• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

AMD Radeon 9070XT review thread

Radical_3d

Member
Not a card but i leave it here because its just as important


bArfZvL.jpeg

Imagine paying the nVidia tax and ending with this combination of pixelation and what seems to be an impressionist version of the image. Van Gogh am cry.
 

FingerBang

Member
The stock of 9070 cards is apparently a few times the one all the Nvidia cards at launch, combined, but apparently only around 20% will be at MSRP and the average price will be something like $680. The 5070 is going to be a full paper launch, with fewer units than the 5090.

Retailers expect the 9070s to be restocked weekly.
 

Panajev2001a

GAF's Pleasant Genius
So, has it turned out that fsr4 is better than PSSR as I legit expected fsr4 just to be pssr with a different name 😆
It is probably related to PSSR (AMD deciding to get a joint venture going with SIE for ML/AI seems to speak well of Sony’s efforts there) but it takes a similar per frame cost on a more powerful GPU (faster and newer CUs, more CUs, faster memory [Infinity Cache] and more time in the oven…). More resource hungry and delivering better results, it seems understandable :).
 

64gigabyteram

Reverse groomer.
You should be able to get one easily. But I bet the MSRP ones will be gone in minutes
Remember- It's AMD. It'll be shocking if ANY card sells out.

I'm half-joking by the way. There have been many instances where AMD mollywhopped Nvidia for price-to-performance and still lost at the end of it all.

I want gamers to wisen the fuck up and buy this thing in droves, but I also don't want them to because I like lots of stock and big discounts.
 
I'm so torn as to whether the 9070XT would be the right purchase to replace my 3080. I'm gonna hold out for a bit I think, but path tracing at 60+FPS seems great if some of the other settings are lowered. It really feels like the GPU upgrades are much smaller gen on gen for the last few years. I wonder whether this will be the case moving forward now...
 

FingerBang

Member
Remember- It's AMD. It'll be shocking if ANY card sells out.

I'm half-joking by the way. There have been many instances where AMD mollywhopped Nvidia for price-to-performance and still lost at the end of it all.

I want gamers to wisen the fuck up and buy this thing in droves, but I also don't want them to because I like lots of stock and big discounts.
Well, normally I would agree with you, but the ridiculous stock situation caused by Nvidia means there's A LOT of people for which the 9070xt will be the best option and the ONLY option for their upgrade.

If you want more than a 7800xt, you can't buy any card at a reasonable price right now. And even at MSRP these cards are barely more powerful than the previous generation.

Here's a cars that gets you closer to what used to cost $1000 for 40% off.

Basically, unless you're looking for a 5090 (and you honestly shouldn't buy one for gaming), the 9070xt is probably what you want instead of a 5070, 5070ti and a 5080. The MSRP versions will evaporate in minutes, the others will probably last a few days.
 

un1que

Member
I'm so torn as to whether the 9070XT would be the right purchase to replace my 3080. I'm gonna hold out for a bit I think, but path tracing at 60+FPS seems great if some of the other settings are lowered. It really feels like the GPU upgrades are much smaller gen on gen for the last few years. I wonder whether this will be the case moving forward now...
I’m in the same boat. Was going to go all out for an rtx5090 till I saw all the issues, prices, etc. if I could get one near cost I’d probably bite but it’s mental
 

FingerBang

Member
I’m in the same boat. Was going to go all out for an rtx5090 till I saw all the issues, prices, etc. if I could get one near cost I’d probably bite but it’s mental
I'm so torn as to whether the 9070XT would be the right purchase to replace my 3080. I'm gonna hold out for a bit I think, but path tracing at 60+FPS seems great if some of the other settings are lowered. It really feels like the GPU upgrades are much smaller gen on gen for the last few years. I wonder whether this will be the case moving forward now...
The issue with the 3080 unfortunately is still the amount of VRAM. If that doesn't bother you because of the games/resolution you play at, then it's fine, but it will definitely be a big issue moving forward.

The 9070XT is mostly a nice jump up from the 3080, but I agree it's disappointing 2 generations later. The 5080 at MSRP would be a great option, but it might take a few months for stock to stabilize and you're getting 15/20% more performance (and stronger upscaling/RT) paying 70% more.

It really comes down to how much money you're willing to spend and what kind of performance you're looking for.
 
