• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Xbox has a bright future ahead

Alebrije

Member
People saying those 4 games mean Xbox is back dont remember the era of Xbox 360 when Halo,Gears moved millions of copies...those 4 games together wont sell the same as Halo2.
 

CosmicComet

Member
that's a real shame, I wasn't really interested in South of Midnight before this, but it alongside that French turn based RPG looks pretty good honestly. There all single players games too which is great, not live service crap.
Zero interest in south of midnight.

I am mildly interested in Clair Obscur, but again it's multiplatform.

Nothing here got me interested in Xbox as a patform.
 
One thing I don’t get is, how is game pass and Xbox live going to survive without a console, as they seem to slowly shutting it down, what happens when cloud gaming dose not take off, what are they going to do then.
 

Three

Member
It's funny you say that...

South of Midnight - Future flop
Expedition 33 - Future flop
Ninja Gaiden Black 2 - Over/Under 1.5 million in sales?
Doom DA - Over/Under 3 million in sales?

Four titles that project to sell around 5 million copies is strong?

i%27ll-believe-it-when-i-see-it-marques-brownlee.gif
You're really underselling Doom DA.
 

SHA

Member
Microsoft is a software company,
Sony has no choice but to follow the same strategy and it's okay to be 2 steps behind.
 

ProtoByte

Weeb Underling
You could be right. I assumed it would sell worse than Eternal due to GamePass but it does have the open world effect possibly going for it. That gameplay didn't give me much confidence though.
I don't know if Doom is one of those games PC players will pump and dump Gamepass for.

It'll certainly eliminate Xbox sales, but that's a smaller proportion than PS and PC anyway.
 
Xbox as a brand/publisher? Sure. Xbox as a console? I just don't see how. They are actively working towards platform agnosticism which devalues their hardware.
Who cares? Good games are good games and that’s all anyone could really want. You own a PS5 because the games are good. Now, you are getting more good games. Why does anything else matter? You won no matter if there are 1 or 2 plastic boxes under your tv.
 
Last edited:

marquimvfs

Member
Well, dying people tend to "see the light" before they die. Maybe that's the bright future they're talking about.
 
Last edited:

IFireflyl

Gold Member
Who cares? Good games are good games and that’s all anyone could really want. You own a PS5 because the games are good. Now, you are getting more good games. Why does anything else matter? You won no matter if there are 1 or 2 plastic boxes under your tv.

I think if Microsoft leaves the console space then a lot of people will care. As pathetic as they have been, the Xbox was still competition to Sony's PlayStation. The Nintendo Switch is a completely different beast that really doesn't directly compete with PlayStation. Competition is what benefits consumers.
 

Ozzie666

Member
As a third party publisher, yes. But can they succeed without the current profits from their hardware, microtransactions, subscriptions and sales cuts form third parties on their own hardware? Their hardware install base is barely hanging on. Without that supporting income, what does Xbox look like? This is why I don't see them giving up hardware anytime soon. Even if they only seel 10-20 million consoles, it's still bringing in some cash they can use to make games.

What is xbox without dedicated hardware for their zealots? There comes a time if sales aren't great, the cost of R&D, promitions etc isn't worth it?
 

Esppiral

Member
Xbox brigh future? I don't see MS selling consoles when you can by the games elsewhere+ Sony exclusives, this is a shoot in the foot
 
What I don't understand is if hardware Xbox dies , what happens to gamepass sure as shit Nintendo and especially Sony won't allow gamepass on their console.
I mean if the console dies that makes gamepass s colosol level of failure even though it's still is the best value in gaming no questions asked
 
Yesterday’s show had me second guessing about PC plans.

I will probably be better served by an xbox console if they make one next. Xbox console + gamepass makes for great combination.

Can get pc handheld to cover some other games that I am interested in.
 

RaZoR No1

Member
I mean I agree with all posts that say that MS as a publisher shines or will shine and Xbox as a platform dies or will die...

The only way MS could save Xbox would be:
- release good or better games than Sony (building trust)
- Slowly put one hit after hit back to Xbox only or exclusive features etc.
- gamers want the good MS games (creating desire)
- gamers buy Xbox again
- ???
- profit

This would be a 5D Chess Move and probably impossible to make it work.
But currently nobody really buys an Xbox for its exclusives ...
 

Cakeboxer

Gold Member
I mean I agree with all posts that say that MS as a publisher shines or will shine and Xbox as a platform dies or will die...

The only way MS could save Xbox would be:
- release good or better games than Sony (building trust)
- Slowly put one hit after hit back to Xbox only or exclusive features etc.
- gamers want the good MS games (creating desire)
- gamers buy Xbox again
- ???
- profit

This would be a 5D Chess Move and probably impossible to make it work.
But currently nobody really buys an Xbox for its exclusives ...
No it won't work. Xbox could release 20 top exclusive games per year and it won't change a thing when it comes to hardware sales. Most casuals are just not interested in exclusives and those are the majority of the Xbox and PlayStation buyers. With Day1 Pc ports and xCloud you just can't sell consoles. Many who are interested in "exclusive" games have a pc and don't need an Xbox.

