I know I know ... I'm about a month late to the party, but hey ;p. Bought RoP earlier this evening because I had some time to kill and Just finished a1 with a Wizzard on Master. Almost as expected I have very mixed feelings about the game.
Bottom line: I think for the millions of people who bought D3 on release the game has become much much better with RoP. Sadly not for me, since I actually liked the grind heavy stupid as shit release D3.
I've went relatively blind into RoP but the one thing I knew about was "Loot 2.0"/"Smart Drops". While I like the overall idea of cutting useless junk rares it went abit too far in my (short) experience. Basically everything is a upgrade. Oh? Butcher dropped rare shoulders? Check if they have any main stats on them - if they do equip, since they'll be a upgrade. No need to compare anything at all.
Please don't get me wrong. I understand that I'm talking about A1 here and endgame will be different. Still, so far I don't really like this change. It basically changed "Loot 2.0" into "Loot Autopilot" for me.
Difficulty. I'll give it to you - release Inferno was stupid. Yet it had something special for me. You litteraly were to scared to progress past A2 Inferno because you were scared of stupid bees. We all know what happened then, goblins. Did it go a bit too far with gob farming? Yeah sure. But overall I liked the dynamic of farming up.
I understand why that had to be changed. Some damage spikes just were off. What I'm really dissapointed about is the removal of whole game mechanics. The fire in Halls of Agony barely tickles, falling trees don't deal much damage either and then there is the removal of complete monster affixes.
Again, I know that I've just finished A1, yet I hoped for more difficulty playing on Master/Torment 1 with the removal of nightmare/hell/inferno and added slider difficulties.
Overall I had fun for the last 2 hours and that's what counts. I'll play to 70 and then ... let's see. I feel like the Diablo franchise is back where it belongs: Killing shit, looting stuff and pleasing the "casual"(I hate that word, but it's appropriate here)gamer.