• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

2011 Fall Anime Thread - Bad Shows & Self Hating Nerds

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jex

Member
[Anne of Green Gables - 25]

Rather than having straight up re-cap episodes to save time this show goes the route of having a few new scenes of interaction as a set-up for the lengthy flashabacks. Personally I find this rather more annoying than the standard re-cap because you think you're sitting down to a normal episode, but actually you're just wasting your time.

It didn't help that all the non-flashback stuff was clearly filler made by the c-team. It was hampered by weird editing, poor composition, a flat script and pretty much no story to speak of.

[Anne of Green Gables - 26]

Well, this helped to wash the bad taste of the last episode out of my mouth. Anne's brand spanking new teacher is apparently the living incarnation of Jesus, everyone loves her, she's perfect, good with the boys and an inspiration to every human being on the planet. Just look at her sleeves:

anne26.jpg



Apparently, to raise money for a new flag, all the children are going to put on a play. Anne competing for a role, practising and acting in a dramatic production of any sort basically writes itself, as you'd imagine given her melodramatic personality. I imagine this is the scene where all the Canadian's teared up:

anne26b.jpg
 
Thoraxes said:
Bring ' back from porn and I will watch the show.
She's the best girl no matter what she does.

I guess that's why she's in porn :p

duckroll said:
AKB48 anime details

http://www.oricon.co.jp/news/confidence/2002820/full/

Here's the full staff list:

Planning/Supervisor: Yasushi Akimoto (AKB45 General Producer)
Original Concept/Chief Director: Shoji Kawamori (Macross, More Macross, Arjuna, Even More Macross)
Series Composition/Script: Mari Okada (Anohana, Hanasaku Iroha, Toradora!)
Character Design: Mikan Ehime (Macross F)
Director: Yoshimasa Hiraike (Working!!, Amagami SS, Sketchbook ~fill color's~)
Executive Producer: Toshimichi Ootsuki (Rebuild of Evangelion)
Animation Production: Satelight (Macross F, Aquarion)


The anime will start next Spring, and will be about 9 "Idol candidates" who aspire to become like the Top8 elected AKB48 idols featured in the show. The voices for the 9 main characters will be chosen out of the 200 idols in the AKB groups, in a series of selections. The Top 8 elected AKB48 idols seem to be the actual ones who are the most popular right now.

Shoji Kawamori says that he hopes that using the proud animation that Japan has to offer, combined with the latest in CG techniques, they can truly show off the professional spirit of the Idols in this anime production. Lol.


uYGPC.jpg


This is an illustation image showing what the top8 elected idols might look like in anime form.


ESTYO.jpg


This is the official character design art for 9 main characters who are the idol candidates. (lol)


an idol anime again?
 

Jex

Member
duckroll said:
AKB48 anime details

Here's the full staff list:

Original Concept/Chief Director: Shoji Kawamori (Macross, More Macross, Arjuna, Even More Macross)
Series Composition/Script: Mari Okada (Anohana, Hanasaku Iroha, Toradora!)
Character Design: Mikan Ehime (Macross F)

Animation Production: Satelight (Macross F, Aquarion)

Shoji Kawamori says that he hopes that using the proud animation that Japan has to offer, combined with the latest in CG techniques, they can truly show off the professional spirit of the Idols in this anime production. Lol.
That's all I need to know. They're really doing their best at sabotaging their chances from day one, aren't they?
 

BluWacky

Member
Oh, Kawamori :(

Is this my punishment for hating Basquash? Was the 10 minutes of Animal Detective Kiruminzuu I watched not enough to assuage you that you must punish us with shitty idol anime?

:( :( :(
 

mr jones

Ethnicity is not a race!
Sup y'all.

Can you recommend a decent action/drama anime to me on Netflix? I liked Ghost in the Shell, and Mushishi was ok too. Monster got boring to me. High School of the Dead pissed me off.

Anything?
 

iavi

Member
mr jones said:
Sup y'all.

Can you recommend a decent action/drama anime to me on Netflix? I liked Ghost in the Shell, and Mushishi was ok too. Monster got boring to me. High School of the Dead pissed me off.

Anything?
I think the Samurai X ovas are up on Netflix, definitely get at those.
 

flawfuls

Member
Bah they should have just done an adaptation of the AKB49 manga. It's shockingly good. Then again I doubt it would have appealed very much to the anime buying audience. Instead of going the moe or romcom route they went the hot blooded shounen sports route.

DNlNa.jpg


I would also like to mention that the legendary 49th member is a dude and it's all completely serious.
 