And even without they wouldn't have a chance. Playstation is the older brand with much more fans. The one chance Xbox had was when Sony fucked up the PS3, but Xbox fucked up the One even more. The only chance for the Xbox brand of "winning" is when consoles are in decline and gaming becomes streaming only. Then they are in a strong position with their studio setup and i don't think Sony could afford to make >300 milion dollar (or by that time probably even much more) games anymore.
 

Mibu no ookami

Demoted Member® Pro™
No it won't work. Xbox could release 20 top exclusive games per year and it won't change a thing when it comes to hardware sales. Most casuals are just not interested in exclusives and those are the majority of the Xbox and PlayStation buyers. With Day1 Pc ports and xCloud you just can't sell consoles. Many who are interested in "exclusive" games have a pc and don't need an Xbox.

And even without they wouldn't have a chance. Playstation is the older brand with much more fans. The one chance Xbox had was when Sony fucked up the PS3, but Xbox fucked up the One even more. The only chance for the Xbox brand of "winning" is when consoles are in decline and gaming becomes streaming only. Then they are in a strong position with their studio setup and i don't think Sony could afford to make >300 milion dollar (or by that time probably even much more) games anymore.

People don't realize that "system sellers" don't really exist anymore and they haven't in a long time with few exceptions: like GTA6. Some games might be system sellers regionally like Black Myth Wukong in China and Monster Hunter Wilds in Japan.

Games largely sell based on the strength of the platform not the other way around.

For Xbox to have a true system seller they would need a ground shattering game that was only available on Xbox and not on PC. They've really never known how to make games like this and to be fair it's super hard to make.

GTA
COD
Pokemon
Mario Kart
Smash Bros
Minecraft
Roblox
Fortnite


These games largely come out once a generation across all publishers. Even popular games like Cyberpunk or Elden Ring do not match up. Microsoft owns Minecraft but it still a multiplatform game and probably would diminish on Xbox only.

There is too much competition for single player and multiplayer games, so unless you're doing something drastically new, you're going to struggle to break through.

Half these games are as popular as they are because they're on every platform or multiple platforms. Like Hogwarts Legacy. Had it been a PS5 exclusive, it would have moved a couple more units, but it would have lost more than half of its sales as a result. Microsoft would love if they could create a game half as popular as Hogwarts Legacy and even that wouldn't have saved Xbox.
 
As a publisher, starting with Indy I'm more interested in stuff coming from Xbox's side than Sony and maybe even Nintendo ( of course I don't know what's coming out on Switch 2 but I'm not personally frothing at the mouth for any Mario or Zelda content at present. Metroid Prime 4, absolutely).

As a console, pretty much dead in the water. Being mostly into PC nowadays, I'm good however they choose to slice it.
 

StereoVsn

Gold Member
Yesterday’s show had me second guessing about PC plans.

I will probably be better served by an xbox console if they make one next. Xbox console + gamepass makes for great combination.

Can get pc handheld to cover some other games that I am interested in.
PC GamePass would work just as well and have a ton more flexibility. Main issue is the stupid pricing on GPUs due to Nvidia’s greed and AMD’s incompetence.
 
Last edited:
PC GamePass would work just as well and have a ton more flexibility. Main issue is the stupid pricing on GPUs due to Nvidia’s greed and AMD’s incompetence.
Of course.

This is purely OCD issue on my part but I would prefer to use steam on PC. Some reports of lower fps on GP games, some reports of bugs etc… but admittedly I haven’t used it myself.

GP on consoles I have used and find it to be great experience.
 

Humdinger

Gold Member
I really don't see how it [GP] survives longterm without an active console, where most of the ongoing subscribers are. I'm not going go resubscribe when my remaining stacked months expire on a dead platform. If they're leaving hardware, they need to get it on PS5 or Switch 2, but that won't happen.

Where will Microsoft get their 30% cut without consoles? I don’t think the MS store on PC gets nearly as many buyers. Also, what about GamePass since the majority of them are on consoles? I don’t feel GamePass will grow much (I’m sure it would shrink) without some type of Xbox hardware?
These are the questions that always seem to come to me when people say the hardware is dead and they’ll go complete third-party/publisher next gen. 🧐 🤷

One thing I don’t get is, how is game pass and Xbox live going to survive without a console, as they seem to slowly shutting it down, what happens when cloud gaming dose not take off, what are they going to do then.

You are correct. It makes little sense for MS to exit the hardware market this gen and leave their largest GP base with nowhere to jump next gen.

However, MS will not be doing that. MS will be offering a next gen console - most likely, two of them. One will be a handheld console. That one is already confirmed. The other will be a higher-end console/hybrid aimed at a more niche audience willing to foot the bill (it's rumored to be $1000+). The latter has been more or less confirmed by reliable sources (e.g., Sneakers and Heisenberg).
 

IFireflyl

Gold Member
Nah, they are already making more console generations. They aren't going to leave the console space.

Nobody said they are leaving the console space "right now". It's not like I expect them to call it quits immediately. What I implied is that, long-term, what they are doing devalues their consoles, and that will result in them leaving the console space eventually.
 
Top Bottom