Fularu said:
Again no
You want steady constant, high DPS? you have to be fury, but you have very very low survavibility (yeah, even with plate)
You want great PVP? Go arms! But at the cost of steady DPS and some survavibility
You want survavibility? You go Prot and are forced to take the most useless talents in the game EVER. Improved sunder? Improved revenge? Improved shield bash? Improved disarm? (??????) forget it, the prot tree is complete and uter crap, and that's coming from someone who tanks up to AQ40.
As for "deserved nerfs" call me back when locks don't wipe the floor with every other class in this game in pvp..
I'd like to write up a big rebuttal to this, but I'll just lay out some simple facts. Warriors frequently top pve dps with fury (which is JUST FINE for pvp, it still has big burst, just not the big burst of arms) and arms still puts them ahead of pure dps casters, and neck and neck with hunters/rogues with equal gear (after the patch, rogues will be ahead though).
I don't think you get it, maybe because you play blizzard's most babied class in the game - warriors are the tanks and geared up to take the least damage of everyone, yet they can also deal the most damage. That flat out isn't right. Warriors should be below rogues, hunters, mages and locks for dps with a dps spec, period. Either that or blizz will have to go and make classes even more generic and allow every dps class to get enough damage absorption to tank equivalent to 390ish defense and 8k armor.
Prot talents may suck, but the fact that bosses are beaten by tanks who only go 15 points into prot shows that it's far more about gear than it is about spec. And it's not like they haven't let some previews of the prot tree slip anyway, such as vitality. Warriors are already the best class in the game, so when prot gets buffed they'll just be even more supreme. You may refuse to believe it, but warriors are practically spoiled compared to the real dps classes. Whine all you want about all the tank gear that drops... is ashkandi, kalimdor's, crol'shrukh, hell, even zin'rohk or OEB a tank drop? The only way those don't go to a warrior is if that warrior is so geared up they aren't interested in it.