• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

COMICS! |OT| January 2016. Didn't I promise? We're going home now.

W

whatsinaname

Member
Animal Man #12 - #17: More self-contained stories told within single issues but still containing hints to the endgame. I am really enjoying this. Loved the issues in Paris and in South Africa. (And the Dibnys). Why can't we have more happily married couples in comics...
 
M

Messi

Member
JEKKI said:
this cover is so cool~!!!

detail.jpg


only becoz they're showing love to EATAKU! aka one of my favorite websites!!

http://www.eataku.com/

it's a food blog run by one of Marvel's talent scouts, where he travels everywhere and eats lots of great stuff!

I always search thru his blog whenever I go travel somewhere,

or even when I'm looking for new recommendations here in LA!
Click to expand...

The story was great too
 
Brian Fellows

Brian Fellows

Pete Carroll Owns Me
Finally caught up on the issues of Nailbiter and Revival I got in the last Image sale.

Nailbiter was kind of all over the place with it's volume 2 issues it has gotten back on track and started moving the story ahead again with the last several issues.

Revival on the other hand hasn't stumbled at all. Every issue has been good. While there is an overarching mystery that still hasn't been explained through 17 issues the book doesn't waste any time wrapping up it's subplots. There is always something happening. None of the issues feel like filler. It's got a serious tone but there is still a bit of dark humor action along with plenty of mystery. The art probably isn't going to blow anyone away but it's still very good. Can't wait to buy more issues.

For now though it's time to get caught up on Rocket Girl and the 17 issues of The Walking Dead I got in the Image sale. I actually forgot to get one issue of Rocket Girl though. So I have 1-4 and 6. D'OH!
 
M

my name is ed

Banned
GrandHarrier said:
Issue #5 of Hitches JLA isn't written or drawn by Hitch and is apparently a Martian Manhunter one shot written by Kindt. Did some kind of mixup happen at the printers, lol?

And yes I'm still playing catchup.
Click to expand...
Haha I remember before JLA came out Hitch said he had about a dozen issues already drawn so there wouldn't be delays.

I guess that was a lie! Never trust a Hitch with a schedule
 
A

arkon

Member
shingi70 said:
Think I'm going to start collecting trades, my birthday is in a few more than so I can ask my family for a bookshelf.

What's the best way to read Transformers comics, saw some of the Wreckers stuff and it has me interested.
Click to expand...

http://www.tfw2005.com/boards/trans...03136-idw-transformers-g1-reading-orders.html

Follow reading order 1, although I would say you can skip straight to the number 1 issues of both RID and MTMTE in that without any loss. That said, Chaos Theory, Death of Optimus Prime and Last Stand of the Wreckers are all worth checking out.
 
M

Mindwipe

Member
Brian Fellows said:
Are RID and MTMTE that closely tied together?
Click to expand...

The first five volumes of each are nearly completely standalone - Volume 1 of MTMTE includes the "Death of Optimus Prime" one shot that sets up the status quo of both titles, and in theory the RID Annual carries on an event that happens in the MTMTE Annual, but both sections work without the other.

The Dark Cybertron crossover is set after Volume 5 of both and is the first meaningful interaction.
 
Brian Fellows

Brian Fellows

Pete Carroll Owns Me
Mindwipe said:
The first five volumes of each are nearly completely standalone - Volume 1 of MTMTE includes the "Death of Optimus Prime" one shot that sets up the status quo of both titles, and in theory the RID Annual carries on an event that happens in the MTMTE Annual, but both sections work without the other.

The Dark Cybertron crossover is set after Volume 5 of both and is the first meaningful interaction.
Click to expand...

arkon said:
Just the Dark Cybertron stuff. Otherwise it's just publication order.
Click to expand...

Cool thanks guys. I'm already getting annoyed with TMNT and the little editors notes in TMNT telling me I'm missing stuff happening outside the main series. Greedy bastards can't ever keep anything simple.
 
