• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

No skin thick enough: the daily harassment of women in the game industry

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 47027
  • Start date Start date
"Boy's club" isn't a binary value. When people use that phrase, they're referring to the dominating trends on GAF, and not insinuating that every single poster on the board is part of this "club", which is ludicrous. The very reason this is an issue is because this mentality is hostile to particular members on this board.

And this isn't a recent thing. If you have been on GAF for the past few years, you would've already seen the signs with regards to shifts in moderation policies and postingrules. The new crackdown, in this thread and in other threads, have been a long time coming.

I do know it isn't labelling all guys but it does seem it. I am against the labelling of things rather then who it is actually labelling. I to tend to not post in threads were a few guys are going on about their random fantasies. Instead of labelling it boys club etc it should be labelled what it actually is.
 
I'm not sure if you I'm having a problem comprehending something simple but help me out... What happens if someone contacts a mod because they feel excluded? I mean is this specific cases or something?

If they contact me, I'll go to the thread wherein they felt they had an issue and moderate according to our policies. There should be NO threads where people don't feel welcome to join. If that's happening somewhere -- and we know it does, particularly in some of the more insular community topics -- let us know and we'll check it out.
 
Why though? When did hate on the internet become so commonplace that it became acceptable?

It is not acceptable, but it has been tolerated for so long that the ones who perpetrate it feel safe that they are untouchable. That whole article turns my stomach, but I do realize that this is a common thing, and that is scary.
 
It's much more likely to be the result of the socially conditioned range of responses. These are learned behaviors. Women have the same impulses. I don't assume you're suggesting that men physiologically can't control themselves, but it seems to be an unintended corollary to your point. Women don't "desire" any less.
There was that interesting bit on This American Life about a transman who was currently in transition and receiving his first, very high, testosterone dosage. It does seems to have changed his sexuality a lot

Alex Blumberg
What were some of the changes that you didn't expect?

Griffin Hansbury
The most overwhelming feeling is the incredible increase in libido and change in the way that I perceived women and the way I thought about sex. Before testosterone, I would be riding the subway, which is the traditional hotbed of lust in the city. And I would see a woman on the subway, and I would think, she's attractive. I'd like to meet her. What's that book she's reading? I could talk to her. This is what I would say.

There would be a narrative. There would be this stream of language. It would be very verbal.

After testosterone, there was no narrative. There was no language whatsoever. It was just, I would see a woman who was attractive or not attractive. She might have an attractive quality, nice ankles or something, and the rest of her would be fairly unappealing to me.

But that was enough to basically just flood my mind with aggressive, pornographic images, just one after another. It was like being in a pornographic movie house in my mind. And I couldn't turn it off. I could not turn it off. Everything I looked at, everything I touched, turned to sex.

I was an editorial assistant. And I would be standing at the Xerox machine, and this big, shuddering, warm, inanimate object would just drive me crazy. It was very erotic to me.
http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/220/transcript

Unfortunately seem many studies on the subject inconclusive due to many outside factors. Many coming from society like you already mentioned.

I don't mean to say that it drives men into blind sex machines, but there does seem to be an inherent difference between female and male sexuality.
 
? That's not what I said it did... it causes a sex drive and aggressiveness. Ya it depends on how it is controlled in how it manifests but it leads to men being more assertive and also a good portion of men to become uncofortably assertive and some are rude... depends on a number of factors. Depends on the levels too, some guys produce more than others. Education and personal training too... lots of factors on how this manifests.

What I was saying is that women don't have this, they don't seem to have this drive. That's why I find it odd to equate women being sexually harassed with men being sexually harassed... I suppose I've been 'sexually harassed' by men too... but I don't feel scared because of it.

When you say "lead to women being harassed more than men" ... that implies an inequality, to me, an easily correctable inequality, but I see differences between the sexes.
Dude, you're assuming way too much based on a hormone.
 
Some new Internet bullying laws are at least a step in the right direction... Especially to protect young people you read some of these stories and it blows your mind how insecure people are, devoting this much time to harassing other people.
 
It is not acceptable, but it has been tolerated for so long that the ones who perpetrate it feel safe that they are untouchable. That whole article turns my stomach, but I do realize that this is a common thing, and that is scary.

