• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

[Verge] Microsoft is combining ‘the best of Xbox and Windows together’ for handhelds

Panajev2001a

GAF's Pleasant Genius
Pretty much lays it out that they are going to use the Xbox System for its gaming OS that it licenses out to 3rd party.
Maybe, but what he says supports the other way around. Migrate devs to the common Game SDK, supports Xbox console titles with VM/compatibiityblayers, and make additive shell changes to make the UI look more console like and hide the PC-ness under a new rug as much as they can.
 
No interest in a HH but it makes perfect sense to have the Surface team involved and looking forward to seeing the next-gen console with a HH for those who like to game on a bog
 
Last edited:

odhiex

Member
“I think, at the end of the day, our goal is to make Windows great for gaming on any device,” says Ronald. “The reality is the Xbox operating system is built on top of Windows. So there’s a lot of infrastructure that we built in the console space that we can bring to the PC space and really deliver that premium gaming experience on any device.”

This is an obvious goal, but it seems like Microsoft tends to make anything more complicated, including their marketing campaign "This is an XBOX", the Company's obsession over A.I. etc.

I don't understand why a mega company like Microsoft, which owns the market share of Personal Computers with Windows, failed to capture the majority of PC gaming. They now have Blizzard (WoW), Call of Duty and Candy Crush. Not sure if the hybrid strategy (XBOX+Windows) will suddenly boost its position in the gaming space. I guess, we'll see.
 
Last edited:

GHG

Member
Just make everygame crossbuy and they will have a winner. Buy xbox game get pc version free and vice versa.

Nobody other than those still inexplicably trapped in the Xbox ecosystem give a shit about this.

They have an uphill battle.

Ms/Xbox are usually first to a lot of things which Sony and Nintendo follow.

Achievements, paid online (which hasn't been a positive for the space), and what else?
 
Last edited:

Trilobit

Member
k3u4hCo.jpeg
 

Astray

Member
Their biggest problem has always been that what's tying PC gamers to Windows isn't a Microsoft-provided library, but a Steam one.

I don't really see how this new initiative will solve this. I personally will wait for the Steam OS stuff to come out and take my pick.
 

TBiddy

Member
Achievements, paid online (which hasn't been a positive for the space), and what else?

Adaptive controllers and Play Anywhere seem to be good innovations as well.

This is an obvious goal, but it seems like Microsoft tends to make anything more complicated, including their marketing campaign "This is an XBOX", the Company's obsession over A.I. etc.

I don't understand why a mega company like Microsoft, which owns the market share of Personal Computers with Windows, failed to capture the majority of PC gaming. They now have Blizzard (WoW), Call of Duty and Candy Crush. Not sure if the hybrid strategy (XBOX+Windows) will suddenly boost its position in the gaming space. I guess, we'll see.

Microsoft has never been good at convincing consumers that their products are good. They are an enterprise company with a gaming branch, which they really don't know what to do with. Sometimes they seem to go all in. At other times it looks like they are abandoning ship.
 
Last edited:

kruis

Exposing the sinister cartel of retailers who allow companies to pay for advertising space.
Their biggest problem has always been that what's tying PC gamers to Windows isn't a Microsoft-provided library, but a Steam one.

I don't really see how this new initiative will solve this. I personally will wait for the Steam OS stuff to come out and take my pick.

Yep. PC gamers on Windows are far more likely to buy a SteamOS based handheld than a Windows based device. It's a delicious irony.
 

GHG

Member
Adaptive controllers

Microsoft didn't invent adaptive controllers.

285526-handsfree.jpg


Play Anywhere



By the way "play anywhere", doesn't really mean play anywhere either.
 
Last edited:

TBiddy

Member
Microsoft didn't invent adaptive controllers.

285526-handsfree.jpg





By the way "play anywhere", doesn't really mean play anywhere either.

First adaptive controller that could be customized then. Jesus. And surely you don't think that Portal game is the same as 'Play Anywhere'.
 
