Never liked it as a massive fan of BK1 on N64. Gave it a second shot on XBLA, even earning all 200 achievement points. It still sucked despite the performance issues being ironed out. It's got a large world that occasionally is cleverly connected beyond the traditional 'hub', but suffers from an obscene level of minigames taking precedent over proper platfomer/environmental challenges. Some irritating traversal issues(again the big world can feel tedious to wander, especially with certain challenges timing you maneuvering throughout. Occasional jank and a more 'muted' color pallette compared to the lively original game.
Felt BK1 held up great on the XBLA re-release, but Tooie was a real step-down.