The long lost Brooklyn boy returns to New York. The prodigal son tries to be the savior of his hometown team, lead the Knicks back to the promised land. He talks of NBA championships, of turning around a woebegone franchise.
The era started with so much promise, but Stephon Marbury and his bloated contract plunged the Knicks into an even darker age. And just two years after Donnie Walsh finally finished cleaning up one of the most colossal busts in franchise history, it may be happening all over again.
Meet Stephon Marbury 2.0, better known as Carmelo Anthony. Yes, he's a software upgrade, bigger and stronger than his predecessor, and slightly more stable (we think) than the last prodigal son the city absolutely had to have.
But as wild as this may sound, a month into his Knick career, Melo has already shown bugs, signs that his story could play out like the mercurial Starbury's fall from grace. Already, the player who was serenaded by Diddy's "I'm Coming Home" as he made his Knick debut at the Garden has caused waves, criticizing teammates for not getting him the ball and complaining about game plans. He has brazenly left the media hanging after a road loss, even pouted on the bench.
No, it's not vintage Marbury. Anthony's sniping with the coach has been only verbal, and he has gone AWOL only after a game, not during a practice. But truth is, this is how Marbury started out, too.
Long before he was inviting interns into his car, Starbury was right where Anthony is now. He was brought in by Isiah Thomas - the same guy who some say swayed James Dolan into throwing in a kitchen sink and an equipment boy to be named later to reel in Melo - and landed with a coach on his way out (Don Chaney) and a team with a gaping hole at center. Marbury promised an NBA title and an unselfish playing style in his first Broadway days in early January of 2004, then dashed everyone's hopes about a week later. "Rome wasn't built in a day," he would say.
Not what Knicks fans want to hear, said Magic forward Quentin Richardson, who played with Marbury in New York from 2005-09.
"You're a big star, you're that good. The fans, they expect you to do good stuff for the team," Richardson said.
Sounds familiar, doesn't it? About a month ago, Anthony was promising plenty of "good stuff," and we don't mean that upcoming reality show he and wife Lala Vazquez have in the works. When he joined a Knick team with a coach on the hot seat (Mike D'Antoni) and a Smurf center (Ronny Turiaf), Anthony talked excitedly of not needing to score "25-30 a night," and NBA titles danced in fans' minds.
Then last week, Melo went all young Marbury on us, telling everyone that the Knicks might not get things together "until next season," and suggesting that the best way to prep for the playoffs would be to "relax" and "have fun." And suddenly, D'Antoni is Chaney. Just as Garden crowds once chanted "Fire Chaney," a low chant rose from a few stragglers in the waning moments of Wednesday's loss to the Magic, a whisper-quiet: "Fire "D'Antoni."
We know how Marbury's story ended. He made his lone Knick playoff appearance that first season and was bounced by the Nets in the first round, setting the stage for his career tailspin. Even as the Knicks tried to build around him, Marbury would feud with coach after coach - and reportedly come to blows with pal Isiah Thomas - as he went from embraced to vilified.
Walsh finally bought Marbury out in 2009. Marbury is now playing in China.
We want to believe this won't be Melo's future, that this local boy is a better than the last local boy ever was. Never mind that the Nuggets are playing better without their superstar, just as the Suns and Nets flourished after Marbury vacated. Never mind that the whole Anthony circus signaled a return to days of excess before Walsh pared payroll, dead weight and Marbury.
Anthony is an Olympian and a proven scorer. Just like Marbury was.
So yes, the Melo era started with promise. But beware of a dark age.