It became pervasive through the same arguments we see trotted out here - you can't do anything about it, so just ignore it. So people grew to tolerate it over time and the cycle just repeats itself over and over.
 
Are stuff like waifu and husbando things or Chie wars or whatever offensive too? I always thought of them as silly fun, but I really don't want to make people feel excluded.
 
Please...PLEASE! Stop with the #NotallMen defenses in this thread.

Please.

If you feel the article was a personal affront, then take a second to cool down and try and apply some critical thought. If after that, you still feel aggrieved, then it probably says more about you than you think.
 
Dude, you're assuming way too much based on a hormone.

I'm not assuming, it's how I felt. I never raped women or harassed women, I was brought up to always be gentlemanely. What I don't like these days is women seem to brush that off as "whatever that's not how you should feel..."... Ask the 17 year old guys on here... it's rough.
 
Are stuff like waifu and husbando things or Chie wars or whatever offensive too? I always thought of them as silly fun, but I really don't want to make people feel excluded.

Waifu and husbandos are definitely just jokes except for some Gaffers who sometimes take it too far. I don't take any of those threads seriously.
 
Are stuff like waifu and husbando things or Chie wars or whatever offensive too? I always thought of them as silly fun, but I really don't want to make people feel excluded.

not making a statement on policy, but for my own part I recoil any time I read "waifu". incidentally, beyond that, uh, some japanese games played and discussed on these forums I find to be genuinely creepy. I may catch flak for that. but whatever.
 
not making a statement on policy, but for my own part I recoil any time I read "waifu". incidentally, beyond that, uh, some japanese games played and discussed on these forums I find to be genuinely creepy. I may catch flak for that. but whatever.

Yeah, sometimes it's downright unsettling. Especially if said "Waifu" looks underage.
 
I'd like to hope that NeoGaf is at least more inclusive of women than other sites, or at least, is trying to be.

There are many places online that are far less inclusive to both men and women, so hopefully we can make Gaf much more inclusive.
 
I'd like to hope that NeoGaf is at least more inclusive of women than other sites, or at least, is trying to be.

There are many places online that are far less inclusive to both men and women, so hopefully we can make Gaf much more inclusive.

I feel more comfortable posting and discussing these issues on NeoGAF than, say, IGN or Gamespot or GiantBomb forums, if that clears anything up.
 
It's still really tough to deal with. I agree with your point, but women brush off just how controlling it is. You literally feel like you're losing your mind (ask the teenage guys on here).

That's basically why 25 and over clubs exist. They don't let the younger guys in who haven't completed puberty.
 
I feel more comfortable posting and discussing these issues on NeoGAF than, say, IGN or Gamespot or GiantBomb forums, if that clears anything up.

GAF is pretty much one of the best moderated gaming forums. I cannot deal with forums in those gaming sites. People get away with pretty terrible insulting comments.
 
I have worked at two AAA studios and I can happily say that I always view criticism from both male and female members of staff equally. Some of my closer friends from these companies are female - I don't understand all the hate.
 
not making a statement on policy, but for my own part I recoil any time I read "waifu". incidentally, beyond that, uh, some japanese games played and discussed on these forums I find to be genuinely creepy. I may catch flak for that. but whatever.

Really? I just always saw the whole waifu/husbando thing as a way of kind of being silly about fictional characters we think are cute or have stupid little crushes on. I know some folks are all about being creepy about that stuff, but I always thought that was just part of fandom and something that both guys and girls participate in. Like, not even in really a sexual way. Just a silly way to sort of joke about characters we like.

However, the underage stuff can gtfo.
 
If a girl says something to me in a game I take it equally as if a man said it. However, generally girls have been more polite than the general populace of men in my case.

Am I special or something? The days where someone gets called out negatively for being a female without everyone jumping on her date around...well, on 2005 I already saw that attitude so.

Maybe it's cause no "Callo'Duty" in my life. Or maybe it's because i'm polite myself. I don't know.

