SuperGT does tech reviews/analysis too?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Digital Foundry: Inside The New Forza Motorsport: Turn 10's Radical Technology Revamp
- Thread starter adamsapple
- Start date
SuperGT does tech reviews/analysis too?
crackajack
Member
So RT wastes probably a ton of ressources to force some photo mode features into the actual game.
I guess I understand why they do it, a jab towards GT7, and being able to say "our game has RT even in game". But it makes just no sense with either console.
RT in general should only be done by some games that have plenty of room because of some specific simpler art style (or ancient stuff like Quake2) and sideprojects by engine teams as tech demos to be ready when the hw actually is. Any game that wants to squeeze the best solution out of the current hw better stays away from RT for now. Even 4090 struggles with RT stuff when doing it a bit more like it is supposed to be, so no way any console is ready.
I also wonder if some games don't artificially make old gen tech look worse. Some reflections I saw in RTX off comparisons looked imho worse than what PS4 is able to do. Puddles looked awesome since years, mirroring nonsense but not really super obvious, and now suddenly its again a blurry mess like in PS3 days?
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
You forgot The Narrative™
ShakenG
Member
Tracks RT mirror - Trackside detail in reflection.
Cars RT mirror - cars in reflection.
??
Last edited:
Turk1993
GAFs #1 source for car graphic comparisons
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Control had these very issues with reflective surfaces and even textures. Less investment into rasterization by leaning on the RTX crutch. Performance be damned.
Last edited:
fatmarco
Member
It's nice to see the developers justify their choices and explain things, but fundamentally this looks worse than Forza Horizon 5 by a significant margin.
The reflections are blurry, it's got a weird washed out filter over it (maybe HDR content translating to SDR?), its shaders look flat/ lack contrast, the textures don't pop at all, and it doesn't look like its rendering at a high enough native resolution.
I mean you can't even make the argument that this game is going for a more realistic looking aesthetic as it looks cartoonier and more stylised than Forza Horizon 5 does. Direct comparisons with Horizon 5 will be a bloodbath I fear.
The reflections are blurry, it's got a weird washed out filter over it (maybe HDR content translating to SDR?), its shaders look flat/ lack contrast, the textures don't pop at all, and it doesn't look like its rendering at a high enough native resolution.
I mean you can't even make the argument that this game is going for a more realistic looking aesthetic as it looks cartoonier and more stylised than Forza Horizon 5 does. Direct comparisons with Horizon 5 will be a bloodbath I fear.
Last edited:
ShakenG
Member
Trying not to nitpick turk but i absolutely hate those sparks. Ive never seen a car do that before in that manner.
Last edited:
DJ12
Member
Alternatively, he wants to do it in November so it doesn't affect the hype push for release, because it doesn't really hold up.
Essentially Forza is more towards the arcade end of the simcade scale so it's not that big a deal, add some razzle dazzle if you are going more for the casual fun experience.
Last edited:
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
And what about RT outside mirrors? Or will only be in mirrors?
Last edited:
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
Great video. Really interesting to hear their choices. Unreal that they got 60fps and raytracing on track. Gg
Nothing more baffling in tech or gaming than seeing people complain about options they can easily ignore.
ShakenG
Member
Just a guess but i believe they are calling 'mirror' the reflection of the whole car, not just the cars 3 mirrors. Only way it makes sense to me.
Last edited:
Elysium44
Banned
Correct me if I'm wrong but the previous Forza games already reflect their surroundings without needing RT to do it. And likewise you can see the reflection of cars on wet roads. I know it's not as technically clever or accurate but the illusion is certainly good enough for me, especially if you just play the game rather than pause it to pixel peep.
CrustyBritches
Gold Member
I'm more of a Forza Horizon fan, but it will be nice to try this out on PC. So far they've confirmed DLSS, FSR 2.2, and RTGI for PC. It would be nice to eventually get DLSS 3 FG. We'll see if they update it later.
ShakenG
Member
Personally, i agree with you. A mix of cube maps and SSR should be more than enough. But was just trying to explain what "RT trackside mirror" might mean. But for PC gamers, no harm in pushing for the extra bells and whistles.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
No harm in pushing on consoles if there is headroom, either.
There's a 4K/60 option without RT that'll probably be more closer to 2160p than the RT version as well, for those who want it.
Last edited:
Loxus
Member
The yellow glow on the road looks unnatural to me as well.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
So John wants to compare a current-gen exclusive game with a last-gen game that was released 18 months ago?