M

Mindwipe

Member
Brian Fellows said:
Cool thanks guys. I'm already getting annoyed with TMNT and the little editors notes in TMNT telling me I'm missing stuff happening outside the main series. Greedy bastards can't ever keep anything simple.
Click to expand...

Last Stand of the Wreckers could be considered to be a prequel to MTMTE, and there's a legitimate argument that it sets a major character up so you should read it first, but I just don't think it's as good a place tonally to jump in. It is still good though.
 
B

Boogiepop

Member
arkon said:
http://www.tfw2005.com/boards/trans...03136-idw-transformers-g1-reading-orders.html

Follow reading order 1, although I would say you can skip straight to the number 1 issues of both RID and MTMTE in that without any loss. That said, Chaos Theory, Death of Optimus Prime and Last Stand of the Wreckers are all worth checking out.
Click to expand...

Is the stuff before Last Stand of the Wreckers on that list any good/actually worth reading? I actually didn't know there was "important" stuff that came before that and don't have any of it currently...
Brian Fellows said:
Are RID and MTMTE that closely tied together?
Click to expand...

MTMTE is the one that's incredibly over the top good, while RID is good enough that I'd call it worth reading, but definitely isn't essential. If you do want to go in on both, I know there's some hardcover collected editions coming out now...
Brian Fellows said:
Cool thanks guys. I'm already getting annoyed with TMNT and the little editors notes in TMNT telling me I'm missing stuff happening outside the main series. Greedy bastards can't ever keep anything simple.
Click to expand...

On this though, the TMNT "side" trades are both important and totally worth getting. It really is a shame that they're not more clearly marked as such, as I'd imagine a lot of people DO skip them and just get the "main" books, but with a few exceptions that are skippable (definitely don't need to bother with the annuals, and as of right now and probably for the foreseeable future the Ghostbusters crossover won't be "important" at least), you really, really shouldn't ignore them. At least they're fixing that a little by putting them in the hardcovers, but seriously, the stuff in those is every bit as great as the main series, and for the most part every bit as important to the plot, so check them out!
 
T

TetraxShards

Member
Boogiepop said:
Is the stuff before Last Stand of the Wreckers on that list any good/actually worth reading? I actually didn't know there was "important" stuff that came before that and don't have any of it currently...
Click to expand...

The older stuff is Simon Furman Transformers through and through. If you want that, you're better off with the UK collections, and then the later Marvel issues and Generation 2 (G2 is fucking bonkers in the best way, kid me ate it up with a spoon).
 
Brian Fellows

Brian Fellows

Pete Carroll Owns Me
Boogiepop said:
I
On this though, the TMNT "side" trades are both important and totally worth getting. It really is a shame that they're not more clearly marked as such, as I'd imagine a lot of people DO skip them and just get the "main" books, but with a few exceptions that are skippable (definitely don't need to bother with the annuals, and as of right now and probably for the foreseeable future the Ghostbusters crossover won't be "important" at least), you really, really shouldn't ignore them. At least they're fixing that a little by putting them in the hardcovers, but seriously, the stuff in those is every bit as great as the main series, and for the most part every bit as important to the plot, so check them out!
Click to expand...

Welp I just dropped TMNT. This is the same reason I quit Marvel and DC. I am 100% Image from here on out.
 
B

BKatastrophe

Member
shingi70 said:
Think I'm going to start collecting trades, my birthday is in a few more than so I can ask my family for a bookshelf.

What's the best way to read Transformers comics, saw some of the Wreckers stuff and it has me interested.
Click to expand...
Well, I'm doing what Tizoc suggested and reading The Last Stand of the Wreckers and then More Than Meets the Eye. It's working for me.

Also, TLSotW is boss as hell.
Baron von Loathsome said:
How are the last two volumes of JLD, anyway?
Click to expand...
Not good. Don't read past the first three (Lemire's run). DeMatteis just fucks that book. Miligan has vol. 1 and then Lemire has vol. 2 and 3. After that just don't bother. The story gets all convoluted in the Blight crossover (between JLD and Constantine) and on top of that the Constantine series isn't good either.
whatsinaname said:
Animal Man #12 - #17: More self-contained stories told within single issues but still containing hints to the endgame. I am really enjoying this. Loved the issues in Paris and in South Africa. (And the Dibnys). Why can't we have more happily married couples in comics...
Click to expand...
Well, we had the West family, but the New 52 fucked that.
 