However, as a server administrator I've had my fair share of threats that involved physically harming me. I got a phone call to my house from the guy. Many people wished me cancer. When speaking about women it seems like they go for the more sexual insult. it seems that even in their threats they don't find acceptable beating up a girl, but they wish for rape, murder and claim they will stalk them

I feel more comfortable posting and discussing these issues on NeoGAF than, say, IGN or Gamespot or GiantBomb forums, if that clears anything up.

it only natural. In the other sites it would take them 2 minutes to set up an account to insult you and act nice on their main.
 
Sorry, in America we have this thing called the first amendment. While there are forms of speech it does not protect (child porn, slander, libel, threats, "yelling fire in a crowded theater," etc.) gender/racial/homophobic slurs and other insults are protected. They kind of have to be, as you can't really ban "I think this woman is a [c-bomb] who should get back in the kitchen" without also banning "I don't like what the government is doing," because both are simply statements of opinion.


That's not what the first amendment means
 
It's still really tough to deal with. I agree with your point, but women brush off just how controlling it is. You literally feel like you're losing your mind (ask the teenage guys on here).
This comes off as another variation of the "boys will be boys" excuse, which I don't buy. It's just a hormone, dude.
 
This type of behaviour bothers me too.

I mean it's one thing to call Samus, Peach, Zelda etc a waifu and it's easier to accept. But some others? Namely ones with exaggerated breasts, or their scantily clad and clearly look like a 7~13 year old kid... that's disturbing.
 
This comes off as another variation of the "boys will be boys" excuse, which I don't buy. It's just a hormone, dude.

still just a hormone when a woman has pms and bites off everyones head over nothing?

You're being dismissive of his statements and wouldnt it go both ways?
 
Really? I just always saw the whole waifu/husbando thing as a way of kind of being silly about fictional characters we think are cute or have stupid little crushes on. I know some folks are all about being creepy about that stuff, but I always thought that was just part of fandom and something that both guys and girls participate in. Like, not even in really a sexual way. Just a silly way to sort of joke about characters we like.

I think there's a whole sector/aspect of some japanese games (and other media) that seems completely "not okay" to me, so "not okay" that I don't really like making it fun and cuddly by jokingly using terms that refer to it.

again, I'm getting into a dangerous area here, because this sector is also populated by the blurriest of lines and if we started trying to name names and parse things out we'd end up twisted in knots. I just know there's something that's, in my view, not okay.

still just a hormone when a woman has pms and bites off everyones head over nothing?

awesome...
 
This comes off as another variation of the "boys will be boys" excuse, which I don't buy. It's just a hormone, dude.

I'm not excusing bad behaviour... what i'm saying is there's an attitude from women that this doesn't matter and that men and women are equal. That's not the case. There's no bad/good, right/wrong with it... but men/women are different.
 
I mean it's one thing to call Samus, Peach, Zelda etc a waifu and it's easier to accept. But some others? Namely ones with exaggerated breasts, or their scantily clad and clearly look like a 7~13 year old kid... that's disturbing.

I agree, I don't understand the 7yo with breasts waifu fetishists... as a parent I find them deeply disturbing.
 
I'd like to hope that NeoGaf is at least more inclusive of women than other sites, or at least, is trying to be.

There are many places online that are far less inclusive to both men and women, so hopefully we can make Gaf much more inclusive.

Though it's not yet ideal, NeoGAF is significantly better than less moderated forums out there. The mods do a good job keeping things on a higher level than many other forums. It is actually impressive considering how big NeoGAF is.

So I always find myself coming back because it's so much worse out there. NeoGAF is the only forum where I've "admitted" to being female. I avoid anything related to gender elsewhere.

But there is always room for improvement.
 
still just a hormone when a woman has pms and bites off everyones head over nothing?

You're being dismissive of his statements and wouldnt it go both ways?

nLjnRXs.gif
 
I think there's a whole sector/aspect of some japanese games (and other media) that seems completely "not okay" to me, so "not okay" that I don't really like making it fun and cuddly by jokingly using terms that refer to it.

again, I'm getting into a dangerous area here, because this sector is also populated by the blurriest of lines and if we started trying to name names and parse things out we'd end up twisted in knots. I just know there's something that's, in my view, not okay.

Now that you mention it, if you're talking about the creepy underage stuff I totally get it and you're right. I guess I've just always used the term for games like Harvest Moon or Fire Emblem Awakening, which have themselves been guilty of the creepier side of that from time to time.
 
