I have to say im with Dascu here, point by point, Im trying to get my last ending now, the true one so yeah, im doing all the endings. I heard some people in GAF telling that it was better to get 999 than Ghost Trick, and for me, thats not true, Ghost Trick was an engaging experience, with a great story and lots of fun, and the gameplay was also more fun and much better, and the character designs and graphics shit all over this game. This game feels not bad, but not as good as people painted it here, and it was not hype because I didnt know anything about the games plot when I started, nor the characters.
The text is PAINFULLY slow, the lectures of tutorial for everything you do are horrible, the 10 puzzles or something in the game are not really good and very easy, even boring.
Im the only one that thinks the graphics are really bad? The scenery is normal, but it doesnt match with the characters in the slightest. The character graphics are worse than the original GBA Phoenix Wrights, each one has like 6 movements in total with not very good animation (and this is one of the worst things of the game in my opinion, instead of making new moves that described how the characters feel, the had to tell me their behaviour with some fucking shitty SLOW ass text, this is horrible, this is fucking bad in my opinion). In games like Phoenix Wright (were there are more than 9 fucking characters) I can tell what the characters think thanks to the animation they had, that game has 12 fucking years for christ sake! Theres no excuse (and no, being a small studio is not).
And dont even get me started with the character design, that is as bad as you can get, typical anime nomura shit to the max. Santa's and Lotus designs are fucking atrocious, please, someone explain why Lotus is dressed like a fucking belly dancer and looks 20 years old
, and I didnt know that ex hackers dressed like prostitutes, is her a prostitute now? a belly dancer? they never explain, at least in the other endings why she is dressed like that. And I dont know how Santa can move his arms with all that fucking shit around him like a fucking mummy.
And what has Clover in the cheek? What the mother of fuck is that, is she the villian of James Bond Die Another Day and some diamond exploded near her? And why is Seven, a
dressed like a fruit market seller?
And why do I have to repeat puzzles every time I start a game, I dont it one time, is not fun to do it another (I know sometimes, for the new endings theres new text while doing some of the puzzles, but thats no excuse, you can put that text in any other place and let me skip the puzzle I have done two time now, worse offender is the cargo room).
I dont feel anything like being Junpei, if that is what they wanted, I dont want them to tell me what I think (i dont know how people can praise the storytelling in this, I think the text that appears in the second screen is really bad and it really doesnt feel like im playing a game), and the choices in the game to get the endings are horrible, seems like you dont have any freedom in the game, if seen hentai visual novels with more freedom to choose, I kid you not.
When I started the game, I thought it was going to be awesome, with the story of a real Titanic and puzzles inside the legendary ship to discover a mistery (I love the Titanic mythos) but then, at least in all the endings I have play, they dont explain why they are playing in a replica of the ship. And all the little stories that they tell at first about the ship... they are all wrong, at least if you are going to talk about the legends people told about the ship, get your facts straight.
I really dont find why to praise so much the game, even to the extent to call Ghost Trick worse than this. The only great thing I find is that beating the game one time is like beating a chapter, and that you need all the endings to get the full story, making you want to play the game fast again to see what secrets are yet to be discovered, the rest goes from mediocre to bad.
MAYBE I need to get the the real ending yet, and all they things that im talking about are explained at the end, but right now I see too many flaws, for it to get so many praise
AniHawk said:
the eventual explanation of the pseudo-science is actually built up through conversations with other characters throughout the entire game. the patchwork sock, the ice-9, the crystalization thing, 'futility: or the wreck of the titan' aren't tossed out just because (and i think only one or two of those was made up for the game, i know that the story about the titanic is actually true).
The two that seem true, Futility and most of all, the "Gigantic" are based on real things, but they are totally wrong (the mummy one also exists as a legend). The worst offender is the "Gigantic" first of all, it wasnt call Gigantic but Britannic, and it fucking SANK. It doesnt help the story so I dont even know why the change the history (yeah, I know about the hospital room, at the end of the game it doesnt mean shit). Why dont get the Olympic instead? That could have been, for story purposes, saved and sold in the "black market" (you could tell the story that when they wanted to scrap the ship, someone took it in pieces, or some other shit, that would have been more belivable than the Britannic story). At least the Futility thing is mostly right, apart from some details.