Does anyone know of policies that could make the process a lot easier on candidates?
Someone in another thread said his school had a job lottery where candidates and employers rated each other and were paired by an algorithm. That would be quite a shock to labor markets.I remember reading how attractive people get hired more frequently over more qualified people.
Does anyone know of policies that could make the process a lot easier on candidates?
That sounds about right. When I started my search, I put links to a portfolio project in my cover letter. I could tell nobody was looking at it based on view metrics. I got way better results when I just described it on my resume. I think the interviewer for my current job Googled my project so he could play it.As a hiring manager i can say I've never once read one and anytime resumes have been sent to other hiring managers in my department they are never included. Just the resume.
With a quick glance of the resume and the salary expectations it is typically quite easy to widdle down the list. It is amazing how bad some peoples resumes are... Or unreal their salary expectations are.
NYTimes said:In the past, I would have posted job ads on all the appropriate websites and braced for a flood of applications. Id spend a weekend afternoon sifting through them all, deleting three quarters and writing follow-up emails to the rest. I always mailed a list of questions for each candidate to complete, with a deadline for their return. This enabled me to filter out at least another half who either didnt reply in time, wrote dud answers or couldnt spell and didnt pay attention to details. Finally, Id have 10 or so interviews. Often, they would all be disappointing.
My problem was that the best candidates all had good positions and were not reading job advertisements.
With a quick glance of the resume and the salary expectations it is typically quite easy to widdle down the list.
I know it is said a lot but it is true. It is all about who you know more than your qualification. If you are not networking and just sending out applications blindly you will be looked over. Try to meet people from the place you are applying at. Hang out where they are hanging out and chat them up.
You will be surprised how many doors open up when you know someone inside as opposed to just sending resumes blindly where you end up being just another applicant in a stack of 500 other people who are applying for the same job that all have the same or better qualifications you have.
People like me who have severe social deficiencies and cant network worth shit are dead in the water, which is why im convinced im eating a bullet when the paychecks stop coming.
As a hiring manager i can say I've never once read one and anytime resumes have been sent to other hiring managers in my department they are never included. Just the resume.
With a quick glance of the resume and the salary expectations it is typically quite easy to widdle down the list. It is amazing how bad some peoples resumes are... Or unreal their salary expectations are.
Is putting "negotiable" on the salary expectation question okay?
NYTimes article: Why I Do All My Recruiting Through LinkedIn
I read this article yesterday from the perspective of an employer that really made me realize why applying for jobs through the most well-known job boards just doesn't work for most people.
Ah okay. ThanksNot unless it is accompanying a number in my opinion. That question is really just to ensure you're in the same ballpark as the budgeted salary for the position. Offering a range is an acceptable response though.
It's been 3 months for me, applied at 20 places and not even one phone call for an interview.
It's really getting to me, I feel like i'm letting my family down, especially after what they did for me during my time in school.
Sometimes I kinda break down at night because I feel like i'm not contributing anything to society.
soon as i lose my current job im just gonna kill myself. Being severely depressed in this job market basically means death.
I thought I had a fantastic job interview, but I guess someone did better.
It sucks to get so close and fall right back down to nothing. Ugh.
Anything is better than sitting around all day.Are you guys of the opinion that any experience is experience? I can get a retail job at the moment. Should I get that while I search for other jobs? I don't want to sit around on my ass all day...
Those are the exact two words I would use to describe it. I've been unemployed for a couple of months now and the situation is horrible. I hate spending hours on writing a good cover letter, polishing my resume for the specific job and getting a standard rejection email, or no response at all. It is terrible.
Still, you have to keep pressing on. I had my moments of wanting to give up, but I kept at it. Finally, after sending out almost 40 letters and having been to 7 interviews, I'm getting somewhere. Haven't signed anything yet, but if I land this job, it will all have been worth it.
I have some small tips that worked for me that might be valuable for people that are in the same situation:
- When replying to a position by email, send your email as a PDF and your motivation in the body of the email. Recruiters are lazy people and the less clicks they have to do, the better. They start reading your motivation when they open the email and the PDF format is easily openend and forwarded on mobile devices.
- Call for an update when you haven't heard anything back for at least a week. After that, try it again the next week if needed. If you haven't heard anything after that, let it go and move on.
