I'm not talking the CTE suppression here. In Live, it's not effected by the suppression there either. I can suppress a Bulldog user, they only have to aim in my general direction vomit ammo and kill me like nothing happened.
I have nothing against the new suppression system. I think it's amazing (outside of the shit visual effect that tunnel visions you too easily). My problem is purely with the gun.
So you agree with me it needs a nerf, then? Why are you saying "B-B-BUT THE AEK/other assault rifles" when those aren't the topic of the discussion. The Bulldog:
-High rate of fire
-Has no suppression issues/gets through suppression like a hot-knife through butter.
-High damage
The only draw-back is:
-Vomits ammo
Three pros, versus one con. Gee, why wouldn't anyone use it over the other assault rifle guns when it kills faster than the FAMAS, can be put in single-fire mode and basically fired as fast as your trigger finger will twitch?
The pros need to be tweaked. Just like they needed (and still need to be, the "recoil" tweak just made it slightly annoying to use) to tweak the AWS.
IMO High RoF guns shouldn't be able to lay you out in seconds flat versus slower rate of fire guns. They should have a lower "damage per-bullet" for obvious reasons. Why pick a slower firing gun when you can pick one that isn't effected by suppression, hold the trigger for two seconds and kill someone?
The drawbacks are considerable higher than average recoil (among the highest of any AR in the game), a very very long reload time, a small magazine meaning that you will take out 2 enemies at most 99% of the time before going through that painful reload time and the fast ammo consumption. It's not just ammo like you said.
As a close quarters weapon making you reload constantly and making that reload as long as they have is a big disadvantage when people are always at your face.
I said I'm fine with Dice tinkering with it, but if they don't I wouldn't mind as well to be honest. I don't think it is overpowered that's why I'm discussing this. As an assault I will not be using the gun in the long run.
Saying that high ROF shouldn't kill that fast compared to low ROF weapons makes no sense. They make serious trade offs to have that killing potential. What's the purpose of high ROF guns if not kill faster at close range? As I said both the bulldog and the FAMAS are advanced weapons that are not suitable for everyone. And even advance users won't be taking out enemies at medium to long rage left and right, and if they try they will eat all their ammo in seconds.
I think it's fair to compare the Bulldog with other high ROF weapons when you're saying it is the most OP gun in the game. When people say one weapon is the best other weapons definitely are in the topic of discussion, otherwise how you will say it is OP? Compared to what?
The AEK can kill people almost as fast, has less recoil and a big magazine, it is an overall better weapon IMO, the FAMAS can kill people just as fast from my experience, has the same recoil (we still don't have the synthic stats) and a bigger magazine.
If you're using a high ROF weapon like the bulldog in single firing mode you're using it wrong, period. Better go with the SCAR lower recoil then, because very few people will manage to get close to max rate of fire or even at a good ROF while still maintaining accuracy. I know I wouldn't. Firing it in single mode defeats the purpose of the gun.
I don't know how it is on PC, but on console I'm not seeing every assault running with a bulldog.
As far as suppression goes, I didn't see any differences from most other high ROF guns that I use. Maybe it's because I flank a lot so most of my kills my enemy isn't firing back or because I usually fire first meaning the enemy will be suppressed first.
Edit: I looked for some reviews of the gun and there is another considerable con that I didn't know and you didn't mention: Bullet velocity. The bulldog bullet velocity is at the low side at just 450m/s meaning at mid range if your enemy isn't completely stationary forget about him. With that bullet velocity, recoil and magazine size you will have a hard time killing moving targets at range.
It's obvious Dice balanced the gun for close quarters which is why killing people so fast makes sense. And another thing we both didn't know, the FAMAS STILL outdamages the Bulldog at close range.
Of the reviews I saw the only one that said that the bulldog
might be overpowered was Matimio, but even then he wasn't sure. Both LvlCap and Xfactor made some good points and X nailed it in the head IMO, for him the Bulldog isn't versatile enough to be considered the best assault rifle let alone the best gun in the game.
No one I could find mentioned the bulldog not suffering suppression effects on both CTE or vanilla servers.