Help. I slept with a girl the first weekend of college this year after talking for about an hour and she seemed cool but she was in an open relationship and that night basically told me she felt weird about it and it would be best if she didn't do it again. Seemed like a pretty cut and dry one night stand situation.
That's your conclusion? She had you once and that's all she needed? No girl ever gets into a open relationship for the benefit of the boyfriend, its very much for her. "Hey beloved boyfriend, you are not getting enough at home, let's turn this into an open relationship because clearly I'm not enough for you!" No, this is about her having plausible deniability to "cheat" on her guy while she makes up her mind. She will make up her mind once she find a LTR-worthy guy. And you are right, that's not you (for whatever reason). You are right in moving on. But just realize something may happened that night that prevented this being an ongoing thing--I assure you, guilt is not the culprit here. Can't tell what with the details provided though.
I got in to a 2.5 month relationship a little bit after that ended in early December
Why?
... and then in January the girl randomly friended me on Facebook. Today I started messaging her about stuff and she's doing a good job of responding and is even doing those little things like adding 4 letters more on to the ends of words or whatever bs girls do these days.
She's invested. She could have faced rejection after messaging you. How does she know you don't probably have a GF? It took courage, and courage implies care.
She's really pretty and I wanna meet up again but I don't wanna be weird about it or misinterpret stuff. I'm not sure if I wanna get in to another relationship though.
That's because you don't.
What do I do here. Like I'd be cool becoming friends, or being fwb, or hell even going back to the not talking thing we had before or meeting up as an informal date - I just don't wanna make it weird.
Edit: also just to be 100% sure I should absolutely never ever ask her why she friend-ed me right? I'm curious but I feel like asking blatantly is a terrible idea.
Making it weird is nice guy code-word for "I don't want to get hurt and feel awkward by telling her what I really want."
There is nothing weird about wanting a FWB situation (which is what you want, by the way) and being forward about it.
Decisiveness is attractive. Hell, if anything, you'd be doing half the job for her; after all,
she reignited the conversation between you and her with no possible knowledge of your relationship status. Potential rejection was high. Girls usually only approach guys once they're comfortable with them.
Use this knowledge to understand that, in the end, you are giving her what she wants: your attention. Your attention, however, on your terms. As in, do not contort your desire. If what you want is a FWB situation, don't settle for friendship. You don't want to be friends with someone you find "really pretty". That's a inherently disingenuous relationship. If her desire doesn't align with yours, then you should move on.
So, you can initiate with something like this:
You: "Hey there"
Her: "Hi!"
You: "Do you have a curfew?"
Her: "No lol" / "No that I know of lol" / "What? No lol"
Her: "Why?"
You: "In case we run late"
Her: "Where are we going?" / "What are we doing?"
You: " " <wait an hour or so, she may text wanting to know>
You: "It's a surprise"
Then plan a date, preferably one that can lead to nice conversation and touching. A lounge, a park, or at your place. Doesn't have to be fancy, it just has to be intimate. Make it clear with your body language why she's there. And if necessary, verbalize it.