TBH while I love steamos for handhelds and proton is awesome, I would prefer a debloated, optimized and consolized version of windows with a great UI for controllers. In the end, proton will always be a step back from native, also I'm not a fan of the linux desktop experience or its file system or command console.
 

GHG

Member
First adaptive controller that could be customized then. Jesus.

We went from "innovation" to "iteration" in lightning speed here.

And surely you don't think that Portal game is the same as 'Play Anywhere'.

What do you think this is then?:

In 2010, we announced Steam Play: a way for Steam users to access Windows, Mac and Linux versions of Steam games with a single purchase.

 
Last edited:

DavidGzz

Gold Member
Achievements, paid online (which hasn't been a positive for the space), and what else?


Xbox Live, integrated voice chat for all games, achievements, and the first console with an internal HDD. Oh, Kinect.....Booyah!/s
 
Last edited:

TBiddy

Member
We went from "innovation" to "iteration" in lightning speed here.


You really need to check what the word "innovation" means, my friend.

And I'm glad we agree that the Portal link you started off with was useless, since you're now iterating to something else. Steam Play, while a great idea, is different from Play Anywhere. We both know that.
 
Last edited:

HeisenbergFX4

Gold Member
I thought that Ronald guy was gone from Microsoft, I guess not.

I see he's become even more wizard like in his appearance. Why are there so many flamboyant weirdos as the face of tech company products? NVIDIA guy yesterday was a hoot.
He's the "VP of Next Gen" or something like that
Also the guy I have brought up many times was with us in Ybarras channel that they chuckled at the power of the PS5 during its tech reveal

So dude doesn’t inspire confidence in me he REALLY knows what’s best
 

xrnzaaas

Member
It's not going to be a debloated, optimized version of Windows running like clockwork, you'll be dealing with all of the downsides or their current OS. Microsoft can't make a good version of W11 for desktop users, why would they succeed with a niche portable hardware.
 
Last edited:

GHG

Member
You really need to check what the word "innovation" means, my friend.

And I'm glad we agree that the Portal link you started off with was useless, since you're now iterating to something else. Steam Play, while a great idea, is different from Play Anywhere. We both know that.

I'd like you to explain how you think Steam Play is any different.

You buy a game on Steam and it allows you to play the game across all hardware where the Steam store is officially available for playing games (Windows, Mac and Linux).

You buy a game on Xbox and it allows you to play the game across all hardware where the windows/xbox store is officially available (windows and Xbox consoles).

Just as Steam play only grants you a copy of the game to play across multiple device types that run Steam, Play Anywhere only grants you the PC version via the windows store (which nobody in their right mind wants to use) and Xbox consoles (the less said about that the better).

You are literally only getting access within the same store that Microsoft themselves own (for example, you are not also being granted, Linux, steam, playstation, etc versions of that game). Which, incidentally, is exactly the same thing Steam has been doing with Steam play since 2010 (although they did make an exception with the PS3 version of portal 2).

"New to Xbox" does not mean it's new to the industry. But we've been here many times before, just as when people really tried to tell us gamepass was the first gaming subscription to ever exist.
 
Last edited:

Astray

Member
By the way "play anywhere", doesn't really mean play anywhere either.
I also think Crossbuy was a thing for some PS4/Vita games too, but not sure if that came before or after MS's initiative..
 

Three

Gold Member
It's not going to be a debloated, optimized version of Windows running like clockwork, you'll be dealing with all of the downsides or their current OS. Microsoft can't make a good version of W11 for desktop users, why would they succeed with a niche portable hardware.
That's a good point. I think there is a possibility where MS are going to try and do it for both. As in license out the "xboxOS" as a competitor to SteamOS on any machine.
 
Seems a bit stupid to meld 'the best parts' of both together for gaming when Xbox OS already exists and would be fine for a handheld gaming device. Seems like work for the sake of work.
 
