EatChildren said:
I'm still too early in Xenoblade to judge it, but majority of the media (wait, I'm the media...) will ignore it on the principle that it's a Wii game, and a JRPG. Though it really only has Skyward Sword to go against it in the Wii specific catagories.
Skyrim will be the RPG darling for this year. Near everyone I know is already going apeshit over it. Witcher 2 will get ignored as its a PC only game (for the time being), and Deus Ex will probably get overshadowed by the aforementioned Elder Scrolls.
I'd assume Uncharted 3 to be another media darling, but I dont think it will be. Portal 2 will be in a good running for GOTY, and I think Gears 3 will be too if it ends the series on a strong note.
EDIT: For me personally, DE:HR will be in my top five for the GAF GOTY votes, possibly top three.
Media Darlings for the year will probably be SWTOR, BF3, and Skyrim.
UC3, Diablo III, AC:R will be contenders, but I think they'll get pegged as solid sequels. But not the jump previous entries in the series made.
Zelda will be Zelda. Some will love it, others will hate it and wish its more similar to their favorite in mainline entry.
Gears and RAGE are the two I can't quite pin yet. Gears if it fixed everything will be a good contender, while I could see RAGE hitting the same note as Borderlands.
I don't really see Deus Ex, Dark Souls, or Witcher 2 having a fighting chance for much with most of the media. But I think these three are going to preform exceptionally well on Gaf's list at the end of the year.
Right now, Its definitely the best game of the year for me, though its not particularly saying much.... Its the only game that came out this year that I played to completion. Heh. Even still, its one of the best experiences I had for the generation if I say so very preemptively.