B

Boogiepop

Member
Brian Fellows said:
Welp I just dropped TMNT. This is the same reason I quit Marvel and DC. I am 100% Image from here on out.
Click to expand...

For what it's worth, it honestly works out to something equivalent to them largely double shipping TMNT/the net length just being about double what it first appears. For most of the run (though it's not 1:1 exactly), they've been releasing a mini-series at a time alongside the numbered run, and then they alternate what comes out in trades. So what you'd need to add to the "normal" trades is the Micro-series stuff, then Secret History of the Foot Clan, and then I believe Ultrom Empire should have at least something of importance (though I don't recall as well as to what falls where, and you may well be able to get by without it, I just don't remember exactly what plot points may have happened in this one). After that, Turtles in Time is super fun, but IIRC you could skip that and be fine. And Mutanimals and the Casey and April trade (which to be fair. I haven't read yet so I can't comment on 100%) feel like the kind of things that are just too new. I'd imagine they'd eventually get importance, but for now may not matter too much. And then there's the crossovers and the annuals, which should be totally skipable (I know the first annual and the Ghostbusters crossover at least do technically get a "see X" box once each, but you really, really don't need to read them).

And to be fair, like with Marvel/DC you totally can ignore this stuff and probably get by, but I don't think it's even vaguely equivalent to the sprawling mess of "x references y, and then that pulls events from z, and so on and so on" that you can hit with those two (plus all the "spin-offs" here just feel like more of the main story, just with slightly different themes and focuses, and are well done and enjoyable across the board). The worst thing it really does is make it a little trickier to keep track of what goes where, which I do wish they'd make more apparent to people who may be coming in later and aren't just picking up the floppies/trades as they come out.

Edit: I always type waaaaaay too much when it comes to TMNT stuff, geeze.
 
G

Groof

Junior Member
Hey all. I got a years sub to Marvel Unlimited for Christmas and I'm wondering if there's a delay in the release of a comic and when it's on there?
 
O

Owzers

Member
Groof said:
Hey all. I got a years sub to Marvel Unlimited for Christmas and I'm wondering if there's a delay in the release of a comic and when it's on there?
Click to expand...

yup, six months typically. You could always read Nextwave on there and enjoy comics life.
 
T

TheFlow

Banned
Brian Fellows said:
Welp I just dropped TMNT. This is the same reason I quit Marvel and DC. I am 100% Image from here on out.
Click to expand...
IDW has been adding in editor notes since issue 5-6.

It doesn't get to me but TMNT has a lot of mini series and tie ins that could be added to the story. I am not going to drop it yet though since I am still catching up
 
V

VanWinkle

Member
Groof said:
Damn, 6 months for real? That's a crazy long time, but at least I got lots to read. Guess I'll check out some older events. Thanks!
Click to expand...

Well, I mean, it's not really meant as a replacement to buying current-running series, but when you think about what you get for the money, it's still an absolute steal.
 
S

Sesuadra

Unconfirmed Member
Hello Comic GAF

I actually wanted to create a new thread but hey, why not ask the pros in the OT first.

So because of star wars I started collecting the new marvel comics in the form of the trade paperbacks, luckily amazon.de sells them ^_^.

know I acquired 4 of them so far and plan to buy all of 'em
except maybe the leia one...they seem to be really bad

but how to store them? I don't know what kind of protective sleeves I need or what else.
if found that store in germany: http://www.x-comics.de/Kombi-Angebote sorry it is in german, but I guess you gals and guys are all so awesome that you know just from looking at it if it's good or not...

I am happy about any information on how and what I need.
thank you all :D
 
Brian Fellows

Brian Fellows

Pete Carroll Owns Me
TheFlow said:
you sure? you haven't even hit the good stuff yet.
Click to expand...

