-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Winter Anime 2016 |OT| Celebrating the New Year and PSO2's release in the west!
- Thread starter BGBW
- Start date
- Status
Cornbread78
Member
Id agree with this to an extent that Hinazuki's character is somewhat limited so far to "feel sorry for this character" and maybe trying to fit everything into 1 cour will have that kind of rushed result.
But at the same time its only been 4 episodes so any complaint could easily be fixed in a future episode. They still have plenty of time to flesh out characters more.
Towa no Quon-2
I don't know what emotion they were going for. Was I supposed to feel bad for the kid despite him mostly acting like a psychopath? This wasn't portrayed in any sort of interesting and nuanced manner. Not to mention the animation took a noticeable step down.
My mother's garden must be that dimension from Event Horizon then.
Alternatively one of his victims would havebeen turned into a horror from the abuse and eaten him, and they would have to put the horror down!
Better than Garo Crimson Moon, that's for sure!
hosannainexcelsis
Member
I haven't seen episode 4 yet, but the scenes in episode 2 with Satoru asking her to become friends and the scene in episode 3 with Satoru taking her to see the "Christmas" tree did enough to establish her as a character who isn't solely defined by her abuse. (While acknowledging that someone in her situation - well - abuse makes up a large part of what she knows.) I agree that the scene in episode 3 with Kayo at home, where Satoru was not present, was unnecessary, but I don't feel like that scene invalidates the rest of the show.
The third episode is definitely worse.
I'm assuming Aikawa is just shitting out scripts for Crimson Moon without really caring about them, since it seems so unambitious even when compared to his less successful works such as Un-Go and Eureka 7 AO.
Basileus777
Member
All this Towa no Quon talk in recent weeks had me interested in watching it. Now I'm rethinking that.
If half of it isn't bad, it just isn't anime!
hosannainexcelsis
Member
I liked the second episode better than Jarmel, for what that's worth.
So this is why non-anime watchers don't consider Ghibli films anime.
So um hunter x hunter episode 95
Gon at the end there with jajenkin was fucking completely lost......he was about to go full enraged gohan on the master. Its the first time I've seen him actually just say fuck all life and thought. Also can't wait to see the old man face the king.....I absolutely love the chairman's character. Killua being off the curse is awesome as well. This ending feels likes it's going to be goooooooooooddd
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
Symphogear GX Specials 01
They mentioned the space shuttle at the beginning of GX so I went back and rewatched that scene and now I regret not putting GX on my aoty list
Me when still no Symphogeah s4
They mentioned the space shuttle at the beginning of GX so I went back and rewatched that scene and now I regret not putting GX on my aoty list
Erased: 4
A very heartwarming episode, Satoru tried his best this whole episode. Like the end of the previous episode it was nice seeing them have a good time together even if Kayos mother tried to ruin it, glad Satorus mother came through. Speaking of Kayos mother, they can chill with the red eyes. But yeah the rest of episode was good with the party and Kayos intention of giving Satoru a scarf. Of course that fuzzy feeling was shattered with those last couple of seconds. He looked horrified.
Ah, I wonder whats going on inside his head though with the slip ups and the memories.
Shoujo-tachi wa Kouya wo Mezasu: 4
Well after that meeting Buntarou probably created one annoying ass character.
Assassination Classroom S2: 4
I enjoyed this episode a lot. Itona is fitting in pretty well so far and the second half with the nicknames was pretty funny.
A very heartwarming episode, Satoru tried his best this whole episode. Like the end of the previous episode it was nice seeing them have a good time together even if Kayos mother tried to ruin it, glad Satorus mother came through. Speaking of Kayos mother, they can chill with the red eyes. But yeah the rest of episode was good with the party and Kayos intention of giving Satoru a scarf. Of course that fuzzy feeling was shattered with those last couple of seconds. He looked horrified.
Ah, I wonder whats going on inside his head though with the slip ups and the memories.
Shoujo-tachi wa Kouya wo Mezasu: 4
Well after that meeting Buntarou probably created one annoying ass character.
Assassination Classroom S2: 4
I enjoyed this episode a lot. Itona is fitting in pretty well so far and the second half with the nicknames was pretty funny.
Basileus777
Member
The must be coming back to the series present. Unless they don't get to adapt it in the episodes given I imagine it is more than a framing device.
