Did he need to put a "IMO" to signpost it for you?
I really think Overwatch deserves GoTY over Uncharted 4. It's historically unlikely.
- Thread starter Exploratory
- Start date
- Status
Did he need to put a "IMO" to signpost it for you?
Oddvintagechap
Banned
People love games like uncharted. Fancy Resturant.
Mainly cause they don't make games like uncharted.
There's a bunch of multiplayer shooters. It's fast food.
Mainly cause they don't make games like uncharted.
There's a bunch of multiplayer shooters. It's fast food.
2014 but yes, It should have. It was the best game in 2014.
anyone who disagrees is wrong 
Do you think that GAF goty has that much weight?
SaiyanRaoh
Member
Maybe they will stick an epic single player campaign in Overwatch in the next week or two. Maybe then it will be award worthy and I'll finally look at it.
JuanLatino
Member
and another thread where people voice their opinions as a fact.
Uncharted is overrated, Overwatch is overrated, Game X is overrated......
Uncharted aswell Overwatch are among the highest rated games in 2016 - and obviously many people had fun with these game.
on what basis is a game even overrated?
Just because you didn't like it? Is your opinion more worth than the opinion of people who loved these games?
Uncharted is overrated, Overwatch is overrated, Game X is overrated......
Uncharted aswell Overwatch are among the highest rated games in 2016 - and obviously many people had fun with these game.
on what basis is a game even overrated?
Just because you didn't like it? Is your opinion more worth than the opinion of people who loved these games?
Overwatch should probably win.
Uncharted 4 is great, but it's safe and doesn't really do anything new or interesting (beyond the jaw-dropping technical accomplishments).
I was so bored with DOOM that I quit like 2 hours in. I just don't see what everyone is gushing over.
I haven't played Titanfall 2 or Inside.
Uncharted 4 is great, but it's safe and doesn't really do anything new or interesting (beyond the jaw-dropping technical accomplishments).
I was so bored with DOOM that I quit like 2 hours in. I just don't see what everyone is gushing over.
I haven't played Titanfall 2 or Inside.
wapplew
Member
Walking dead won spike goty, demon soul won gamespot goty, those might have some weight.
Exploratory
Banned
Overwatch and Uncharted 4 came out right around the same time.
Lion Heart
Banned
I would love to see The Witness win, but U4 deserves it too.
Clearly the best two games of the year by a big margin.
Clearly the best two games of the year by a big margin.
I've played almost every one of the legit contenders besides Uncharted 4 and will have played it by the time the games season rolls around
I say titanfall 2 is the best game I've played this year, and I'm a huge Souls fan that platinumed Dark Souls 3.
Awesome Single Player, Memorable missions, fun gameplay mechanics and one of the best multiplayer games of the year.
I couldn't really get into Doom, and Overwatch is just a bunch of console players finally learning about Team Fortress 2 style games.
I say titanfall 2 is the best game I've played this year, and I'm a huge Souls fan that platinumed Dark Souls 3.
Awesome Single Player, Memorable missions, fun gameplay mechanics and one of the best multiplayer games of the year.
I couldn't really get into Doom, and Overwatch is just a bunch of console players finally learning about Team Fortress 2 style games.
The Elite
BOSS
Titanfall 2 has an entire campaign. A great campaign.
An incredibly short campaign.
Is that why all the big name TF2 players like Ster and Seagull ditched TF2 to play Overwatch?
SumptuousLemur
Banned
Doom and INSIDE are my games of the year
Overwatch is a Team a Fortress 2 clone
Uncharted 4 was just more Uncharted
Overwatch is a Team a Fortress 2 clone
Uncharted 4 was just more Uncharted
Huge Succeeded
Banned
as awesome as UC4 is I feel there's several games that deserve GOTY over Uncharted 4 and yet I'm fully expecting...
"Our game of the year 2016 is... Uncharted 4!"
i'll be pleasantly surprised if it's not but I'm holding my breath. You think it's a tragedy that Overwatch might not get the nods it deserves? I feel the same way about the amazing games that Firaxis put out this year.
"Our game of the year 2016 is... Uncharted 4!"
i'll be pleasantly surprised if it's not but I'm holding my breath. You think it's a tragedy that Overwatch might not get the nods it deserves? I feel the same way about the amazing games that Firaxis put out this year.
orthodoxy1095
Banned
No, someone is stupid because they have a stupid opinion.
Modes are a dumb way to judge games and a terrible way of evaluating worth. Two of the best games this year, The Witness and Inside have only one mode. I'm not throwing them out in favor of some other game just because they don't have an extra mode.
The Elite
BOSS
. That's five hours more than Overwatch's campaign.
loki 16
Member
6 hours is not short. It's perfectly fine.
From Google:
So you're right that it's been a bigger problem the past 3 decades or so, but it was always extremely rare for a comedy to win.
Pro-tip: it's an opinion even when people don't write "I think" or "in my opinion".
Especially "X is overrated" cannot not be an opinion. It literally means "I don't think as highly of X as the critical consensus".
lebowski4ever
Neo Member
much prefer uncharted. made a huge mistake buying overwatch. fuckin horrible game imo.
RespectThySole
Member
Overwatch is easily my GOTY. Would be a shame if Uncharted 4 won. It wasn't anything special. All of the other nominees are more deserving in my eyes.
Strangelove77
Member
I think Uncharted 4 is great(story and MP as well) and it's my GOTY, but Overwatch winning would be very cool. It's just such an odd game to win GOTY. It would get attention from those that dismissed it because it's MP only.