It's not going to be a debloated, optimized version of Windows running like clockwork, you'll be dealing with all of the downsides or their current OS. Microsoft can't make a good version of W11 for desktop users, why would they succeed with a niche portable hardware.
I don’t know this gives me more hope than some of the earlier articles that came out. Yeah it will run on Windows background but should be more streamlined. I mean Steam OS is just a front end for Linux. If you look at it from a workflow perspective shifting the Xbox os team to work on this as the main all in one system seems like a smart path. MS seems to be fully aware of the threat of Steam OS. If they can put a somewhat competent tailored release out this would be a huge boon for pc gaming.

Not everyone wants to have just one pc for everything, especially since general office pcs are so cheap now. Unless you are in a super high computational field i.e. analytics,media based,etc,plus a lot off that now can be offset to the cloud).

Yeah we will have the Xbox storefront flash first but it sounds like Windows now where you can install other storefronts this could be huge. A lot of people including me would probably jump out of the console space mostly if something like this were to come out. MS is starting to understand that they have to be more flexible in the gaming space like the PC space. That’s why Windows won vs Apple in the 80s and continues to be the dominant OS.
 
Last edited:

Punished Miku

Human Rights Subscription Service
Seems a bit stupid to meld 'the best parts' of both together for gaming when Xbox OS already exists and would be fine for a handheld gaming device. Seems like work for the sake of work.
nah, it would be awesome. I think people would be creaming themselves if Sony was doing this. The ability to take your console experience to virtually any device is pretty appealing.
 

TBiddy

Member
I'd like you to explain how you think Steam Play is any different.

You buy a game on Steam and it allows you to play the game across all hardware where the Steam store is officially available for playing games (Windows, Mac and Linux).

You buy a game on Xbox and it allows you to play the game across all hardware where the windows/xbox store is officially available (windows and Xbox consoles).

Just as Steam play only grants you a copy of the game to play across multiple device types that run Steam, Play Anywhere only grants you the PC version via the windows store (which nobody in their right mind wants to use) and Xbox consoles (the less said about that the better).

You are literally only getting access within the same store that Microsoft themselves own (for example, you are not also being granted, Linux, steam, playstation, etc versions of that game). Which, incidentally, is exactly the same thing Steam has been doing with Steam play since 2010 (although they did make an exception with the PS3 version of portal 2).

"New to Xbox" does not mean it's new to the industry. But we've been here many times before, just as when people really tried to tell us gamepass was the first gaming subscription to ever exist.

I assume you've accepted that the adaptive controller was groundbreaking. So far, so good.

Steam Play was designed to allow certain games to be playable on both Windows, Linux and macOS, using different executables, meaning the game had to be supported on all the platforms or emulated via Proton.
Play Anywhere is a marketing name for games running on both Windows... and Windows on Xbox, allowing you to play a lot of games on both your PC and your console with a single purchase.

I trust you see the difference.

As for when "people tried to tell us gamepass was the first gaming subscription", I couldn't care less. If you want to fight someone about that, go find someone who said that.

Also Xbox Live over the PS2's wild west of online infrastructure, something PSN and NSO would adopt later.

Agreed. But we both know that GHG will never accept that, because online gaming previously existed. Going by his logic Blu-Ray wasn't an innovation, since discs weren't new. DualSense wasn't innovative. The SSD in the PS5 wasn't innovative. Nothing about the new consoles are innovative.

Flatscreen TV's? Not innovative. Just an iteration of existing TV's.

Nowadays the best of Windows is that it can run Steam. Is there something else?

From a consumer standpoint? I don't think so. Most people would probably be better of with a Mac.
 
Last edited:

Punished Miku

Human Rights Subscription Service
Nowadays the best of Windows is that it can run Steam. Is there something else?
Imagine you're playing on Xbox now. Now you also have everything on Steam, all the Epic free games, and the convenience of a great console system UI focused on controller friendly interface, and access to GP, synced up cloud saves everywhere, and rewards points integration for free money. Is there even anything else to have at that point? That's pretty much everything.

MS really couldn't even do anything else at that point but just further optimize performance.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom