PvP was the shit back in the day, Vanilla and TBC, was way better than the 40 man raids lol. Facing off against a skilled team of coordinated players with a team of your own was a tad more skill based than
Frostbolt x 100 (double trinket sometime)
Evo
Frostbolt X 100 (double trinket sometime)
The only thing that sucked about Vanilla PVP was the Honor Grind, I never did it (lol fuck that, + I was raiding 4 nights a week, as if I could even if I wanted to) but I was invited into a lot of groups who did to help out when I was free, I felt sorry for what they had to go through, such a crime in a way.
And Arena was really fun for the first couple of seasons, 5's were anyway.
My fondest memories of raiding was getting down Twin Emps, great fight for the time, still doesn't compare to a lot of things from pvp back than.
Than what's your solution? There's always going to be a grind no matter how you spin it. And it's nothing like dailies, I mean fuck people where bitching about having to log in every day to progress via dailys and how they wanted to progress in their own time. That's what the Isle is, from the looks of it you get out of it what you put in. I'm sure some hardcore non raiders are going to get a lot of 535 epics in the first fortnight alone, that's their choice, and something they wanted. And it's not double gated by valor as well.