Cornbread78
Member
Evangelion ep.10-11
Asuka is a real uppity douche huh? Well, she does get rid of the tsundere crap once in awhile like she did at the end of ep.11 to help get rid of that angel. I mean, she finally came up with a good plan to beat it with Rei and Shinji. Weird how it's almost the halfway point and they still haven't even started breaking down where the Angels cone from and what they are.
Asuka is a real uppity douche huh? Well, she does get rid of the tsundere crap once in awhile like she did at the end of ep.11 to help get rid of that angel. I mean, she finally came up with a good plan to beat it with Rei and Shinji. Weird how it's almost the halfway point and they still haven't even started breaking down where the Angels cone from and what they are.
hosannainexcelsis
Member
The flashback arc lasts from mid-volume 2 to volume 5, according to a manga reader I've heard from, and the manga is currently up to 8 volumes, so yes, it's not just a framing device.
Basileus777
Member
Do you know at what rate they are going through the source material? As much as I like this flashback arc, I'd be disappointed if we didn't get to see much of the present again in the anime.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Mr. Nietzsche in the Convenience Store Episode 2
I wish sometimes that some of the jokes wouldnt last as long as do, a few end up leading to many moments of awkward silence. Though Nii-kun makes everything awkward, but still some go on for too long.
Laughed the most from Lottery-senpai and everyone thinking Matsukomo would be the type to panic and break down from a robbery whill Nii kun would try to fight them back.
I wish sometimes that some of the jokes wouldnt last as long as do, a few end up leading to many moments of awkward silence. Though Nii-kun makes everything awkward, but still some go on for too long.
Laughed the most from Lottery-senpai and everyone thinking Matsukomo would be the type to panic and break down from a robbery whill Nii kun would try to fight them back.
hosannainexcelsis
Member
I haven't read the manga so I can't say, though according to the same source the anime is doing a fair bit of reordering/deleting/adding. I do feel fairly confident that the anime won't spend the rest of its time exclusively on the flashback.
Admiral Woofington
Member
Please do watch towa no quon so we can make the AnimeGAF feel rock emotion concerto
Why on Earth would you want to do that? The first episode was one the biggest snorefests I've ever seen.
Hellwarden
Member
Dagashi Kashi Episode 4
First off, lewd.
The first part of the episode was considerably more enjoyable than the second. The second part didn't really have much going for it, and ended on a pretty limp note.
First off, lewd.
The first part of the episode was considerably more enjoyable than the second. The second part didn't really have much going for it, and ended on a pretty limp note.
Basileus777
Member
So which half of this is supposed to be good then?
Branduil hates anime. He doesn't even watch it anymore!
Clearly they're saving for the OVA where Eli graduates from µ's and gets married to the boyfriend she's been keeping a secret for months.
Hmm, I just don't think those scenes helped her as a character. Satoru's heroic obsession kinda makes it so that even when they're interacting, there's little to tell about her other than her vulnerability and position (as in, needing to be saved by him), and her reactions to his advances isn't enough to flesh her out. I think most people just go 'she's cute' and doesn't that just feed into her portrayal as a poor little girl?
I'm not saying it invalidates the rest of the show, but it does lessen it. Now she's gone and presumably discarded and there's not much to remember her by, other than that she was abused, and that her failure will prob drive Satoru to do whatever the fuck he does in the future.
hosannainexcelsis
Member
Since I ended up going and spoiling myself on the manga, I had better refrain from commenting further.
man that sounds like time travel. I just hope it doesn't get super silly.
It's going to be Primer and you'll like it!
I'll just set my expectations low and hope that Kenya isn't Satoru's mom from the future past or something.
nintendoman58
Member
Man, he must have liked Shirobako and Euphonium so much that he decided to stop watching anime all together to never get rid of the taste they left in his mouth.
What a shame, he'll never know the joy of Gundam Build Fighters now. ;_;
Basileus777
Member
I'm so conflicted. But I'll at least check out the first episode. Though first I need to watch that Escaflowne film.
I get what you're saying but I think this is a consequence of two things - the majority of the show being from Satoru's perspective, and his very narrow focus in terms of objectives. In the future, he remembers Kayo as the weird girl no on talked to who got killed. His conclusion is that if only he got to know her better, maybe he could prevent that from happening. But his aim seems very superficial. The way he approaches the problem is that he imposes himself into her life to act as a deterrent. He doesn't seem to know what she likes, or what she really wants, it is more important for him to just be there so she "has a friend" because he believes that loneliness is the main factor that resulted in her demise.