Last edited:
I have a RTX3090 but don't think it's worth upgrading for only 30% extra power. i'll sit this one out. I can run most games on my ultra wide 2k with DLSS at 90fps which is fine by me.
 

Ogbert

Member
I'm so torn as to whether the 9070XT would be the right purchase to replace my 3080. I'm gonna hold out for a bit I think, but path tracing at 60+FPS seems great if some of the other settings are lowered. It really feels like the GPU upgrades are much smaller gen on gen for the last few years. I wonder whether this will be the case moving forward now...
I’m going for the 9070xt.

Feels like the workhorse card that offers the right balance of cost vs performance well into next gen.

And as ever with performance tests, you drop a couple of settings here and there and the frame rates jump up again. I have zero interest in Wu Kong’s raytracing test. It’s simply a demo and has little relation to practical gaming.
 

un1que

Member
I’m going for the 9070xt.

Feels like the workhorse card that offers the right balance of cost vs performance well into next gen.

And as ever with performance tests, you drop a couple of settings here and there and the frame rates jump up again. I have zero interest in Wu Kong’s raytracing test. It’s simply a demo and has little relation to practical gaming.
4k 60 with all the bells and whistles is all I’m asking for.. why’s it cost so much to get there 😂
 
9070XT (not oc) vs 7900XTX for generational leap

DescriptionAlan Wake 2Black Myth WukongCyberpunk 2077Half-Life ray tracedIndiana JonesPortal RTXQuake 2 RTXStar wars outlaws
4k158%188%129%99%96%115%115%103%
1440p151%163%130%91%92%108%110%111%

9070XT (not oc) vs 5070 Ti


DescriptionAlan Wake 2Black Myth WukongCyberpunk 2077Half-Life ray tracedIndiana JonesPortal RTXQuake 2 RTXStar wars outlaws
4k73%40%68%64%35%66%71%79%
1440p77%42%69%69%40%62%73%84%

Indiana Jones seems broken for sure, even 5070 here is kneecapped

Black Myth wukong somehow flattens the RDNA 4 under a 5070 by quite a margin so that's... yea.

Cyberpunk 2077 seems to reach the "playable" state with 1440p. FSR4 performance maybe with 4k. Don't getting this is max, so really, optimization to be found.

Pretty big jump architecture wise compared to RDNA 3, considering it has to leap 7900XTX with was flagship and this is mid range.

But like @zeroluck says, for some games its border on playable while some it just didn't leap enough. I don't expect the RTX remix games to perform that well. It'll be on AMD users to test.

9070XT vs 5070 Ti for what is playable and not broken is maybe ~70% in some cases but again, if the card is true MSRP $599, means you have to find a 5070 Ti under ~$900 for it to make sense.
Which is possible if you buy a founders edition.
 

dgrdsv

Member
bArfZvL.jpeg

Imagine paying the nVidia tax and ending with this combination of pixelation and what seems to be an impressionist version of the image. Van Gogh am cry.
Combination of what? DLSS TNN just outputs higher detail here than either DLSS3 or FSR4. And this is typical in all comparisons I've seen.
FSR4 seem to trade blows with DLSS CNN but it is definitely worse than the TNN.
 

Nankatsu

Gold Member
These are MSRP for the reference models, Sapphire however has 2 "Pulse" versions they sell for MSRP. Availability is another question, though, hence I am saying "if you can get one"
sqKFblr.png

y3m6wIF.png


You'll have to wait another 12 hours before you can buy them.

Jesus, what is Asus smoking? More 210€ on the TUF Gaming OC model?

My GRE is an Asus TUF Gaming OC model, but I bought it for 570€ back then.
 

Xyphie

Member
One of the big retailers here in Sweden gave some deets on MSRP prices, confirming it's a limited launch price:

Current MSRP prices during the RX 9000 release
We now have an update on how the release of the new AMD Radeon RX 9070 and RX 9070 XT will go, when they are released today (March 6) at 15:00.

How MSRP prices work
We have now learned how the recommended prices, so-called MSRP prices, work for the launch of the AMD Radeon RX 9070 and RX 9070 XT. We are not allowed to say exact prices before the release, but simply explained they will apply to a limited number of cards.