This comes off as another variation of the "boys will be boys" excuse, which I don't buy. It's just a hormone, dude.

You are correct. A man's attraction to females is totally controllable (unless one has some kind of mental disorder/horrible example in being raised).

I'm incredibly attracted to women, as I should be, but I'd never act in anyway to harass or make them uncomfortable.

The "boys will be boys" excuse is total BS. Ones that act that way should have been taught some manners.

There's no excuse for acting like a massive jerk.
 
There was that interesting bit on This American Life about a transman who was currently in transition and receiving his first, very high, testosterone dosage. It does seems to have changed his sexuality a lot


http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/220/transcript

Unfortunately seem many studies on the subject inconclusive due to many outside factors. Many coming from society like you already mentioned.

I don't mean to say that it drives men into blind sex machines, but there does seem to be an inherent difference between female and male sexuality.

As I understand it, this person is going through the equivalent of puberty. Adolescent youths go through the same thing. It dies down eventually, though. I am not constantly aroused like I was when I was 14. I can essentially turn it off and on at will in adult hood.
 
I'm not excusing bad behaviour... what i'm saying is there's an attitude from women that this doesn't matter and that men and women are equal. That's not the case. There's no bad/good, right/wrong with it... but men/women are different.

This'll be the last time I say this because obviously I'm not getting anywhere, but men do not harass women more often because they have more testosterone. It's from a cultural environment of being able to get away with those kinds of comments and society tolerating that kind of behavior in many places.
 
Some new Internet bullying laws are at least a step in the right direction... Especially to protect young people you read some of these stories and it blows your mind how insecure people are, devoting this much time to harassing other people.

This is obviously good as not everyone can just "man up" and deal with the constant barrage of hate.

The thing is that these days it can get very personal very quickly as gaming accounts can be linked with Facebook and other social media, people tend to put themselves out there via streams and so on. I'm older now and I have means to deal with potential troublemakers. I think even though in some respects society has progressed, as a whole it might be tougher out there now for young people and females than what it was 10 years ago...
 
Why do junior members always rush to lemming themselves off cliffs in these types of threads?

You're looking at it wrong, these threads were designed to flush out the lemmings.
 
I don't want to be a major party pooper but if we're just talking about sexual advances women will always be "more harassed" than men...

As i've pointed out in this type of conversation before, i'm a male and i've been 'hit on' by more gay men than straight women in my life, by a large margine.

Difference is in the hormone make-up of the sexes.

I'm a gay man who has been asked out on more dates by women than gay men. Can we trade?

If they contact me, I'll go to the thread wherein they felt they had an issue and moderate according to our policies. There should be NO threads where people don't feel welcome to join. If that's happening somewhere -- and we know it does, particularly in some of the more insular community topics -- let us know and we'll check it out.

Mm. And this goes for any issue, not just someone who feels that there is an attempt to exclude them or drive them from a thread. And remember: If you didn't report something that bothered you when you saw it, you don't get to complain that they got away with murder later.

Of course, if you do PM a moderator and you don't get a response, this doesn't necessarily mean that it wasn't looked at. We sometimes forget to respond; we sometimes just fill a request and move on (e.g. name change); we sometimes look at it, decide the issue is so minor that it is manifestly absurd that they'd be whining about it in the first place and we can't think of a reason to dignify it with a response. There's nothing wrong with sending an alert to multiple moderators about an issue, though; it'll increase the likelihood that someone you send it to has time to look at it and will be able and willing to respond.
 
still just a hormone when a woman has pms and bites off everyones head over nothing?

You're being dismissive of his statements and wouldnt it go both ways?

People here will ridicule you. But I understand what you mean. pms means pain. And under painful circumstances one would react different to everything than, let's say, being cheerful.

But to all those saying wow/awesome/etc to this, do you think we're not in the least affected in our testosterone levels when playing? This can cloud our normal behavior. Some will even say shit to get relief, even if they regret it afterwards.

The only problem is the notion that people have that words are so full of value coming from a disgruntled person. Do you pay much attention to what an alcoholic person rambling on the streets says? would you get seriously offended?
 
Top Bottom