For now at least. I can always start back up later. If IDW really wants my business they'll do a line wide sale on Comixology.

But for now I'm just gonna get an extra back issue of Revival per week in place of TMNT.
 
Z

Zombine

Banned
Hawkeye Omnibus came in the mail today, so I'd say the thread is a go. I'm p sure I'm going to say fuck it and just re read these next two days.
 
G

GAMEPROFF

Banned
Sesuadra said:
Hello Comic GAF

I actually wanted to create a new thread but hey, why not ask the pros in the OT first.

So because of star wars I started collecting the new marvel comics in the form of the trade paperbacks, luckily amazon.de sells them ^_^.

know I acquired 4 of them so far and plan to buy all of 'em
except maybe the leia one...they seem to be really bad

but how to store them? I don't know what kind of protective sleeves I need or what else.
if found that store in germany: http://www.x-comics.de/Kombi-Angebote sorry it is in german, but I guess you gals and guys are all so awesome that you know just from looking at it if it's good or not...

I am happy about any information on how and what I need.
thank you all :D
Click to expand...

Für Tradepaperbacks braucht man IMO keine Hüllen, die Trades stehen IMO recht fest im Regal, wenn du aber wirklich was haben möchtest, such ich dir noch was raus

Edit: Golden oder Silver Age Bags von Ultra Pro, Golden für Hardcover, Silver für Softcover
 
S

Sesuadra

Unconfirmed Member
GAMEPROFF said:
Für Tradepaperbacks braucht man IMO keine Hüllen, die Trades stehen IMO recht fest im Regal, wenn du aber wirklich was haben möchtest, such ich dir noch was raus
Click to expand...

Na dann würde ja ein Karton reichen..weil Regal ist gerade nicht möglich :/! Zumindest für die nächsten 12-16 Monate nicht.
Danke!

Edit: Dein Edit gesehen, also falls ich noch in Richtung Hüllen gehen will die Silver nehmen. Ist ja alles Softcover :)

whatsinaname said:
Hello, and welcome!

Those protective sleeves/boards are actually for storing single issues. (The boards are to provide stiffness).

Most of us do not use any additional protection for trade paperbacks and hardcovers. If you do prefer using something, I've seen people online use a few things.

1) Magazine sized plastic bags.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000PY9DKO/?tag=neogaf0e-20

2) For a more permanent solution, my local library uses these.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1UAYV6TwHFk
Click to expand...

Thanks! yeah I guess the sleeves/boards are overkill with trade softcover.
But one of those boxes will be nice for me..don't have space on my shelve anymore >.<
 
W

whatsinaname

Member
Zombine said:
Hawkeye Omnibus came in the mail today, so I'd say the thread is a go. I'm p sure I'm going to say fuck it and just re read these next two days.
Click to expand...

I got my OHC v2 in today as well. Still have the last issue to read. It wasn't on MU by the time my sub ended. -_-

Sesuadra said:
Hello Comic GAF

I actually wanted to create a new thread but hey, why not ask the pros in the OT first.

So because of star wars I started collecting the new marvel comics in the form of the trade paperbacks, luckily amazon.de sells them ^_^.

know I acquired 4 of them so far and plan to buy all of 'em
except maybe the leia one...they seem to be really bad

but how to store them? I don't know what kind of protective sleeves I need or what else.
if found that store in germany: http://www.x-comics.de/Kombi-Angebote sorry it is in german, but I guess you gals and guys are all so awesome that you know just from looking at it if it's good or not...

I am happy about any information on how and what I need.
thank you all :D
Click to expand...

Hello, and welcome!

Those protective sleeves/boards are actually for storing single issues. (The boards are to provide stiffness).

Most of us do not use any additional protection for trade paperbacks and hardcovers. If you do prefer using something, I've seen people online use a few things.

1) Magazine sized plastic bags.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000PY9DKO/?tag=neogaf0e-20

2) For a more permanent solution, my local library uses these.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1UAYV6TwHFk
 
G

GAMEPROFF

Banned
Sesuadra said:
Na dann würde ja ein Karton reichen..weil Regal ist gerade nicht möglich :/! Zumindest für die nächsten 12-16 Monate nicht.
Danke!