Lafiel

と呼ぶがよい
duckroll said:
AKB48 anime details

Here's the full staff list:
Planning/Supervisor: Yasushi Akimoto (AKB45 General Producer)
Original Concept/Chief Director: Shoji Kawamori (Macross, More Macross, Arjuna, Even More Macross)
Series Composition/Script: Mari Okada (Anohana, Hanasaku Iroha, Toradora!)
Character Design: Mikan Ehime (Macross F)
Director: Yoshimasa Hiraike (Working!!, Amagami SS, Sketchbook ~fill color's~)
Executive Producer: Toshimichi Ootsuki (Rebuild of Evangelion)
Animation Production: Satelight (Macross F, Aquarion)

The anime will start next Spring, and will be about 9 "Idol candidates" who aspire to become like the Top8 elected AKB48 idols featured in the show. The voices for the 9 main characters will be chosen out of the 200 idols in the AKB groups, in a series of selections. The Top 8 elected AKB48 idols seem to be the actual ones who are the most popular right now.

Shoji Kawamori says that he hopes that using the proud animation that Japan has to offer, combined with the latest in CG techniques, they can truly show off the professional spirit of the Idols in this anime production. Lol.

I have no words right now...
 
Wheeljack539 said:
No, there's no such scene of that in the game. I think you may be confused when
Ilya mind control's Shirou to her mansion/castle in the forest. There's a cg of her sitting on Shirou's lap that does look questionable, but its of her trying to get him on her side.

There is a humorous 4-koma strip of Ilya floating around where's she's at a computer looking all focused and at the end Taiga finally appearing to tell her, "It doesn't matter how many times you play it, there is no Ilya Route!".
Yeah, you're right. :) I was indeed confused by the pics, but you're right.

hosannainexcelsis said:
Ben-To 2

That was... fun. I'm genuinely shocked.

The earnestness with which they treat this ridiculous premise really helps sell it.

What is it with this season and terrible first episodes?
Sure, the second episode is better, but the first one wasn't terrible...

flawfuls said:
Bah they should have just done an adaptation of the AKB49 manga. It's shockingly good. Then again I doubt it would have appealed very much to the anime buying audience. Instead of going the moe or romcom route they went the hot blooded shounen sports route.

http://i.imgur.com/DNlNa.jpg

I would also like to mention that the legendary 49th member is a dude and it's all completely serious.
"Blessed by god" because he is male, not an inferior woman like the others? :(
 

Articalys

Member
THE NO LIFE KING said:
Any news about Hellsing Ultimate from NYCC???
This is the only mention I could find of Hellsing from notes on their panel, so make of it what you will:

15:44:58 <bay|NYCC|FUNi> Q: Hellsing ova boxset possible?
15:45:12 <bay|NYCC|FUNi> A: we haven't continued working on the series yet so stand by
 

iavi

Member
icarus-daedelus said:
So I found this series of ugly CG shorts on Hulu called Mr. Stain on Junk Alley. Near as I can tell, it's about a homeless dude and a jerkass cat living in an alley, having wacky hallucinations while they fail to find food and starve to death.

I don't know...I can't stop watching for some reason. It's not totally terrible.
Question is, is it funny? That's key.
 

Lafiel

と呼ぶがよい
So, with this recent AKB48 anime announcement, it appears that IDOLM@STER truly did revolutionize the "idol" anime genre, this is only the beginning, expect a new generation of Idol anime due to IDORU influence, the question is will any of them compare to IDORU?
probably not
 

cajunator

Banned
Steroyd said:
Squid Girl - 04

I say, I thought the play on broken engrish was brill-iant.

Mini-Ika...

1187585027077.gif


EVERYTIME!
Chibi Ika did remind me of Potemayo a lot. So did the girl with the orange hair actually.
 

Geneijin

Member
duckroll said:
AKB48 anime details

Shoji Kawamori says that he hopes that using the proud animation that Japan has to offer, combined with the latest in CG techniques, they can truly show off the professional spirit of the Idols in this anime production. Lol.
???

I'm finding a surprising lack of examples to these techniques.
 

cajunator

Banned
mr jones said:
Sup y'all.

Can you recommend a decent action/drama anime to me on Netflix? I liked Ghost in the Shell, and Mushishi was ok too. Monster got boring to me. High School of the Dead pissed me off.

Anything?
Moribito
 

jman2050

Member
Lafiel said:
So, with this recent AKB48 anime announcement, it appears that IDOLM@STER truly did revolutionize the "idol" anime genre, this is only the beginning, expect a new generation of Idol anime due to IDORU influence, the question is will any of them compare to IDORU?
probably not

Anime is dead
 

cajunator

Banned
I bought yet another bookshelf so my anime collection doesn't keep spilling out onto the floor.
Now to find a decent display case for all the figurines.
Any good online outlets that sell display cabinets? Not a curio or something, but more one of those tall glass cases. Something to keep the dust off everything.
 