Overwatch will definitely win somewhere.
And I'm outta here. These threads always get ugly.
Overwatch will definitely win somewhere.
And I'm outta here. These threads always get ugly.
IntelliHeath
As in "Heathcliff"
I know it might not be a popular opinion but I think OverWatch trailers are way better than OverWatch itself.
I guess everyone needs to add an IMHO at every post now.
I would definitely agree. Uncharted 4 is kind of a disappointment anyway for its series. I previously said during Overwatch's beta that I wouldn't buy it for full price because of how barebones it was, but I got it anyway and I regret nothing. Unlike Joke Fighter V, Overwatch manages to be a hell of a lot more fun and addicting to play even with the lack on content on launch. For a new IP, it's widely successful, and I think that accounts for much more.
I mean, Overwatch doesn't really seem that new or interesting either. Just does what it does quite well. I think Uncharted is possibly more unique in that it blends genres in a way that's very rarely seen.
Let's not pretend that Witcher 3 wining over BB is different from DA:I winning over Bayonetta 2
just look at this
http://gotypicks.blogspot.com/
It's always the mainstream and popular game wins and usually on the most popular system(explains why no Nintendo game is dominating any year)
Not saying that Witcher 3 is as bad as DA:I of course lol.
Bony Manifesto
Member
Really? I'm predominately a single-player gamer, and I'd say it was the other way around. With a single-player game, you play through the campaign, which is tailor-made to make you feel like the most important person in the universe, with all these spectacular set-pieces happening around you, then when the credits roll, you move onto the next one. With online multiplayer games (and especially something like Overwatch) you really have to spend time understanding the mechanics, and accept that you're going to have hundreds of humbling deaths before you get the hang of it.
JuanLatino
Member
there were enough threads about this the past days where people were trying to sell it as a fact that Game X is shit, overrated.
That's my opinion as well, so I guess we're unpopular.
I'm still holding out hope that the game/franchise gets some good SP content.Hoo boy, that pre-emptive UC4 GOTY salt. I know it infuriates certain Neogaf members to see the game get the praise it deserves, but starting a thread to stamp your feet about the mere possibility it might be named GOTY instead of your favourite game is downright embarassing.
You think Overwatch deserves recognition as GOTY? Fair enough, but I can't see any reason for UC4 to be in the thread title if that was really your intent with this thread in all honesty.
When/if UC4 does clean up them GOTYs though, I'm fully expecting some hilarious nuclear meltdowns from some of you. So don't blow your load too early guys, save some for the main event in a few weeks
You think Overwatch deserves recognition as GOTY? Fair enough, but I can't see any reason for UC4 to be in the thread title if that was really your intent with this thread in all honesty.
When/if UC4 does clean up them GOTYs though, I'm fully expecting some hilarious nuclear meltdowns from some of you. So don't blow your load too early guys, save some for the main event in a few weeks
Exploratory
Banned
Yep Doom does nothing special. It's like no one ever played Doom, Doom 2, or Doom 3.
I feel like there was an interesting thread here about multiplayer vs single-player games when it comes to GOTY, but it's being lost in the "I liked this game more than that game." "Oh yeah? Well I liked that game more than this game!" arguments.
Anyways, I actually think Overwatch has a decent chance at GOTY. Seems to have stayed relevant throughout the year, and gets a ton of love from its fanbase. And after Splatoon and Rocket League, I think critics may be more open to naming a multiplayer game the GOTY.
Anyways, I actually think Overwatch has a decent chance at GOTY. Seems to have stayed relevant throughout the year, and gets a ton of love from its fanbase. And after Splatoon and Rocket League, I think critics may be more open to naming a multiplayer game the GOTY.
NinjaCoachZ
Member
That's funny because it's another aspect of the game that mirrors Team Fortress 2. I never got around to actually playing that game, but the "Meet the Team" promo skits were amazing.
That's my opinion as well, so I guess we're unpopular.
The lore and characters in OW are so good that I really think it'd be a shame if Blizzard never does anything SP-related with the series.
IcyRhythms
Member
Um...given that they're both single player games, I wouldn't throw them out either. I'm throwing out games like Overwatch and the original Titanfall for being multiplayer only games. Again, it's beyond silly that you feel someone is stupid because they don't share the same opinion. Opinions aren't stupid just because you disagree. That's about as retarded as one can get. Take care
What a lazy post, lol.
Just no to what you said about Uncharted and Overwatch. Overwatch does many things differently than TF2 from my experience. You can just throw that statement out there like that.
Uncharted 4 has been the biggest departure from other Uncharted games in terms of music, tone, and pacing, and humor. It has significantly better gameplay mechanics and controls than any other game in the series and arguably has some of the best gun play and controls in the TPS market next to MGS V.
Try actually playing the games next time and you wouldn't be saying this.
Hari Seldon
Member
Lol if you want to talk about being shafted look at PC exclusives.
Stabby McSter
Member
Hoo boy, that pre-emptive UC4 GOTY salt. I know it infuriates certain Neogaf members to see the game get the praise it deserves, but starting a thread to stamp your feet about the mere possibility it might be named GOTY instead of your favourite game is downright embarassing.
You think Overwatch deserves recognition as GOTY? Fair enough, but I can't see any reason for UC4 to be in the thread title if that was really your intent with this thread in all honesty.
When/if UC4 does clean up them GOTYs though, I'm fully expecting some hilarious nuclear meltdowns from some of you. So don't blow your load too early guys, save some for the main event in a few weeks
lmao wtf is this
- Status
Similar threads
- Featured