I can't wait for dLMN8R to come in here and explain how terrible this would be.
You have this weird infatuation with me. Not sure if I should be flattered or creeped the fuck out.
At the very least, it might help your case if you ever once admitted that you don't think through anything enough to reach proper conclusions instead of always striking out with half-baked opinions.
I think this mock-up looks great, actually. It's the first one that actually looks feasible to do without breaking two decades of backwards compatibility.
The problem, of course, is that it still requires a dramatic overhaul of everything on the desktop. The final RTM skin isn't as pretty, but it's also not ugly, looks a hell of a lot better than the RP, and was also probably 1% of the work it would have required to implement the mocked-up theme.
Some things to think about that most people never do:
- How much code change is required to fundamentally overhaul a standardized piece of UI? (Ribbon layout)
- How would all of this scale to different DPIs?
- How possible would it be to localize all of this? Some languages take up 2-3x the physical space as English. How would those languages fit in this UI?
- How would this UI work with right-to-left languages like Hebrew or Arabic? Would they work at all?
- How would this UI work with screen readers and other accessibility factors? If the entire UI needs to be overhauled, so does the behind-the-scenes support for these tools.
I'm not saying that mockup is impossible or bad in any way. But what it is, is expensive and immensely risky to implement. At the end of the day, I don't personally think it's *THAT* much better, and I certainly don't think it's worth cutting some other piece of work to implement this instead.