TomServo said:
You really need to be told not to pull aggro?
Having tanked for several years now, I can assure you that Yes, yes they do. I've been in far too many groups where DPS lets loose while I'm en route to the mobs, even spamming AoE on trash mobs when Avenger's Shield only grabs aggro on three. Tanking is all about control, and people who don't grasp that concept generally lead to chaos.
And of course, the first thing clothies do when they pull aggro is
run away, in the opposite direction of the mob, which is usually the opposite direction of me. I've actually seen a mage throw down an AoE on Naxx Trash before a pull (I was marking targets), gain aggro, and then blink out of the room (and out of line of sight) and run for the exit. Funniest shit I've ever seen, we took control of the situation but we made sure he died before we booted him from the raid.
I've also had smart asses think "Pulling aggro off the tank" is equal to "Doing amazing DPS". It's not, and if the mood strikes, I usually let their mistake play out for the sake of education. I got tired of dragging idiots way back in Kara, so I tend to let people who should know better find out the hard way.
Already a bit of a long-winded post (by internet standards), but if there's one thing I wish people would learn is that aggro management is a team effort, and it's not just the tank's responsibility to make sure he has and holds threat. Everyone has to watch what they're doing and not destabilize situations.
Oh, a few more gems before I close;
Had a Ret Pally DPSing a Heroic many moons ago, using his PVP spec which included a few points in Protection. Including Improved Righteous Fury for the damage reduction, which he neglected to turn off. It was such a stupid thing to do, I didn't even think to look for it until the third time he blasted aggro off me after a solid pull. In that case, because it was a Paladin (and I like paladins, to a fault), I just whispered him to take it off. I hope he learned from it.
Had a dead weight huntard in my guild (he was an officer's dad or uncle, but basically useless and obnoxious) insist his pet could tank Heroic Black Morass (Back in TBC, so it wasn't even close to possible then). Not only that, but he insisted that I should heal his pet so it could do my job. I actually screen capped it, the officers couldn't believe it and he was quietly banned from raids. (I'm Eresia, btw)
And finally, I have actually had a Paladin cast Hand of Protection (Well, it was Blessing at the time) on me while tanking, because he didn't think the healer was going to be able to get to me in time, even though the situation was actually completely under control... or was, until my aggro (and the group) was wiped. He thought he was 'saving the group'... should have popped his suicide pill instead, that'd have at least been useful.