Lot of positive opinions in here right now. Here's a negative one.
This game is so barebones. Finish an event in career, dump back to menu. Finish a single race, dump back to menu. There is no sense of progression at all. I've already got 50 of the 225 total stars after about two hours of play, yet I don't feel like I've really done anything at all. I don't feel like I'm getting anywhere. Every event feels like it carries the same weight. There is no build up. Nothing exciting is going on. If that's a positive to you, fine. If you just want to get back to the racing without being bothered with anything else, fine. I would say the same about myself. But that doesn't mean the game doesn't need character. This game has absolutely zero character.
The fact that the servers are down is terrible. I really, really hope this game feels more alive when the servers come up. For as much as they've touted the social aspect of this game, it must be pretty embarrassing for this to be the situation on launch day. The worst part is that there are cars I can't even unlock, because I can't progress in a club. We all assume the servers will be up any minute, but how often has something like this happened where servers are our for hours, then days, then... Who's to say when any of this will actually work?
Cars crashing into me? Not my fault, but take away some points. So frustrating. Especially when one of the stars on a track is to run a "clean lap," and I've got cars crashing into me totally outside of my control. Screw that.
The graphics and locations are beautiful but I feel like I've already seen everything within the first two hours.
The music...utterly boring. The best thing about this game is that it's gotten me to sign up for Sony's Music Unlimited which actually seems pretty decent. At least I can listen to some music I like as I play now.
It is kind of fun to play. I don't hate it. It just feels so empty. Like this game was made by robots.
One last thing - the character model is so poorly animated and so low-poly that I wonder what's the point of even having it?