Edit: Dein Edit gesehen, also falls ich noch in Richtung Hüllen gehen will die Silver nehmen. Ist ja alles Softcover :)
Click to expand...

Kauf dir erstmal am besten ne Einzelne, hab das aus dem Paniniforum geklaut, die haben normalerweise immer recht, da ich aber nur meine Floppies eintüte, kann ich da keine 100%ige Versicherung geben. Ich vertrauen denen aber sehr.
 
T

Tyrant Rave

Banned
Just finished Born Again and wow, what an amazing comic from start to finish. Matt's metaphorical death and rebirth were done so well and it's such a GOOD comic. The writing and art come together perfectly. So many wonderful moments like this:

tumblr_nn8b1fG98n1upfu3oo4_500.jpg

tumblr_nn8b1fG98n1upfu3oo5_500.jpg

(the trade looks much cleaner... I'm a huge sucker for how the original singles look though)

Must read comic IMO.
 
S

Sesuadra

Unconfirmed Member
GAMEPROFF said:
Kauf dir erstmal am besten ne Einzelne, hab das aus dem Paniniforum geklaut, die haben normalerweise immer recht, da ich aber nur meine Floppies eintüte, kann ich da keine 100%ige Versicherung geben. Ich vertrauen denen aber sehr.
Click to expand...


Ich hab dem X-Comic laden auch mal ne Mail geschickt..aber ich denke ich tendier zur "Box only" Lösung :).
 
G

GAMEPROFF

Banned
Tyrant Rave said:
Just finished Born Again and wow, what an amazing comic from start to finish. Matt's metaphorical death and rebirth were done so well and it's such a GOOD comic. The writing and art come together perfectly. So many wonderful moments like this:

tumblr_nn8b1fG98n1upfu3oo4_500.jpg

tumblr_nn8b1fG98n1upfu3oo5_500.jpg

(the trade looks much cleaner... I'm a huge sucker for how the original singles look though)

Must read comic IMO.
Click to expand...

God, I loved Nuke in this book.
 
V

ViewtifulJC

Banned
only bad part of Born Again is some of the finale, since it was part of an ongoing narrative and a temporary writing gig, Frank had to do all that stuff at the end about Captain America and shit, and the FoggyxMurdock reconciliation doesn't happen until waaaaaaaaay later(like the end of Nocenti's run, #291), even though it feels like it should happen at the end.
 
J

JTripper

Member
Just read the finale to Brubaker's The Fade Out.

It was pretty good, but I think I missed something potentially important.
Was Charlie a communist? That last conversation with Brodsky about him reading his military file and having a 'secret' confused me a bit. Or did he just mean him ghost writing for Gil as the 'secret'?
 
G

GAMEPROFF

Banned
ViewtifulJC said:
only bad part of Born Again is some of the finale, since it was part of an ongoing narrative and a temporary writing gig, Frank had to do all that stuff at the end about Captain America and shit, and the FoggyxMurdock reconciliation doesn't happen until waaaaaaaaay later(like the end of Nocenti's run, #291), even though it feels like it should happen at the end.
Click to expand...
Yeah, the appearence of the Avengers feelt really wrong
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

  • Poll
Rate The Game Awards 2023
News 2 3
107
7K
Shakka43 replied
  • Locked
Xbox launches "Black History Month" promotional campaign for the month of February.
2 3 4 5
228
17K
MidGenRefresh replied
COMICS!!! |OT| January 2017 This is the Dawning of the Age of Apocalypse
115 116 117 118 119
6K
257K
BenjaminBirdie replied
COMICS!!! |OT| September 2017 | 25 Years of wearing a smile to work!
64 65 66 67 68
3K
221K
Einchy replied
COMICS!!! |OT| August 2017 | Gwenpool's milkshake brings all the boys to the yard
90 91 92 93 94
5K
269K
Aizo replied
Top Bottom