Sorry, I wasn't aware how far back the discussion went, didn't intend to incite hostility.
I'll say again, I'm not sure how anyone can argue against it. It provides everything Medusa needs in an item.
- Stats Very cost ineffective
- Movement Yasha does the same
- Survivability Nope
- Wave clear/split push Nope, illusions do absolutely shit damage
- Increase farming speed in jungle Yasha does the same
- Utility i.e. dodging spells, etc. Ok, even though dodging spells can be insanely hard, that's the only use of manta, dispelling shit ie silences and all but that doesn't mean you make the item in every game
It's just a fantastic item on any agi carry, but I think specifically Medusa benefits from it with her natural tanky-ness, and split-shot ability.