You've explained why I like her better than I could.It's true. Vivienne may look down on everyone, but it's only because everyone is being so naive about how rulership and stability actually work. You can have disagreements with her, but your reasoning better be more articulate than a teenager demanding freedom over their own life from their parents.
The mages are busy looking at what is possible instead of what happens because of their search of it, the rebels of every other sort are too busy looking at incidents involving rule to realize that infrastructure is indispensable, and she may acquiesce to the problems of tight theocratic rulership a bit too much but she is fully lucid about the implications of every aspect and what the least of many evils is.
The thing about her is that nobody is her intellectual rival except for maybe Dorian, but he doesn't care to challenge her because their worlds are separate except for the great evil that would threaten them both. Remove that aspect and he will still have problems with the Chantry, but his issues with it are separate from anything that anyone else would bring up.
He's smart enough to realize that no revolution or inquisition is going to smoothly and quickly transform a system and faith ingrained in so many people, and trying to slowly change a system while holding it is better than uprooting it, because in doing so you all to quickly become the all more severe form of the very thing you hated most about the old establishment.
You know, I actually never thought about having two mages in my party, but the potential for their banter is so high I might go for it. If I come across a locked door I can always come back later.
lol this brings to mention how when you kill innocent, gentle animals your party shouts things like they are killing darkspawn
*blows up a halla* "ONE DOOOWWNN!!"
I realized how right she was when I took the mage path, left to their own devices the Libertarians took over Redcliffe and invited a Magister- a foreign power into Ferelden. Fiona is god damn stupid.
She understands that the best way for mages to move forward and progress is to strengthen their meager political power and to work to change the status quo by working in it like inviting mages to join the chantry rather than to break away with no plan or consideration for the common citizens. She wants progress which is why she "Greatly Approved" of the suggestion of Chantry-Mage integration, not revolution. Revolution helps no one and makes mages look like assholes even if it's a slim majority taking the libertarian side. I mean, I took the mage origin in DA:O, look at what happened to the Ferelden circle. Were the templars paternalistic and unnecessarily strict? Sure, but who exactly benefited from Jowan's shenanigans to break away with blood magic from the circle? Nobody. That isn't to say that she's perfect though, her dismissal of Solas' theories on Cole and spirits in general are IMO unnecessary.I can't imagine that happening for me, which is why I hope she won't have a pivotal role in any future add-on. I just want to keep ignoring here as I've done so far. If I could choose the main character for new content, Leliana or Dorian would get my vote.