For this release we will have MSRP prices from three manufacturers, where they all have both an RX 9070 and an RX 9070 XT at MSRP prices:

MSRP cards
PowerColor Radeon RX 9070 XT 16GB Reaper
PowerColor Radeon RX 9070 16GB Reaper
ASUS Radeon RX 9070 XT 16GB Prime OC
ASUS Radeon RX 9070 16GB Prime OC
Sapphire Radeon RX 9070 Pulse
Sapphire Radeon RX 9070 Pure

NOTE!

The prices only apply to the first shipment of each model. For Sapphire and ASUS it will look just like usual, we have only received one shipment and you can buy it until it runs out, but with PowerColor it will look different.

Our second delivery from PowerColor is already waiting, and we cannot offer it at MSRP prices. This means that we will first sell the Reaper models at MSRP prices and the stock balance will tick down as usual until the first delivery is sold out. Then, with a certain delay, the stock will be replenished with new cards and we will then release the Reaper cards for order again - although not at MSRP prices.

If you receive an order with MSRP prices even though the cards are sold out, we will of course give you that price, but unfortunately we are not able to continue selling cards at MSRP prices after the first deliveries are sold out.
 
Last edited:
Very good price but several outlets mentioned that AMD is basically sponsoring the stores to have cards at MSRP but after those are sold they will go up with like 10% or more. So if you're in the market for an MSRP card you may need to act quick.
So, has it turned out that fsr4 is better than PSSR as I legit expected fsr4 just to be pssr with a different name 😆
How could it not be better? It's running on much newer hardware.
 
Not gonna lie I like the look of that Sapphire Nitro, but I already have a 7900XT. If I could click my fingers and trade them for 150 I would but shifting a GPU is hard work without a box.
 
I thought the 9070XT was supposed to go head-to-head with the RTX4080, even in RT. What's happened? It seems that leakers have been spreading fake benchmarks and naive people really believed them.

Worse perfomance in raster compared to the 4080.

0uRWrFC.jpeg


Much worse in RT

nOOGGwA.jpeg


And still one generation behind in PT

5civFZb.jpeg


Q4gKDw3.jpeg


f0ZGkyh.jpeg


In cyberpunk Harwade Unboxed used only standard RT instead of PT byt still there's quite a big gap

MCgoHrJ.jpeg
 
Last edited:

Bojji

Member
I thought the 9070XT was supposed to go head-to-head with the RTX4080, even in RT. What's happened? It seems that leakers have been spreading fake benchmarks and naive people really believed them.

Worse perfomance in raster compared to the 4080.

0uRWrFC.jpeg


Much worse in RT

nOOGGwA.jpeg


And still one generation behind in PT

5civFZb.jpeg


Q4gKDw3.jpeg


OPpROhT.jpeg


In cyberpunk Harwade Unboxed used only standard RT instead of PT byt still there's quite a big gap

MCgoHrJ.jpeg


Yeah, as always with AMD some people were too optimistic. BUT I think overall 9070XT is a very good GPU and worth buying IF the price is right.
 

Nankatsu

Gold Member
They aren't supposed to go on sale until 1500 CET, which is 75 minutes from now; whatever that store is you linked looks lik it's trying to scalp.

Yeah, it's scalping. I edited the post, because it's sold on their marketplace and I didn't noticed it.

It's not a L for us, at least for now.
 
Last edited:

Nankatsu

Gold Member
Spotted a few more portuguese retailers with prices (not a marketplace) and the difference compared with MSRP is huge.

Meanwhile they took down the GPU's from their website, so probably that ended up being a placeholder price.
 

Zathalus

Member
I’ve got a feeling the EU prices will be north of 1100 Euro. If you’re determined to spend that much on a 9070 XT then you may as well pay 100 Euro more and get a 5070 Ti.
 
I thought the 9070XT was supposed to go head-to-head with the RTX4080, even in RT. What's happened? It seems that leakers have been spreading fake benchmarks and naive people really believed them.

Worse perfomance in raster compared to the 4080.

0uRWrFC.jpeg


Much worse in RT

nOOGGwA.jpeg


And still one generation behind in PT

5civFZb.jpeg


Q4gKDw3.jpeg


OPpROhT.jpeg


In cyberpunk Harwade Unboxed used only standard RT instead of PT byt still there's quite a big gap

MCgoHrJ.jpeg
Weirdly the 4K average is a lot closer to the 4080. I presume it's some kind of memory bandwith constraint, I'm no expert.

And yes these benches are from Hardware Unboxed.

2160p-p.webp
 
Top Bottom