Amagon

Member
Articalys said:
This is the only mention I could find of Hellsing from notes on their panel, so make of it what you will:

15:44:58 <bay|NYCC|FUNi> Q: Hellsing ova boxset possible?
15:45:12 <bay|NYCC|FUNi> A: we haven't continued working on the series yet so stand by
You gotta be fucking me. Ugggghhhhh...
 

Instro

Member
mr jones said:
Sup y'all.

Can you recommend a decent action/drama anime to me on Netflix? I liked Ghost in the Shell, and Mushishi was ok too. Monster got boring to me. High School of the Dead pissed me off.

Anything?
Without knowing what you have seen, I'll just to a quick scan of some stuff on the anime page on Netflix.

Baccano- Probably the perfect fit if you're looking for a mix of action and drama since it does both extremely well. Great cast of characters, well written plot, etc etc.
Samurai Champloo
Death Note
Gurren Lagann is on there, although theres not exactly a lot of drama since it so over the top.
Golgo 13...although I suppose that's more action that anything else
Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood is on there definitely watch that, assuming you dont have a problem with a 64 episode show.
GunGrave would also be worth checking out, although some sections get pretty stupid.
Darker Then Black is on there as well iirc. Certainly worth watching.

Anything on Netflix that you had your eye on already? Might be a bit easier to give you suggestions, since this is just guesswork atm.

EDIT

Oh, Heat Guy J is on there too! That's cool scifi shit.
 
Ben-to 2

I love how there's a whole structure to the supermarket fighting. "Team" identifiers, rules and those that break them, strategies, prominent individuals. This really is Ikkitousen at a supermarket.
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
hosannainexcelsis said:
To expand on that, the episode I watched had 6 3-4 minute segments and 2 shorter ones in the middle, all centered around one slice-of-life style situation. I think you'd like it.
icarus-daedelus said:
Or epeen envy? :p

It's regular length but more or less a sketch show, kinda like Nichijou (not as ridiculous, obv.) or marathoning a bunch of Chi's Sweet-ass Home episodes.
Ah, sounds neat and low impact anyway.

duckroll said:
AKB48 anime details
Sequel to idolm@ster already!
 

Instro

Member
duckroll said:
Shoji Kawamori says that he hopes that using the proud animation that Japan has to offer, combined with the latest in CG techniques, they can truly show off the professional spirit of the Idols in this anime production. Lol.
Boy Kawamori sure is bringing it next year with Aquarion on this Idol show.......
 

NewFresh

Member
Ben-To Ep.2

The level of seriousness that the characters demonstrate is perfectly contradictory to the actual plot of the show.


cosmicblizzard said:
Ben-to 2

I love how there's a whole structure to the supermarket fighting. "Team" identifiers, rules and those that break them, strategies, prominent individuals. This really is Ikkitousen at a supermarket.

That is what I love most about the episode. There are layers and layers of ridiculous depth.

A Black Falcon said:
Ben-to 2 - This show is great stuff, really one of the best shows of the season so far. It's a complete surprise, I don't know if anyone was really expecting this to be good, but it is... the idea is completely absurd, but that's the whole point. While the characters take this idea -- vicious battles over half-price bento boxes -- quite seriously, the viewer simply can't, so it's all just completely ridiculous. Fortunately, that split works pretty well here. This is a good battle harem show. I'm wondering where the plot's going to go now, there are plenty of plot elements and questions to answer...

I was! I'm even quoted in the OP.


On that note, the battle element definitely takes prescedence over the harem element, but yes, it is harem, of course. Oh well... at least the female characters are reasonably interesting, for the genre. I wonder whether the lesbian girl will fall in love with him too... if it follows genre convention it's likely, unfortunately, but we'll see.

I am hoping that they keep this focus (75% Battle 25% Harem) throughout the shows run. But you are right that it would fit the typical conventions of the genre to ramp up the amount of girls and fan service.
 

dimb

Bjergsen is the greatest midlane in the world
PdotMichael said:
Idol shows are like harem animes without a big idiot as main character.

I guess it makes it a little better.
What about idol shows with big idiots as the main character? Like idolm@ster.
 

Enron

Banned
Shouta said:
Sounds ultra boring. Honestly, they should totally animate the AKB49 manga when it finishes. That would be a lot more interesting.

In other news, Shouta reads AKB49 manga. lol
 

cajunator

Banned
LordCanti said:
Usagi Drop?

It's pretty much sickeningly cute, in a dawww sort of way.
Oh shit. I haven't finished watching that! I left off around episode 8 or osmething.

BluWacky said:
Bottle Fairy or Tiny Snow Fairy Sugar. Definitely vomit-causing in their cuteness.

Broccoli shows are great.
I love those.

Looking for something from other studios though. Perhaps something cute I haven't thought of or seen before.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom