Hey, the finale was good! Thoughts:
- The opening bit on the trial was fantastically done. They were saying goodbye to a ton of characters, and they managed to give them all pretty good notes to go out on. Except Kevan. Poor Kevan didn't get a line. But Mace got to act pompously indignant, Pycelle got to have a brief flash of not acting, Lancel actually got to be the focal point of a big scene, and Marg was able to be a queen again for just a little bit. Tommen's suicide was weird, but I guess understandable, even if that one's obviously not happening in the books. Mad Queen Cersei looked fantastic, and I'm excited to see what she and Crazy Qyburn get up to, though I don't see how long she can survive if the combined Martell-Tyrell forces are coming, even before Dany gets there.
- Oldtown and the Citadel looked great, and the explicit reference to the Archmaester makes it sound like we're going to get at least some of the characters from that story next season.
- I'm not really feeling the Dany/Tyrion dynamic. Their conversation felt flat and overly long. But at least without Daario around the Yara shippers can go wild!
- The Arya scene was good (poor Lord Manderly though, being reduced to a nobody and having his pies taken by Arya) but after her awful season, it felt like kind of a cynical move to teleport her over there to give us a fun murder. Like, sorry for wasting all that time in Braavos! Here, have this! One other complaint is that the whole Riverlands plot, now that it seems ended by Frey's murder, feels a little useless. The siege and Blackfish's death tied into nothing at all. Every character made it out of there pretty much exactly as they were before. Maybe Arya will bust Edmure out and he can have some future relevance that will make that all worthwhile? (Also, did Jaime completely renege on his promise to get Edmure a comfortable place at the Rock?) This whole scene feels kind of prescient for how the adaptation will work from here on out. Frey's death, a plot in the book that seems like it will involve a lot of stuff from the Brotherhood and Blackfish and who knows who else gets reduced into a single Arya scene.
- The Northern stuff, as a book reader, is kind of frustrating, just because we lost the whole Northern conspiracy dynamic where characters like Glover and Manderly were hardcore loyalists working for Stark restoration the whole time, whereas here they're grumpy dudes who have to be beaten into line by Lyanna Mormont. But ignoring the books, it was a good storyline on its own, and the ending paid off well. Don't know where it goes from here though. Does Jon get pulled into Southern affairs? Or does he stay focused on the North? Do the Riverlands sign on to King Jon now that they're free from Frey? How badly is Littlefinger going to fuck this all up, especially since Jon seems to have taken control of the Knights of the Vale from him.
Edit: Oh, two quick other things: Tyrion pledged himself to Dany "now and always", the same phrasing Theon used with Robb. Foreshadowing? And then Jon's reference to the enemy "bringing the storm", hint at Euron's involvement with the White Walker stuff in the future?