- Create a routine for yourself. Finding a job is now your job. For me, I spent the morning going to the gym, doing some chores and from 12-5pm, I was looking for a job. Applying, looking for positions, calling people in my network for some updates, writing letters and so forth. That way I could relax in the evening and watch a movie or play a game. Creating and sticking to a routine will keep you sane, trust me.
- Above all, no matter how bad things get, never, ever give up.
Are you guys of the opinion that any experience is experience? I can get a retail job at the moment. Should I get that while I search for other jobs? I don't want to sit around on my ass all day...
the major trick to securing employment is to stand out from the pack. Unfortunately, it requires a lot to do this.
I was born and raised in Australia and it was difficult for me to secure a job post graduation. Once i got a (crap) job, i moved countries two years later.
As soon as i moved countries, i realised i was so far ahead of the pack here simply because there werent a huge amount of young, qualified expatriates in this region.
If you are a US citizen and have a degree from a US university, it might be worthwhile moving to a developing country such as the UAE, GCC countries, Malaysia or somewhere like this.
In the US, you may have a lot of competition, but in these areas, a young, qualified and well spoken individual might be a lot more difficult to come by.
Just being decent written and oral skills in English in these countries can often put you ahead of the game so it may be worthwhile looking abroad for job opportunities in areas that require qualified expats. Yes it's difficult, yes it's a HUGE risk...but it will look good on your future CV to show that you have worked around the world rather than just being born/raised/educated/worked in one particular city all your life.
Working is always better than not, but not all experience should be put on a resume. You have to tailor your resume to the specific industry and company. A lot of people think it's required to list every place you've ever worked. Wrong. I instantly toss resumes that put the ice cream parlor they worked at when they were 16 along with other irrelevant shit that clutters up their one page. Similarly, a lot of people that don't have much experience don't put enough non-work information on their resume to supplement their experience shortage. For example, someone who has only worked at the ice cream parlor, which is absolutely ok, doesn't have any type of internship/volunteer/club/organization/certificate/license or something that tells me that you're doing more than scooping ice cream and praying someone takes a chance on you.
I've given this advice here before, but most people here reply with no money/too afraid to leave home/family is important or something similar. By the time you're ~20 you've most likely spent enough time in one place.. people need to understand the world is way more accommodating nowadays and living your whole life where you were born is old fashioned.
Lack of proper feedback is the worst. Everyone deserves a chance to improve.Everyone that I provided support loved having me there except for my boss. I do have a reference from the agency (someone other than my boss or my co-worker), but I'm not looking forward to applying for jobs again. Especially considering I really loved providing assistance to the people working there and I think eventually I would have gotten up to speed if my boss had communicated or not have unreasonable expectations.
I once had a really great interview despite having to go through the whole thing with raspiness in my voice due to allergies. It seemed like they understood.I thought I had a fantastic job interview, but I guess someone did better.
It sucks to get so close and fall right back down to nothing. Ugh.
Got an email saying they "went in a different direction." Reason was flat-out that I "didn't have office experience." This was very specifically marked an ENTRY LEVEL job. And it was co-op, too. The whole reason I wanted the job was to gain the experience so that when I left college I would have something to work off of, but there's that good ol' catch 22.
The frustrating thing is when they don't even get back to you at all. Yeah that position I applied for was a longshot but I would really appreciate it if they just reply to you with No, thank you.
I always prefer when you apply and the next day you already get an email that you're not qualified enough. Those are better because you can get that job out of your mind and move on to something else.
HR is another term for incompetence.
I once had a really great interview despite having to go through the whole thing with raspiness in my voice due to allergies. It seemed like they understood.
5 positions and I think only 10 applicants. I was REALLY confident and also really desired the position.
Got an email saying they "went in a different direction." Reason was flat-out that I "didn't have office experience." This was very specifically marked an ENTRY LEVEL job. And it was co-op, too. The whole reason I wanted the job was to gain the experience so that when I left college I would have something to work off of, but there's that good ol' catch 22.
When you basically have a 50% chance and you still don't get the job, even after a good interview? Soul crushing indeed.
Took me 10 years to find a job (well 6 if I count that I have been studying) and I keep hearing from old timers that it was so easy to get a job 60-70 years back :/
I just graduated and I'm not looking forward to it, that's for sure.
