Alright, just finished the game, including the DLC case (which is PHENOMENAL), and so I thought I'd post my final thoughts.
Overall, I think AA5 is really an incredible entry into the series. I think they found the right formula of how to keep the main series fresh after the missteps of AA4. (Which is still a good game, but this is on another level.) I think this, along with AAI2, shows that the series has a bright future, even if Takumi doesn't return. I think Eshiro has taken up the mantle quite successfully, and I'm very excited to see where he takes the series going forward. As for pros and cons...
Pros
-The rotating leads. This kept the narrative moving at a great pace, and finally gave Apollo a chance to really shine and an opportunity to redeem Phoenix, all while successfully introducing Athena, who is a great addition to the cast.
-The supporting characters. Overall, the newly introduced characters were very well done. The majority of the new characters were well fleshed out, and quite memorable. Even in cases where certain aspects of the story itself was not as compelling, the cast still shone through. The returning characters also fit into the story well, though some of them could of been utilized a bit more.
-The presentation. The new graphic engine is absolutely stunning. It perfectly fits the tone of the series, and still captured the "spark" that past entries had. The music was also incredible. Both these elements are hallmarks of the series, so it was great to see them get the care and attention they deserve.
-The story. Despite a few slow parts, the narrative overall was very well done. Especially toward the end, the way that the story kept building and intensifying was outstanding. I think a bit part of this was a much more focused Phoenix and Apollo, who both seemed lost in AA4. Also, strong new major characters like Athena and Simon fit into the storyline quite seamlessly. Also, this game probably features the strongest "filler" case in the entire series. (The DLC case, which is A+++.)
-The unique gameplay systems. I was very happy to see that each lead attorney had their special ability present in the game. While the Mood Matrix was the most prominent, the Perceive system and Psyche-Lock system were still very enjoyable. In regards to the Mood Matrix, when I first heard of it, I wasn't that enthused about it, but after playing the game, I think it was handled quite well.
Cons
-The quality control. As has been pointed out numerous times, this game features quite a lot of typos. The script itself was truly excellent, but the lack of polish was glaringly obvious. This needs to be rectified in future installments.
-The anime scenes. While the idea is a good one, the execution of the anime scenes in AA5 left a bit to be desired. The art direction did not quite live up to the rest of the game, presentation wise. In the future, if they intend to keep this features, I hope they raise the quality level.
-The voice acting. Very hit-or-miss. Some fit perfectly, while others seemed uninspired or dreadfully miscast. Unfortunately this spoiled the emotional impact of some scenes, which is a real shame.
-The difficulty level. Overall, this game is way too easy. Almost every single contradiction is spelled out for you, or you are given endless chances. (ie. The Mood Matrix) While in hindsight, it doesn't really affect my enjoyment of the game, they could definitely learn to ease up on the hand holding. (I suspect this was done because they want AA5 to be a good jumping in point for new players.)
-Capcom USA. I feel that they really dropped the ball when it came to this game. I know it has been discussed to death, but the lack of physical release, and the removal of the Trivial DLC is still pretty shameful. Their excuses to why they did these things simply do not hold water. The truth is they were cutting costs and time, and it showed in the final product. (Thankfully, the actually game itself was able to shine through this mismanagement.) Also, why on Earth was this rated M? I don't get it at all.
---
In closing, AA5 is sensational. A MUST play for any AA fan. I feel that the future of this series is very bright. I just hope Capcom USA also realizes this, and puts more effort into supporting the loyal fanbase, and delivering the whole product.
Edit: Whoops, didn't mean to double post. I meant to edit my last one. Sorry.
Blood, blood everywhere.
