit more. Everyone thought that the reveal really didn't change anything and the episode felt like nothing really happened.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom