Apple September Event 2017 |OT| A Top-Notch Keynote

Why do people keep trying to peddle "it didn't work". It clearly worked. He swapped phones at the original phone had been rebooted and required a passcode before Face id could be enabled, as is standard with Touch ID.

Nope. The message on the screen is the same as the one you get if you try to use Touch ID too many times and fail. The message you get after a restart specifically tells you it's required because of a restart; Craig's message did not.

.
 
What is the purpose of the iPhone 8, at this point? It seems to me most people would rather save $100 and get an iPhone 7, or spend an extra $200 and get an iPhone X.

Just catching up with everything but I'd be one of those people jumping to an 8+ over the 7+ or X. Currently coming from a 6S+ (which is still going strong with zero issues) and I would rather just have the new tech in the 8/8+ over the 7/7+ and I can't afford the X (nor do I want to actually give up TouchID to FaceID).
 
Regardless of it working as intended or not, not a good first impression of your new hot face thing failing right away for some reason. He at the very least could have improvised and explained what happened.
 
What is the purpose of the iPhone 8, at this point? It seems to me most people would rather save $100 and get an iPhone 7, or spend an extra $200 and get an iPhone X.

Well the 8 is really the 7s.

I think I am getting an 8, although all it really has over the 7 is wireless charging.
 
Nope. The message on the screen is the same as the one you get if you try to use Touch ID too many times and fail. The message you get after a restart specifically tells you it's required because of a restart; Craig's message did not.

In addition to this, there's just no way Apple would have made such a simple oversight in planning sessions. They had every bit of the presentation scripted to a T.

The hardware screwed up.
 
You mean the cellular? You should be able to buy it anywhere but possibly exclusive to EE if they are the only operator supporting the tech needed? I think for wifi use there was something the operator needed to support to use the Apple Watch to make calls without the Iphone nearby.

Only EE provides the cellular sim for it. Sadness. :(

Unless there's a way to unlock it and use different providers? I don't think you can do that. :/
 
The Verge is wrong and doesn't know what they are talking about, as they often do not. You can see the error Craig got in the very article - that's not the one you'd get after a restart.

What about this part?

This is the same screen that would come up on existing iPhones after a device has been restarted — or simply after several hours have passed without authenticating through the lock screen.
 
The Verge is wrong and doesn't know what they are talking about, as they often do not. You can see the error Craig got in the very article - that's not the one you'd get after a restart.

There is no message if your Touch ID is wrong after a few times.
It just brings up the passcode screen like normal.

The message says specifically it's required for to Enable Touch ID.
I get that message now and then randomly (like I haven't used it for a long period on my iPad).
Not just a restart which is a slightly different message but effectively the same thing.
 
The Verge is wrong and doesn't know what they are talking about, as they often do not. You can see the error Craig got in the very article - that's not the one you'd get after a restart.

Did you miss the part where a period of inactivity requires the passcode to be reentered as a security measure?
 
Just catching up with everything but I'd be one of those people jumping to an 8+ over the 7+ or X. Currently coming from a 6S+ (which is still going strong with zero issues) and I would rather just have the new tech in the 8/8+ over the 7/7+ and I can't afford the X (nor do I want to actually give up TouchID to FaceID).

I own a 6S+, and the only thing I could see myself buying is the X.

7 is just a waterproof 6S. Not worth spending $500+ on.
8 is just a 7 with wireless charging. Not worth spending $700 on.
 
There is no message if your Touch ID is wrong after a few times.
It just brings up the passcode screen like normal.

The message says specifically it's required for to Enable Touch ID.
I get that message now and then randomly (like I haven't used it for a long period on my iPad).
Not just a restart which is a slightly different message but effectively the same thing.

Nope. If you do Touch ID wrong just once, then you get "Try again." If you keep doing it several times with a finger that's not registered, you get "Your passcode is required to enable Touch ID", just like that demo. The restart message specifically says "Touch ID requires your passcode after your iPhone restarts." Just tested and confirmed using my 6S Plus with the iOS 11 GM.

What about this part?

This would only be possible if no one had face-unlocked the demo phone in the past 48 hours, or hadn't entered the passcode at all in the past week.
 
Nope. If you do Touch ID wrong just once, then you get "Try again." If you keep doing it with a finger that's not registered, you get "Your passcode is required to enable Touch ID", just like that demo. The restart message specifically says "Touch ID requires your passcode after your iPhone restarts." Just tested and confirmed using my 6S Plus with the iOS 11 GM.
I tested it on my iPad and if you leave it alone for a while, "Your passcode is required to enable Touch ID" is the message I get.
 
Nope. If you do Touch ID wrong just once, then you get "Try again." If you keep doing it with a finger that's not registered, you get "Your passcode is required to enable Touch ID", just like that demo. The restart message specifically says "Touch ID requires your passcode after your iPhone restarts." Just tested and confirmed using my 6S Plus with the iOS 11 GM.

You get the "Your passcode is required to enable Touch ID" for multiple reasons not necessarily related to an issue with Touch ID. I just got it for upgrading to the latest version of iOS 11.
 
I'm a huge fan of Apple, but I feel this keynote was a little disappointing. The X looks great, but I can't help but feel it is a little undercooked and overpriced. It really seems like it is plagued with ill thought out things which need further refinement, for instance:

What has happened to reachability?
Why have they put notifications and control centre up in the top corners? (goodbye one hand use)
Why did they let the notch cut into videos and apps?
And so on.

Don't get me wrong, much of the hardware looks great. But I really think iOS needs to serious reinvention to better reflect the hardware and screen size.

Personally, watching this convinced me to just keep my 7. If it really blew me a way, I might have thought about upgrading early, but instead I might just wait till next year.

Everything else also felt a little lacklustre. For instance:

Whats the deal with Space Grey coming back.
Where is the dark mode.
How come I can't get a non cellular stainless steel watch.

For me I will probably upgrade my Apple Watch since I have had mine from launch. The series 3 doesn't look like a huge jump over the 2, but it should be a nice jump from mine.
 
So no Apple Pencil on the X? Still 60Hz?

Seems like anyone would just get the 8/8+. That's what I'll probably do. 4S, 5c, 6+, now 8+.
Haven't seen much a reason to upgrade from the 6+ but I liked what they started doing with the cameras on the 7+.
New SoC sounds really great though.

Can you have a cellular Apple Watch independent of having an iPhone?
 
I tested it on my iPad and if you leave it alone for a while, "Your passcode is required to enable Touch ID" is the message I get.

You get the "Your passcode is required to enable Touch ID" for multiple reasons not necessarily related to an issue with Touch ID. I just got it for upgrading to the latest version of iOS 11.

Unless we are to believe no had touched this demo phone for between 48 hours to a week prior to this demo, or had just upgraded the iPhone without anyone testing it out afterwards, neither of those scenarios would apply.

The simplest explanation is just that it happened to not work. Like, yes, there are other reasons that error can appear - but they all would require a level of incompetency from Apple that isn't in line with how ridiculously rehearsed and scripted these demos are.
 
Nope. If you do Touch ID wrong just once, then you get "Try again." If you keep doing it several times with a finger that's not registered, you get "Your passcode is required to enable Touch ID", just like that demo. The restart message specifically says "Touch ID requires your passcode after your iPhone restarts." Just tested and confirmed using my 6S Plus with the iOS 11 GM.

Doing this brings up the same message: http://www.redmondpie.com/disable-touch-id-in-ios-11-iphone-quickly-without-reboot-heres-how/
 
Unless we are to believe no had touched this demo phone for between 48 hours to a week prior to this demo, or had just upgraded the iPhone without anyone testing it out afterwards, neither of those scenarios would apply.
Just pointing out that it MAY not be because of FaceID that you seem so adamant about.
 
I've been watching hands on videos for the last hour and my consensus is I'm scared - FaceID does not seem to work very well, it is not very accurate based on angles, a lot of errors where the angle of the phone was off and the phone didn't unlock.
 
Unless we are to believe no had touched this demo phone for between 48 hours to a week prior to this demo, or had just upgraded the iPhone without anyone testing it out afterwards, neither of those scenarios would apply.

The simplest explanation is just that it happened to not work. Any claim that it was another factor requires a level of incompetency from Apple that isn't in line with how ridiculously rehearsed and scripted these demos are.

You're most likely right but it was a demo on a pre-release device using beta software and every other attempt during that demo and all the other hands on videos I've seen so far had it working perfectly so I'm inclined to believe it was just a simple bug.
 
The cost is probably all from the HDR display.

It looks interesting, but I'll wait to see what other Android phones go slim in the next year. I definitely want an HDR screen next time, too.
 
Just pointing out that it MAY not be because of FaceID that you seem so adamant about.

It's technically possible, but all the alternative explanations are way less likely than "it just happened to fuck up" to the point where I think some people should probably stop and ask themselves why they are arguing so hard to show it may not have been.

Like, I'm not even trying to argue FaceID is gonna be a big failure or anything, I just think it happened to not work on that one demo.
 
I've been watching hands on videos for the last hour and my consensus is I'm scared - FaceID does not seem to work very well, it is not very accurate based on angles, a lot of errors where the angle of the phone was off and the phone didn't unlock.

Links?
 
Top Bottom