Damn, I am tempted to do this. I have the original PS4 that makes a weird buzzing noise from the power cord when it is off, and it can get hot/loud while playing. For $99 I would get a brand-new upgraded console, Uncharted 4 (ehh, but decent), and Overwatch (the only one on the list that I would play). But you're saying because Overwatch is $79.99, I could potentially get any $79.99 game, or does TLG have some special trade-in deal?
No this isn't standard policy. It's just that I told the guy that I wasn't interested in any of the games and he told me to get Overwatch as it's the game with the highest market value. Told him I wasn't interested in Overwatch and wish I could get a game like FF XV or TLG instead. He went to talk to his manager and told me that we could figure something out and they'd probably let me get TLG instead of overwatch as they're selling both games for the same price and they won't discount Overwatch for some time (big seller).