On the other hand, Satoru isn't really all that interested in his other friends, they're just there. So because he's not focused on them, the perspective is distanced from what they do day to day, and in any fictional narrative, absence can make a character feel more real because we can assume and fill in that when they're not around, they presumably have their own lives and do their own things instead of revolving around the protagonist. Since Satoru is essentially stalking Kayo, we get a sense of what appears to be her entire daily life cycle, which turns out to be really one-dimensional because of her anti-social nature and the abusive environment she's in.
I think this form of presentation is fine, except for the fact that the show can't stick entirely to that and still feels the need to have fill-in scenes which are out of perspective from Satoru. That's probably why so scenes feel so distracting.
I dunno. The first trailer for the show had like a gazillion scenes of Satoru and Kayo hanging out together in all sorts of places. I doubt that part of the story is anywhere near done.
Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinju 4
I think the honeymoon might be over for me. It looks as though my guess from last week was on the mark, as they do seem to be heading into
Interest is quickly fading, hopefully the next episode surprises me.
I think the honeymoon might be over for me. It looks as though my guess from last week was on the mark, as they do seem to be heading into
a love triangle tearing the friendship apart; just watching Shin's reaction to Bon revealing his invitation seems to confirm it.
Interest is quickly fading, hopefully the next episode surprises me.
Crash Station
Member
Edit: not talking about same show.
hosannainexcelsis
Member
Basileus777 was talking about Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu there, not Erased.
victreeb3l
Member
Yo Yuki Kajiura did the soundtrack for ERASED too? This is like GOAT tier anime.
Just caught up on all 4 episodes. My mind and heart is a mess. Need time to write coherent impressions but this series is absolutely fantastic so far.
Just caught up on all 4 episodes. My mind and heart is a mess. Need time to write coherent impressions but this series is absolutely fantastic so far.
hosannainexcelsis
Member
Concrete Revolutio 7
I teared up at the end there. Earth-chan is great, both as a character in her own right and as another lens with which to examine the morality of this world.
I like how the show is treating the "hippie" student protests. The only other anime I'm aware of that treats the student protests of the 1960s is Kids on the Slope, and it did so in a pretty lame way, so I'm glad to see it handled better here.
About the next episode preview, of course Ken Ootsuka would handle the episode focused on a classic-style mecha.
I teared up at the end there. Earth-chan is great, both as a character in her own right and as another lens with which to examine the morality of this world.
I like how the show is treating the "hippie" student protests. The only other anime I'm aware of that treats the student protests of the 1960s is Kids on the Slope, and it did so in a pretty lame way, so I'm glad to see it handled better here.
About the next episode preview, of course Ken Ootsuka would handle the episode focused on a classic-style mecha.
AquaWateria
Member
This comment is making me curious but at the same time it's making me feel really nervous.
Crash Station
Member
Admiral Woofington
Member
the final episode alone is worth watching for the fantastic fight scenes. It's not a tough show to follow or finish either really. Its biggest issue is that characters are fucking stupid.
Towa no Quon 5
I managed to watch this after finishing Inside Out (which was great by the way), so Ill use that as a template.
Joy:
Sadness:
Disgust:
Anger:
Fear: The last episode could be really bad.
I managed to watch this after finishing Inside Out (which was great by the way), so Ill use that as a template.
Joy:
Ah, how Ive missed this Burning Rock Emotion! The soundtrack is still sounding good throughout the episode. Look at Yuuma coming through in the beginning that was nice. And there were some cool action scenes here and there with Cybernetic Pyro and Quon. Oh and Towa is still in one piece so maybe a happy reunion is in store for Quon.
Sadness:
The old lady didnt deserve that, thought she was about to have some Attack of the Clones Yoda skills when she got up, but the barrier was good even though she got sucked up or whatever in the end.
Disgust:
Miu is still around. Quons bare ass in the dirt, thats not hygienic.Took less than 5 minutes and a half-finished monologue for Takao to say fuck them he out, at least let the monologue finish.
Anger:
Its cool they found a new place to go to right quick but still irritated how foolishly Quon let Fantasium Garden be destroyed in the first place. And did they even bother to check Cybernetic Pyro when he came to Sanadas fortress to make sure he couldnt be tracked? Also Kamashiro got powers too, its not really surprising just smh of course they over the top too.
Fear: The last episode could be really bad.
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
I said I dropped it but I actually watched the fourth Showa Rakugo episode and now I can let it go with no regrets, I still feel the same. I just can't find the appreciation for rakugo.
I'm watching Eureka 7 right now and this is the thanks I get?
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked