Think I am about done with the game and just wanted to post some final thoughts here.
I never played the original Diablo 2, was mostly a console gamer back then. This was a nice opportunity to see what I missed out on after enjoying D3 on and off for years.
What I liked:
- The vibe of this game is miles ahead of D3. From the excellent music, to color palette, to lighting system, to the dark brooding atmosphere.
- I disliked having tons of affixes on screen in D3, forcing you to spend a considerable amount repositioning and waiting for them to expire. D2 has a much simpler and satisfying system of moving slightly out of range of things, kiting, and dodging slow projectiles. You are constantly moving and fighting.
- I like the rune system as it adds a whole layer to gearing. I also like that sets are strong but aren't the end all be all of gearing.
- Love the loot system and how many things can be valuable. From white and grey bases, to charms, to jewels, to runes. You can find a real gem when you least expect it.
- Seems like every class has a few viable builds so the balance is alright if you don't count the teleport ability making everyone go sorceress until they have Enigma.
- The trading system and how it makes you feel like part of a community.
What I didn't like:
- Everyone is a Sorc due to teleport. It's hard to trade when everyone is looking for the same few items.
- Being this old, this is pretty much a solved game. Everyone knows what is valuable and aims for those items, so mid range items and minor upgrades struggle in the trade economy.
- Meanwhile, self-found gear is a bit too slow for my tastes. It was easy enough to get a decent build that can go through Hell via trading, but after I got 3 piece tal, a spirit, magefists, decent yellow amulet/rings, and geared my merc, I hit a wall that wouldn't budge for several days. I needed to find a high rune or bust. I tried farming some popular spots like hell ancient tunnels, hell durance of hate, hell mephisto, andariel, etc for a few hours a day while listening to podcasts without making any real progress for the past 3-4 days.
- Demand for starting gear like monarchs, 4os polerams, resist charms, MF items dropped considerably after the first few days so I wasn't able to trade as much.
it's a great fucking game and I am glad I played the heck out of it for for a couple of weeks. The dislikes I have are not the fault of the game itself but is a product of everything being pretty much figured out by the community. The trading is one of this games' biggest strengths. If I was at least getting something like a PUL rune a day or unique I can trade for a mid rune I would stick around and slowly build up for a month to trade for an item I need. As it is, I think I am ready to move on due to having horrible luck for the last few days. Kudos to those that can weather the RNG variance of not getting shit for days on end.