I would personally put Dallas over Nadine due to his compatability with alicia and vice versa...
Its a toss up but i would go with Dallas
- I
very rarely ever have any Engineer shoot, so I don't really need the boost to accuracy.
- Is Welkin included in the Man Hater potential? Even if he isn't, my Engineers stand by a lot of people (not all of them female), which is why I'm not a fan of team depreciating potentials on a whole. Now, I don't use Nadine's Bond much, as the only Darcsen I
sometimes use is Wavy. But I'd rather a potential I don't use than a negative one.
- Alicia's Like/Potential is a nice ability (as you should always have Alicia), but she doesn't usually stay very close to my Engineer at all. While also rare, I'm more likely to have Nadine close to a backup Engineer.
- I'd agree that Pollen Allergy is worse than Desert Allergy because of the strong presence of grass/trees throughout the game, so Dallas gets that hands-down.
- Super Repair is great, Super Defense is better. Engineers are among the squishiest of classes and mine are always mobile. I'm traditionally much more concerned about interception fire on the way to supporting a teammate than the tank's health (especially as you beef it up throughout the campaign). So Super Defense plus Resist Counters makes the day.
- Demolition Man gets no use in any of my runs. Again, my Engineers are not offensive in the least. This one's a cancel out with Rear Guard, which I also don't use.
I acknowledge the Like statuses, but I've never primarily utilize them as a paradigm for team builds. Everyone largely stands on their own merits in my squad and that alone (mechanically speaking). So yeah, not a blowup by any means, but I would still hand it to Nadine. It depends on how you prefer to boost your Engineers straight on the field.