And they hate the idea of a PS5 Pro
RickMasters
Member
Hang on….. I thought there was a ceasefire after the ABK buy out?…I thought we all agreed to play nice or Microsoft will buy gearbox from embraced group? … fine…. I knew the peace could only last so long. The ceasefire is over…. To war!
Ok I’m just being dramatic now.
RickMasters
Member
I hope people don’t work out how to do this to other players online. I’ll scream so hard into my headset I’ll get one of those new sensitive Xbox bans
MidGenRefresh
*Refreshes biennially
Is there footage of a fully maxed out PC version?
Bloobs
Al Pachinko, Konami President
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
Thats what I want to see as well
Turk1993
GAFs #1 source for car graphic comparisons
Its for the track, instead of SSR and cubemaps its using full RT reflections on the track it self.
RickMasters
Member
I agree. Though part of me thinks I’ll still try out the performance RT mode often enough, but yeah I’ll probably not notice it much while actually racing. To focused on track position and race craft to look at my car on the reflections other people cars….. besides….. I won’t see anybodys cars in front of me by lap 2. I play racing games better than anybody so all I see is cars in the rear view. Maya sell just give me a more detailed rear view mirror as I’ll see cars in that more often than next to, or in front of me.
I’m like….. the driving game version of senna or Hamilton. Or mansel…. Or Prost.or Schumacher. I’m all dat behind the wheel. But yeah…. You guys all behind me can tell me if the reflections look good on your cars. I’m too busy being in first place.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
A lot of track cars and performance cars will have flat bottoms from the scuff plates for wind diffusion.
A Honda Civic Si, however, does not.
Turk1993
GAFs #1 source for car graphic comparisons
Its just a zoomed in photomode shot, Forza doesn't render extra details in the zoomed in area like other games.
Maybe the graphics will be better in the full version.
ShakenG
Member
Haha right, obviously thats correct. I shouldn't be posting this late.Its for the track, instead of SSR and cubemaps its using full RT reflections on the track it self.
Whats worse is, thats how i actually understood it at first
Cheers Turk.
rodrigolfp
dont mind me, sorry for confusion.
Gaiff
SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
The reflection of the main car in the blue one? That's nice but I doubt anyone notices it while blowing past the other car. There's also the reflection on the tarmac but I'm not sure how it would look with SSR (or maybe cubemaps? Not sure what fallback solution the game uses).
twilo99
Gold Member
The CPU choice for this generation consoles was indeed very poor and hopefully they learn their lesson.
twilo99
Gold Member
It worthless in most games IMO.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
I think it's more that requirements have increased quickly for the kinds of new tech devs want.
The CPU's being Zen2 was hailed as a huge victory and a massive improvement over the Jaguar's relative to their time of release when this gen started.
Last edited:
Turk1993
GAFs #1 source for car graphic comparisons
Its also noticable in the cockpit with cars that have a reflective interior and it looks really nice with all the accurate reflections in real time. Also thats not a reflection on the ground, its the light bounce of the yellow car by the headlight of the blue car.
Gaiff
SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
Because it's half-assed in most games. When implemented properly, it's awesome but sadly, this requires a lot of compute power.
twilo99
Gold Member
That's also true, but to be honest its a really gimped Zen2 anyway, mid or top of the line would've aged much better. I understand the thermal constraints, price, etc. but they need to figure something out for the next round.
Mister Wolf
Gold Member
Control is the only game that made raytraced reflections worthwhile due to its location. Metro Exodus, Dying Light 2, and Cyberpunk are the only ones to utilize RT Lighting properly. Everything by everyone else has been hogwash.
Last edited:
Dural
Member
The gaming side has gotten to the point that I don't even want to visit it anymore. We have a racing game with multiple options for RT in game and a performance option for none at all and there's still complaining about it even having RT. Something no one thought would be possible in real time on consoles.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
The only thing that will work is if the new consoles are modular and allow cheaper upgrades.
I can already sense a Pro console post from
HeisenbergFX4
incoming but investing in a new console for the same brand, same generation, just to get marginal improvements is a big ask for a lot of people. Pro and One X barely made a blip in the sales. Having modular components will make it a lot easier and affordable for people*.* but then you're basically turning them into PCs.
twilo99
Gold Member
I think they've done a great job on that considering the weak hardware they have to deal with, it's rather impressive actually.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
How tho? There are other games with "4K" 60fps RT modes. Full open world ones too.
What people doubted and were correct on, was the usage of 4K being insinuated as being native.
Last edited:
twilo99
Gold Member
All in for that but it will never happen unfortunately. Maybe they can make CPU, RAM, and storage upgradable, but keep the rest stock? I dunno..
Negotiator101
Member
Negotiator101
Member
WTF?