Booshka! I misinformed you. My stats are actually:
END 46
STR 35
DEX 34
Not as strong as I thought
Anyway, I've the Large Ember now, so I'm able to +10 my spare Claymore. My question is, would I see the benefits from scaling compared to my +5 Lightning immediately, or would it need more time?
And what's your opinion of the Black/Silver Knight swords (not the Great)? Do they scale?
The absolute best thing about the Black Knight Weapons (Aside from looks) is that they're so easy to upgrade. If you get one, you can have it at +5 before ringing the 2nd bell of awakening and only making one quick detour into the Great Hollow. With the regular weapons, you need to head down into New Londo Ruins and drain the water to make them competitive with the Black Knight weapons, which early in the game is a big detour and a pain in the ass for me.
There are some huge caveats with the Black Knight weapons. First off, they all require 18 dexterity. For pure strength builds, this investment might not be worth it.
By and large they generally do weigh a lot more and their R2 attacks are almost all useless. Cool, but useless from a practical standpoint.
Plus they're random drops from non respawning enemies. So unless you're willing to remake the character over and over again until one drops you can't rely on getting one.
None of the black knight weapons can be buffed with Crystal Magic Weapon, Sunlight Blade or Darkmoon Blade.
There are usually stronger equivalents within the same weapon class. For a pure strength build the Man Serpent Greatsword +15 is a better strength weapon than the Black Knight Sword. It has a better moveset too and the only problem is a slightly higher equip burden and the greater upgrade difficulty.
The Silver Knight Straight Sword is alright for a straight sword. It'd damage is mostly equivalent to the Balder Side Sword, which is a huge fan favorite. It's buffable too which really helps. I prefer the Balder Side Sword's movement personally.
The Balder Side Sword only requires 10 strength as well, compared to the Silver Knight Sword's 16.
The Silver Knight Sword has a much higher Dexterity requirement at 22, but considering both weapons are best used for dexterity builds I consider that a moot point since you'll most likely have 40 dexterity anyway.
The biggest problem with the Silver Knight Straight Sword is the weight imo. The Balder Side Sword and the Silver Knight Sword have mostly equivalent damage, but the BSS weights 3.0 while the Silver Knight Sword weights 6.0 which is huge for it's weapon class.
That said, the Silver Knight Straight Sword is my favorite looking weapon in it's class by a big margin.
This is a great tool for figuring out what weapons to use. Just enter your stats, check which weapon classes you're interested in and compare the damage.
http://mugenmonkey.com/darksouls/weapons