I'm having a bit of trouble deciding how I feel about this game. I like it, but there are a lot of changes that I'm not entirely happy about. They didn't ruin the game, it's still awesome... but I'm leaning towards liking the original better.
- I don't really like how it's moved from a more room-based Metroidvania type world in the first game to a more open world like Assassin's Creed. I didn't think I'd have a problem with this, but I do. It's not as fun to explore. It's harder for me to get a good mental visualization of where everything is in this type of game.
- The interiors are so much smaller than before. They were the meat of the first game, but it feels like there was much less focus on them this time.
- Combat is technically better in a lot of ways, but I feel like some of the things they introduce later on really complicate things beyond my comfort. There are enemies you have to stun to attack, okay, but then you have other enemies attacking you while you're in the cape stun animation, and apparently you can't counter out of it. And all the quick deploy gadgets are just well beyond what I'm able to think of at once. I was able to do the achievement in Asylum for doing all the moves in one combo, but there's no way I'd be able to do that in this game.
- Predator sections seem to have been toned down considerably. There aren't nearly as many of them, and the ones outside just aren't the same. On top of that, the ones that are there just don't seem as fun as the ones in the first game. And I can't tug guys off ledges anymore.
- There's so much going on in the story from minute 1, it's hard to really take it all in. Maybe this is just me.
- Similarly, there's so much going on in the overworld. Side missions and Riddler trophies everywhere. It's overwhelming.
- On that note, I'm really annoyed that you can't clear out the overworld of enemies for good, like in the first game. Having to worry about getting shot up by some guy you didn't see makes exploring for trophies considerably less fun.
I think the crux of a lot of my... I don't want to say complaints, because I really do like this game. I guess thoughts. The crux of a lot of my thoughts is that they made the game BIGGER and BETTER and MORE COMPLEX, and, for me at least, it wasn't always for the better.
On the other hand, the boss fights were a million times better than the first game. Freeze was easily the best, though, which was interesting, since it wasn't at a major turning point in the story, nor was it BIG AND BOMBASTIC AND HOLY SHIT LOOK AT ALL THIS STUFF GOING ON ISN'T IT AMAZING like the other major ones.