I don't even know how to fill a resume when I've come straight out of college with no substantive job/internship experience to speak of.
I'm in business, so I'm not sure how much of what I've done to secure employment is applicable for other fields, but...
While at MBA, I sent out one dozen resumes and cover letters. I was interviewed nine times and received four job offers. Out of the MBA, moving into my second job, I sent out four resumes and cover letters, was interviewed four times, and received four job offers.
Here's what I've learned:
RESUMES / COVER LETTERS
1) Your grades don't matter, by and large. There are some, a small, prestigious few, that give a crap what your grades were - but most don't. So don't sweat them and don't focus too heavily on them in your resume.
2) Skills are very important. I'm not talking about listing "Highly Proficient in MS Office" - that's a tool, not a skill. What you know how to do with these tools is more important: "Multivariate Regression Analysis", "Segmentation through K-Means Clustering", "Conjoint Analysis", etc. Have a Skills / Assets section in which you call these out in bullets, but don't go into excruciating detail there or even in the body of each prior employment. What you did in prior jobs is about results - what did you drive for the company, how much money did you make them, how much time did you save them, etc. through your actions: "Clustered consumer segments and devised a tiered strategy which allowed [firm] to better target product assortment and pricing, leading to incremental sales of $8 million and GM of $2.6 million"... Try to quantify as best you can. 'Segmentation through K-Means Clustering' would be in the Skills / Assets section below, linking to that result.
3) Cover letters are often required. When I see someone ask, "How important is a cover letter?", my answer is: As important as you make it. If you are standardizing these things, be it a resume or cover letter, you are doing it wrong. Unless your ingredients list - i.e. the things you included in your resume - are absolutely, stupidly perfect for the job, you are hurting yourself by standardizing this stuff. Every resume and cover letter I have ever sent out was specifically built for the job and company I was applying for/to, from language used and skills listed, to design. Reflect their culture. Make it look like you already work there and already love it enough that you ape its style constantly. It's hard and it takes time, but it pays off.
4) Something I added to the end of all my cover letters was a section I simply called: "A Thought". In it, I provided a recommendation to the firm based on analysis I had done about their marketing strategy, their pricing, etc. Whatever I could figure out that I thought was insightful or interesting or just showed that I truly cared about the firm and its business. It also allows you to indicate your awareness of their industry - not just from their vantage point, but from the entire industry. How things work, how companies are competing, etc. It shouldn't be long; it should be concise. Don't waste it, it's valuable. About half the companies I received interviews from specifically cited that as something that they appreciated that got my resume moved up among the horde.
5) Follow up on a weekly basis. Do so twice. Let it go after. If you interview, send thank you letters / emails to everyone who interviewed you. As with the resumes and cover letters, make these communications specific to the individual. Mention what you talked about with them, how you think about it now, hours later.
Beyond that, the rest is just typical formatting bullshit. Show that you can deliver value to a company from the get-go and they will most likely want to at least talk to you.
INTERVIEWS
1) Know how to speak about why you want the specific job, why you like the company, and why you're a good choice for them. For the most part, knowing why you want the specific job and why you're a good choice for it will suffice, but there are many companies which take themselves very seriously and want to see that you take them seriously too.
2) Don't bullshit your top weaknesses and strengths. Make them legitimate. Talk about what you've learned while dealing with your weaknesses and what your plans are to continue to learn from and overcome them. Be specific. I've been an interviewer enough times that I can always tell who is full of crap and who isn't.
3) Show that you want to learn. Ask questions. Try to make it a conversation between the two/three of you rather than a shooting range. Look confident when you speak, but if they prove you're wrong about something, look pleased about it (that you've learned something), and thank them for the correction.
4) Be able to discuss how you come up with ideas through examples. This becomes increasingly more important when you're going for a job or have had jobs in which there is great ambiguity or critical thinking involved. Talk about the sequence of events, the steps that took you from a notion and led you to something actionable. Freely give credit to others you collaborated with or later inspired changes in your own thinking throughout the process. Practice will help you make this concise. If they want to know more, they can ask.
And that's about all I can think of that I consider really important. Might add more if I think of anything else.