Okay, here's my conundrum. I'm looking for a dungeon-crawl-y co-op action RPG to play with my brother when he returns home from college in December. Our favorite co-op games have included Diablo, Baldur's Gate Dark Alliance, L4D, etc. We've even watched each other play stuff like Mass Effect and Fallout 3. In that sense, I'm thinking Borderlands would be a really solid pick. It sounds like there's a nice character variety, decent weapons, fun co-op combat dynamics, etc.
Here's the caveat. He put loads of time into FO3 and doesn't sound terribly enthusiastic about Borderlands. I think he might be in a post-apocalypse fatigue? As for me, I enjoyed watching FO3 more than I enjoyed playing it; the post-apocalyptic setting eventually lost its luster.
Further, even though my bro and I are decently keen on stat management, stat micromanagement will turn us off pretty much immediately. How is Borderlands in that regard?
Lastly, we both got annoyed by the accuracy system in FO3. Is shooting in Borderlands closer to FO3 or L4D? How is accuracy calculated? Damage calculated?
Thanks.