I'm guessing the new progression plan with no new "catch up" dungeons is as follows:
Raid Tier 1 LFR
Raid Tier 2 LFR
...
Latest Raid Tier LFR
Latest Raid Tier Normal
Latest Raid Tier Heroic
Is that about right?
If so, I'm definitely liking that plan more. I don't like having to skip a lot of raid content to catapult myself into the latest and greatest (I never saw Firelands, for example).
Well, it's kinda crappy, though. I understand the appeal of running old raids and stuff, but there's a problem in that
1- You'll have less people running them, so it'll take far longer to get into one
2- When you do manage to get into one, people will bitch that you're underperforming or
3- You'll run into a raid where nobody knows mechanics, you'll wipe on every boss or so at least once, and then it'll be really, REALLY sucky.
Seriously, LFR as a difficulty is interesting, but there are important problems with them, most notably that as people gear up, there's no reason to go back - at this current tier, you get more VP/hour doing heroics than LFR (much, MUCH more). If you're DPS it's worth it to chain run scenarios, too.
I'm a tank. I get insta-queue into Heroics. I can solo most of them without any trouble if I'm careful, so when I have a semi-competent healer, I can just chain pull everything. It's pretty ridiculous that you can do that when you get to the 2nd tier of raiding (and even then I could do it within the end of the first tier). First heroic of the day gives me 80VP, subsequent runs give me 40. I typically run a heroic within 10-15 mins, typically less if there are no events (I love getting the temple, because there's very little timed shit in it, but stuff like Shado-pan Monastery is shitty and takes forever).
If you count that, for the first hour, I get (80 + 3*40)VP, or 200. In an hour. Most LFR runs that aren't terrace take at least 30 minutes to run if not more due to wipes and shit.
So even counting doing different LFRs every time, you don't even really hit 200VP/hour doing it.
Then there's the problem of look, if we get someone new in our guild, we'll have to gear them the old fashioned way, running old raids just for gear for them, which is ridiculous, because not only is it not guaranteed to drop, but it's also a MASSIVE waste of time when we could be raiding current tier. If we wait for that person to get drops through LFR, then it'll take forever. The only other solution would be to run LFRs with that person to maximize the drops he can get, but then we need to be 25, not 10.
I like LFR as a way to gear up to current raids, but as a catch up mechanic, it's completely idiotic. What if you don't get the drops in LFR? You're fucked for a week while the rest of the playerbase advances and we're back to what Vanilla and BC were in terms of progression, which I don't think was a good model (despite one of the best raids of all time, Karazhan).