Your speculations really don't matter. He ran his campaign on rigged election rhetoric for how many weeks, telling his shitty supporters to watch the booths for illegal activity, among other things that one could construe as fucking dangerous, and that's the narrative we have to work with, and that's how he should be judged.
You are speculating as well? You obviously believe he truly believes all he said. I don't. None of us know the guy, and none of us have asked him behind closed doors. He has at least openly done a 180 on Hillary being pursued for jail, and also on deporting immigrants. No, America, Trump isn't going to deport all Muslims and start concentration camps in January. Who could have known that was rhetoric???
I judge him just fine on being a con artist. You obviously judge him on being ironically, honest. Think about that for a second. You are non-ironically saying he is an honest man who believes everything he says? That is precisely how voters for him were conned. It's also how his detractors are being conned as well. Two birds killed with one stone.
He manages to appeal and/or con people sympathizing with his rhetoric that he will carry it all out, and also cons his opposition into mass frenzy and losing their shit constantly. Objectively a lot of the shit he actually pulled was a very tactical, albeit it dirty and deceitful, way to win an election.
His "masterstroke" on Hillary was getting her to waste time and/or almost kill her own campaign focusing on the basket of deplorables and Pepe the frog. My god that was embarrassing. As I said above, conning his detractors into a mass frenzy and uncontrollable bursts of emotion. He is still doing that today whenever he puts out a Tweet and the media goes bonkers. It's also savagely causing the left in general to lose its shit, but anyone following my rants on GAF as of late knows my criticism of the left is for another topic. It may not be popular but it's how I see it unfolding right now.