Finally devoted a good chunk of time to this game this past weekend. My initial thoughts were that was a really pleasant surprise, but the more I play it the more annoyed I get with certain aspects.
- The stealth portions suck. The game gives you radar, but half the time it doesn't even seem accurate. The mission where you have to lead the senator to a safe house was totally infuriating because guards would appear that weren't on the radar. If they're going to go to the trouble of framing the story with the whole ridiculous Animus thing to help explain the HUD, then give us working radar or some way to detect what the guards can see.
- The controls can still be frustrating, especially in combat. I've done all of the training stuff and gotten gold medals, but I STILL don't feel like I'm doing it right. So much of the control is context sensitive that it can be kind of glitchy.
- The story is total gobbledigook. I would be much happier if we just had the Renaissance segments. So much time and attention is spent on those portions, it sort of cheapens it to frame it with the lame modern day segments.
There are a lot of things I like though. Training a squad of assassins is super addictive, and it feels awesome to call the entire squad down on a Borgia tower. I wish there was even more of this in the game.
The setting and style are top notch IMO. Even though Rome isn't as exciting as AC2, it's still
impressive to see all of these locations rendered in game. I studied art history in college, and I never thought I'd play a game like this. I want even more of it.
Overall it's less of a cash-in than I thought it would be, but I'm hoping 3 has some further refinements.