ToyMachine228 said:
So does Righteous Defense work like a Warrior taunt as far as threat goes? Last time I knew, a Warrior taunt put the Warrior even with the threat of the highest person on the threat list permanently, not only for the duration of the taunt. Does the Paladin taunt work the same way, or is it only during the 8 seconds?
Warrior taunt only puts the warrior at the top of their target's threat for its duration. But if you use either of the 2 major threat generating skills (sunder or heroic strike) it will generally stick. Explaining it is pretty complicated, but I think there's a sticky about it on the WoW warrior forum. I believe the way it works is, if the warrior's #1 on the threat list, then taunt resets the threat list when someone else pulls aggro, putting the warrior back at #1 if they HS/sunder them. Really, though, I think it's just a temporary threat wipe, kind of like ice block but it affects all targets (including the warrior!).
I think Righteous Defense works similarly, but the reason why it's not as effective is prot pally tanking is a lot more reactive - far more threat is generated by using blessing of sanctuary + holy shield, though avenger's shield generates a lot of threat with improved righteous fury. But avenger's is used more for pulling, especially in BC where most packs in instances are at least 3 mobs.
Pally tanking basically follows this pattern:
Pre-pull) Buff yourself with blessing of sanctuary
1) Pull with avenger's shield
2) Consecration (similar to warriors using demo shout when everything's in range)
3) Holy shield
4) Seal of righteousness or Seal of crusader/judge your main target and then Seal of righteousness
As long as your group gives you a little time to establish initial aggro (just like letting a warrior sunder 2-3 times) you'll hold aggro on just about anything. When it's all set up, you block a lot because of Redoubt + Holy shield proccing, and each time you block it deals a lot of holy damage, which gets an extra 90% bonus in threat. So once stuff's beating on you, it's hard to pull it off. It's just that aside from Avenger's shield it can be hard to get initial aggro. It's really easy to hold aggro without the tab-sunder stuff most warriors do. The only problem with Righteous Defense is you can't just throw down an ability to generate a lot of threat right after taunting, like a warrior can with sunder/heroic strike.